thylacine60
Premium Platinum
- Banned
- #551
completely joking....
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Bilby?Perhaps a wallaby rather than a frog!
Think we are on the same wavelength HBF.
I hope not, although youre right about his inconsistency, i wouldn't wan't to see a huge figure chucked at him to make him stay. Gibbs has been played in many different positions and roles while at Carlton, it makes me wonder if he might of developed better at another club. Maybe Gibbs isn't right for us and we wern't right for gibbsYep.
Of all the players on our list Gibbs frustrates me more than anyone.
Reckon he's our modern version of Fevola. The gap between his best & worst is an absolute chasm.
I really think he'll be somewhere else next season.
Disagree entirely but each to his own. He's been one of our most consistent players this year but clearly I'm one of the few who shares that opinion.Yep.
Of all the players on our list Gibbs frustrates me more than anyone.
Reckon he's our modern version of Fevola. The gap between his best & worst is an absolute chasm.
I really think he'll be somewhere else next season.
Disagree entirely but each to his own. He's been one of our most consistent players this year but clearly I'm one of the few who shares that opinion.
As for those bagging Gibbs because the club put Yarran's contract on hold, how is that Gibbs' fault? Not sure where the contract is at but the decision to put contracts on hold lies entirely with the club. Can understand why Yarran is angry but to take his frustration out on Bryce reeks of immaturity. It's common practice for clubs to do this when signing a player for big $ers.
You can't really say that.Pretty sure the players are pissed at Gibbs because of what his Manager came out and said at the start of the year. Gibbs hasn't said anything to deny this either... He clearly has no faith in the club so why should the club have faith in him kinda thing and put contracts of players who want to be there on hold. I'd be pissed too.
You can't really say that.
He actually has. Swann on SEN before the Essendon game (pretty sure it was the week) was interviewed by Robbo. Robbo asked about Gibbs asking to know our plans. Swann said Gibbs actually didn't ask that & his management did so without his permission. Not to mention the original story was written by a guy who has been banned from Visy due to his inability to write a factual article. Here's the link: listen from 12:40.Why not? His Manager asked the question implying he doesn't... Gibbs hasn't said anything to the contrary
Disagree entirely but each to his own. He's been one of our most consistent players this year but clearly I'm one of the few who shares that opinion.
As for those bagging Gibbs because the club put Yarran's contract on hold, how is that Gibbs' fault? Not sure where the contract is at but the decision to put contracts on hold lies entirely with the club. Can understand why Yarran is angry but to take his frustration out on Bryce reeks of immaturity. It's common practice for clubs to do this when signing a player for big $ers.
Totally agree. Gibbs can be absolutely fantastic when the whole team is the same, but when the chips are down he simply isn't there. If he wants to stay at Carlton and earn some respect amongst the supporters, he needs to run his guts out and put in 100% effort all game, every week, instead of riding on the highs and fading during the lows.One thing you will never see from Gibbs is him being in our best couple of players when we aren't playing well. Take Friday night - how many players could put their hands up and say they played well. Maybe 2-3. He's great when we're winning and he can play as that linkman between the stoppages.
Possibly one the most talented players we have had on our list for the last 20 years, but he just doesn't work hard enough IMO. Shows glimpses here and there, but just doesn't do enough for someone who debuted all the way back in 2007.
Not really true. Was the only Carlton player playing well in the first half of the Richmond final. Whilst Judd was massive in the third, Gibbs was awesome for four quarters. Was BOG for us against Sydney in the rain last year when we lost. Bog against hawthorn when we lost. That's just off the top of my head.One thing you will never see from Gibbs is him being in our best couple of players when we aren't playing well. Take Friday night - how many players could put their hands up and say they played well. Maybe 2-3. He's great when we're winning and he can play as that linkman between the stoppages.
Gibbsy don't lie. It won't be done tomorrow. It will be done on the weekend of round 13.
I really don't like Frawley at $800K per annum, he's a decent player but not that good. I'd be expecting Tom Hawkins for that figure.
As for the rest of the Agents, they can stay where they are !!
Just like Gibbs when the media said he was asking for that much.I think the $800k figure has been disputed by Frawley on a number of occasions.
Just like Gibbs when the media said he was asking for that much.
Hawthorn or Geelong won't pay Frawley that.