Tom Scully's next contract

[Toump Ass]

Pretty certain he was GWS' number one target.

Unfortunately for them he's fallen drastically short of his potential, and even with a solid 2015 season he's got a long way to go on giving them a fair return on what they've paid for him already.

You'd think he'd take a fairly significant pay cut. Plenty of players at GWS more deserving of the salary cap space than Scully.

 

[Pee Tear Griffin]

Will have to take a huge haircut. He really needs to repay the faith GWS showed him to get him from Melbourne.

The bloke is ugly enough as it is. I think he could do with a bit more growth, actually. Might make him look less like a bullet-headed weasel.

 

[Bollox]

Got no problem with Scully's decision coz it was just a stupid offer.
Has Richmond HBFer written all over him.

What about Rhys Palmer ? Hard to believe he'll be 27. and never even mentioned after the unbelievable 1st yr he had.

 

[Topkent]

And that shows you dont know.

You guys put more than 12 months work into scully and the deal itself has been an abysmal failure

 

[Colonial]

You guys put more than 12 months work into scully and the deal itself has been an abysmal failure

I wasnt saying that it hasnt. Not that i agree with you

Maybe read what i was replying to.

 

[Topkent]

I wasnt saying that it hasnt. Not that i agree with you

Maybe read what i was replying to.

There is no justification though, he was a big failure
Callan Ward should have been paid the money Scully took
Does it matter? No but you cant try and justify it in anyway, he will forever be the highest paid average player ever unless Tom Boyd doesnt develop

 

[Colonial]

There is no justification though, he was a big failure
Callan Ward should have been paid the money Scully took
Does it matter? No but you cant try and justify it in anyway, he will forever be the highest paid average player ever unless Tom Boyd doesnt develop

Who was paid it all in the first couple of years. It didnt effect us in the slightest.
Seems to bug opposition supporters more than Giants fans.

 

[Topkent]

Who was paid it all in the first couple of years. It didnt effect us in the slightest.
Seems to bug opposition supporters more than Giants fans.

Which you could have paid to a future captain instead of a C grade tagger

 

[Sultan]

Which you could have paid to a future captain instead of a C grade tagger

Jordie Mckenzie was never on our list...

 

[HBF]

The bloke is ugly enough as it is. I think he could do with a bit more growth, actually. Might make him look less like a bullet-headed weasel.

Maybe go with something like Ben Brown then..

 

[Colonial]

Which you could have paid to a future captain instead of a C grade tagger

Steele or Hopper hadnt been drafted yet.
Eather way he isnt on that money now. Its worked out exactly how they expected.

Its ok. You dont need to worry about us. We are doing fine.

 

[Topkent]

Jordie Mckenzie was never on our list...

Lucky.... You might have paid him a million a year for his work ethic

 

[Mister Carlton]

Is this one of the rare things melbourne can gloat about

Not really. You ended up drafting him in the first place.

 

[Topkent]

Not really. You ended up drafting him in the first place.

Then got the picks for Jesse Hogan for him....

 

[Marc_Remillard]

Scully has been very successful, he's an average talent but managed to get $6m over 6 years out of GWS and get his dad an overpaying job as well.

Regardless of what you think of him as a player you have to respect him for that, essentially he has set up the rest of his life.

/respect

 

[Theo X]

Scully has been very successful, he's an average talent but managed to get $6m over 6 years out of GWS and get his dad an overpaying job as well.

Regardless of what you think of him as a player you have to respect him for that, essentially he has set up the rest of his life.

/respect

Right place at the right time.

 

[JackFlash]

Trade him to Carlton at the end of 2016.

 

[Sultan]

Lucky.... You might have paid him a million a year for his work ethic

Very lucky, just another thing you'd be having a teary about.

 

[Topkent]

Very lucky, just another thing you'd be having a teary about.

Losing Scully could end up one of the greatest things that ever happened to the MFC

 

[TwentyNine]

He actually had a decent season this year and if he keeps up that level or improves further, a contract around the $400,000 mark per year would be about fair I think. That's probably with the Giants but there are other clubs who might be able to offer him a more prominent role.

 

[Giant Pete]

Losing Scully could end up one of the greatest things that ever happened to the MFC

Yet you wouldn't think that if we just went off the drivel you've been posting.