kaisasosai
Team Captain
Thanks Clint
Round 17 Trades
- Thread starter skins62
- Start date
- Tagged users None
doona
SMFC
Anyone think Fyfe is 100% gauranteed of bring rested?
- Apr 18, 2012
- 2,960
- 1,465
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Yeah got that feeling too.
Will likely trade beams though... That article about his shoulder being held together with sticky tape/needing surgery freaked me out a bit.
doona
SMFC
I was going to downgrade McKernan (r3)/Upgrade Cripps but as McKernan is playing with a low be, and I want ox my only rook on the field (Fyfe late out, Knights as the e) I am going:
Fyfe > Gazza
Cripps > Malceski
Leaving me with 77k. Plan is Ox to picken next week by downgrading McKernan.
Then a finished team
Only liabilities are Newnes, Gibson, Lynch (adel), Yeo, malceski
Last edited:
doona
SMFC
Solid
- Apr 10, 2010
- 6,659
- 9,184
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- AFC Wimbledon
Any rumour of injury? Huge game for Freo and their last at the MCG before finals, seems like a strange game to miss.
Trades for me I got Gaz last week and think I might miss the Rocky boat so Nicholls > Dahlhaus, moving McKernan into the ruck.
Second trade not sure and not a lot of cash left so thinking I might switch S.Johnson to S.Selwood and leave it at that.
Last edited:
doona
SMFC
He hasnt been training with the main group all week. even today he didnt train. Since the Hawks game (Mitchell) he has been playing with a corky. I cant see them risking him. For me my trades are either:
Mckernan > Downie (R3, so neither playing)
Cripps > Gaz
bank: +33k
or
Fyfe > Gaz
Cripps > Malceski
+77k
I am not taking the risk of needing my M9. Mckernan is playing, a low BE. Cripps needs to go so I think the second trade gives me the best team this week. (Also more cash) and I will still have Mckernan to milk. I want to finish as high up in the rankings and do not want to risk Fyfe.
I think Fyfe will be a late out. We have 2 trades a week so I am going to use them.
Also I have the luxury of being able to do Mckernan > Downie/nakervis next week with not much loss of money seeing as Mckernan is no.1 ruck
- Jun 2, 2014
- 3,011
- 3,321
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
I'm taking a pretty big risk. Have had my trades done since Monday but after the teams have come out I've decided to go unique and not bring in Ablett.
Instead, my trades are
Membrey > Sloane (Lambert Dpp)
Dumont (sick of brad Scott being a shitcampaigner and not naming him) > Knight.
Leaves me with 200k more then if I went with Ablett, and I can focus on completing my last couple of upgrades in the forward line.
Instead, my trades are
Membrey > Sloane (Lambert Dpp)
Dumont (sick of brad Scott being a shitcampaigner and not naming him) > Knight.
Leaves me with 200k more then if I went with Ablett, and I can focus on completing my last couple of upgrades in the forward line.
doona
SMFC
Sloane a bit of a risk. If he dies well, like bartel and a couple of others they are on my radar
Quickfire opinions.
Option A -
Trade B. Smith to Kelly (play Kelly for a few weeks and eventually trade either Kelly or Docherty to Picken when I get the cash. Focus on upgrading Kreuzer, Steele, Wines and Bontemelli in the next few weeks while Kelly makes cash)
Option B - keep B. Smith, downgrade a bench rookie like Fantasia etc and try and bank another 70k. Next week (probably copping some lost money from Smith) try and get the money together with another downgrade to swap Smith to Picken
Option C
Upgrade Wines to the best affordable midfielder. I cant afford Steven or Hannebery so this isnt an enticing option just now.
Option A -
Trade B. Smith to Kelly (play Kelly for a few weeks and eventually trade either Kelly or Docherty to Picken when I get the cash. Focus on upgrading Kreuzer, Steele, Wines and Bontemelli in the next few weeks while Kelly makes cash)
Option B - keep B. Smith, downgrade a bench rookie like Fantasia etc and try and bank another 70k. Next week (probably copping some lost money from Smith) try and get the money together with another downgrade to swap Smith to Picken
Option C
Upgrade Wines to the best affordable midfielder. I cant afford Steven or Hannebery so this isnt an enticing option just now.
