Daniel Talia vs James Frawley

[Bailey01]

Talia and StKilda limited his scoring yet he still kicked 2 and had 12 marks 23 disposals. Not many CHFs get those numbers.

Yer ok call it breakeven, Talia limited Riewoldt pretty well than to what he has done the last weeks kicking 10 goals in 3 games.

 

[bigtexan]

Nah talia towled him... Got all his possies up on the wing... After 1/4 time he won the battle...

 

[Go the Guts]

Riewoldt 23 touches 12 marks 5 inside 50's 2 goals.

What constitutes him winning the contest?

Significantly up the ground, a whole lot of that happened nowhere near the forward 50. I'd say that's a win. And as I said, one of those goals was on another player, so Riewoldt only kicked one goal on Talia, which is standard against him. As the Saints no. 1 spearhead, that's a clear win.

 

[Go the Guts]

No matter how you look at it Riewoldt had 12 marks clearly he won his position.

Yeah fair call. His role is to take marks. Well done Riewoldt, you clearly outmarked Talia on the scoreboard.

 

[MiloStedman]

Frawley is looking pretty good up forward for Melbourne. They're in a bit of a situation now in where he'd be equally valuable at both ends of the field.

Perhaps if Chris Dawes can turn himself into a half-competent no. 1 option Frawley can stay down back.

 

[TheRoo32]

Riewoldt is always gonna get a heap of marks. Facts are he got most up on the wing. Talia had it all over him in the forward 50. As for the poll, Talia comfortably. Very rarely gets goals kicked on him