Pre-Season 2015/16

Remove this Banner Ad

Billings had a shin splint style injury that eventually turned into hairline fractures. Its the exact type of injury that is "well we give it another week and see how it goes". It seems your entire issue is that the club even gives an idea of time till they return on uncertain injuries.
or there may have been a fracture there that was initially difficult or impossible to diagnose at first, but inflammation and new bone growth make the diagnosis more likely with time. Initially we would make the shin splint call because the balance of probabilities pointed to it, but as time progressed without a resolution of the pain, then other diagnoses must be considered.

Human beings are not machines with a usb plug to access a chip with all the medical data for analysis, we are biological organisms with inherent issues that make medicine problematic. We make a diagnosis based on probabilities, then we treat the patient as if that diagnosis is the issue requiring treatment. Most of the time we are right, but sometimes we are wrong and hopefully we are able to discern that there was a deeper issue in a very timely manner. Sometimes we just have to wait for the body to heal itself. While our club docs are brilliant, they are not infallible, not even the best specialists in the land are perfect. We rely on some very talented specialists to help ensure we are doing the absolute best for our players.

The times to recovery released by the club are not things written in stone, treat them as a best guess
 

Log in to remove this ad.

No. The over entitled who think every fart a player let's go should be analysed and reported on to them by the medical staff would complain that their absolute right as a supporter of the club to know every Nano second a player is likely to be out for was being toyed with and the club was lying to them.
Jesus Christ. The absolute idiocy of some believing that medical staff can predict the future and how a medical condition will turn out is ludicrous.
There is no conspiracy, there is no deception. It is a medical condition FFS.

Get over you perceived and totally undeserved sense of self importance and entitlement.

Perhaps you missed the ;)? I was being facetious.
 
No. The over entitled who think every fart a player let's go should be analysed and reported on to them by the medical staff....
Happy to back the club in on most occasions.

However if they start telling us that someone will miss 2 weeks after exhaling a huge air biscuit, then quite frankly....

... that stinks! :eek:
 
FOX Sports said:
IT’S been two frustrating years for Blake Acres, who has not been able to transfer his blistering VFL form into regular AFL appearances. Injuries have played a role, but now the 190cm midfielder appears primed to cement his spot in Alan Richardson’s best team following an excellent summer on the track. In many ways, the 20-year-old is St Kilda’s most exciting hidden gem.

http://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/nab...l/news-story/9d84e9f779114e1971637b65f50c5aa5

:thumbsu: :thumbsu: :thumbsu:
 
So the Billings 1 week away turned out to be a season, do you want me to find an article of that as well? 2 weeks ago there was an article saying that he would be back in a week and I think I posted it on the players board under Freeman. Go take a look there.

Jack was rested in the hope that the stress issue he was suffering from settled down...it didn't. They let it rest for another few weeks before they announced that his season was done. Sometimes a prognosis isn't accurate despite the expertise of the medical staff.

I'd like you to find an article that says what you are claiming the club 'always' says. That Freeman is 2 weeks away. If one exists that's sweet, my response was that the references that you posted didn't say anything of the sort. I'm not going to trawl through all of your posts to find an article that you could have easily inserted in the first place.

It's a very different regime now that when we were all regularly led astray with the 'A.Hamill- 2 weeks' debacle....they're pretty upfront with injuries. the only time the club can be a bit dodgy is when a player is going through something off field or has been disciplined & they want to keep it in house.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Haha I know it's all fun and games :D. But I will be back with this issue on the 23rd of Feb which it will be exactly 2 week :p:p
You may be torn on this topic. It may be a strain. But it's good to know you are not hamstrung in your ability to return to this thread.

You are afterall, a Free Man :cool:
 
You may be torn on this topic. It may be a strain. But it's good to know you are not hamstrung in your ability to return to this thread.

You are afterall, a Free Man :cool:
Stop trying to muscle in on CALL ME SNAKE's pun territory. He might snap.

Then the board will rupture as posters take sides.
 
Last edited:
You may be torn on this topic. It may be a strain. But it's good to know you are not hamstrung in your ability to return to this thread.

You are afterall, a Free Man :cool:
The strain has taken a lot longer to heal than I thought. Hopefully I can be a free man soon as I can't wait for the nab cup to start in 2 weeks :cool:
 
Haha I know it's all fun and games :D. But I will be back with this issue on the 23rd of Feb which it will be exactly 2 week :p:p
Frankly, I don't think you have a leg to stand on. ;)
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top