- Apr 10, 2010
- 6,659
- 9,184
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- AFC Wimbledon
Could play through the cork after 6 days but not after 13 sounds like ducks and drakes to me.... and on a completely unrelated note going into the weekend with no midfield emergency suddenly seems a bit reckless
Nicholls > Rocky (McKernan to R2)
Dumont > Lambert
Browne (Dons) or Fields (Carlton) to bring in as a rookie defender????
Browne is playing this week and Fields isn't..................worried about cash, will Fields get another gig?
Browne is playing this week and Fields isn't..................worried about cash, will Fields get another gig?
- Apr 18, 2012
- 2,960
- 1,465
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
I'm holding Fyfe and trading Beams to a low BE premo. Not exactly sure who yet
VB -> Knight
BroSmith gets another week at D6 then onto the bench.
hrms...do players scores ever correlate that strong to round?? Going to say no and cross fingers Beams doesn't smash it.
Anyone else noticed The Traders seem to be hitting the red bulls a bit hard lately? Much more intense! Hope they haven't fallen victim to stardom like Benny. (really though, I like it - reckon it's a bit of alcohol and concerted effort to be more exciting)
VB -> Knight
BroSmith gets another week at D6 then onto the bench.
hrms...do players scores ever correlate that strong to round?? Going to say no and cross fingers Beams doesn't smash it.
Anyone else noticed The Traders seem to be hitting the red bulls a bit hard lately? Much more intense! Hope they haven't fallen victim to stardom like Benny. (really though, I like it - reckon it's a bit of alcohol and concerted effort to be more exciting)
Last edited:
Clint Beastwood
Club Legend
I'm holding Fyfe and trading Beams to a low BE premo. Not exactly sure who yet
hrms...do players scores ever correlate that strong to round?? Going to say no and cross fingers Beams doesn't smash it.
Surely not as the opponent would more than likely change....without actually looking one would think it would correlate more strongly with opponent and team composition.
Unless there's people like Birchall (who has always frustrated the hell out of me) who think "oh s**t, round 17, better score 135+ fantasy points just to * with people".
doona
SMFC
I'm holding Fyfe and trading Beams to a low BE premo. Not exactly sure who yet
VB -> Knight
BroSmith gets another week at D6 then onto the bench.
hrms...do players scores ever correlate that strong to round?? Going to say no and cross fingers Beams doesn't smash it.
Anyone else noticed The Traders seem to be hitting the red bulls a bit hard lately? Much more intense! Hope they haven't fallen victim to stardom like Benny. (really though, I like it - reckon it's a bit of alcohol and concerted effort to be more exciting)
I reckon you could pull any round, look at the supercoach stats and find a few relavent players that always ton it up. so it is basically data mining to find a result that suits a pre-determined hypothesis.
- Jun 9, 2010
- 769
- 717
- AFL Club
- Geelong
- Other Teams
- Orlando Magic
Cripps > Jack Steven
Koby Stevens > Dahlhaus
Koby Stevens > Dahlhaus
Malceski or Kelly guys?
Bigfella0417
Draftee
- Apr 23, 2015
- 19
- 1
- AFL Club
- Essendon
farrrk i have fyfe beams and heppel to worry about,who should stay and who should go?
doona
SMFC
I'm tossing between that now for my Cripps trade.
Malceski gets more money for next week. Kelly when fit is the higher DT scorer and will be for the season in my opinion if d6.
But it's what you can do with the money
Last edited:
- Apr 18, 2012
- 2,960
- 1,465
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Fyfe battling a Corky - Coach said he's a certainty to play but they're flying lots of players....so do you trust him? Will it be a long term injury that will hold him back?
Beams shoulder needs surgery and it's more likely to break down as the season goes on - not the kind of thing that gets significantly better after a rest. He's worth $600k - he needs to perform very well. Fyfe is $540k atm.
Can you do something to improve your team next round with that extra cash? It lets me get Hodge.
Just have to go through the reasoning for yourself - weigh up risks - your own team - league/rank importance etc. I've been wrong heaps of times and there's every chance Beams could smash and Fyfe a late out.
Personally I'd sit on Hepp for now.
Slipps
Norm Smith Medallist
- May 25, 2012
- 6,961
- 7,077
- AFL Club
- Richmond
I got kelly two weeks ago for saad he 60 as a sub then 120 his output he can get for his price is pretty good i rekon
