Herald Sun SuperCoach 2008

[Athomas]

Hayes played almost every game last year , unless you mean he got injured again (not as far as I know)?

And hasn't impressed me yet.

 

[Athomas]

Id go dal santo + armitage

Very tempted to do that as well.
Extremely tempted.

But 2 Saints Midfielders?
Had Dal Santo all last year.

 

[sdsdsdsd]

Very tempted to do that as well.
Extremely tempted.

But 2 Saints Midfielders?
Had Dal Santo all last year.

Its StKildas year this year, also i dont think armitage will break the team on a regular basis, id much rather go McNamara and use the left over $ to upgrade murphy to foley

 

[Athomas]

Its StKildas year this year, also i dont think armitage will break the team on a regular basis, id much rather go McNamara and use the left over $ to upgrade murphy to foley

I'll have heaps of cash anyway after the trades.
I'd prefer Murphy over Foley.

McNamara might not play Round 1, but then again Armitage might not either.

 

[Virgil]

I'll have heaps of cash anyway after the trades.
I'd prefer Murphy over Foley.

McNamara might not play Round 1, but then again Armitage might not either.

What makes you say that, I'd've thought he'd be close to being best 18 all season.

 

[sdsdsdsd]

I'll have heaps of cash anyway after the trades.
I'd prefer Murphy over Foley.

McNamara might not play Round 1, but then again Armitage might not either.

McNamara played at the end of last year in the final vs collingwood which shows that they trust the kid, i think he has a better chance at west coast than armitage at stkilda

 

[foxy_dal]

Armitage will probably play round 1 but i would think he would lose his spot aftre a few games especially once baker is back from suspension. Geary ahead of him atm according to some.

 

[SAINTS 4 07 FLAG]

why is masten more than mcnamara ?? thats werid

 

[SAINTS 4 07 FLAG]

who would people get out of Montagna,Hayes,Swan,Lockyer or Carrazo ??

 

[Athomas]

Armitage's Averages are ahead of McNamara but only pre season.

Eagles team lists might JUST be up by Lock out.

 

[Pie Legend]

who would people get out of Montagna,Hayes,Swan,Lockyer or Carrazo ??

im thinkin that as well

ATM, i hav Swan and Cross, but i dno

 

[sdsdsdsd]

who would people get out of Montagna,Hayes,Swan,Lockyer or Carrazo ??

Have faith in ur team go lenny

 

[Hard Ball Get]

I'm really struggling with the Gibbs Vs Griffin decision at the moment.

It looks as though with my current set up I will have one of them in the side. They are the same price and both have plenty of upside.

I'm a little clouded by my love for Griff and my unenthusiasm over Gibbs though.

 

[Athomas]

I'm really struggling with the Gibbs Vs Griffin decision at the moment.

It looks as though with my current set up I will have one of them in the side. They are the same price and both have plenty of upside.

I'm a little clouded by my love for Griff and my unenthusiasm over Gibbs though.

How many dogs players do you have?

If 2 or less then go Griffen.

 

[westies]

Help need Guys, Tell me What you think?

Backs: Shaw, Ladson, Johncock, Walker, Nash, Ellis, Nicoski:
res proud/Hansen

Mids: Goodes, Hayes, Thompson, Stanton, Stevens, Houli:
res Tuck/Proud

Rucks: Kosi, Simmonds
res Leuenberger/Meesen

Ford: Franklin, Fevola, Hall, Murphy, Didak, Monfries, Hawkins:
res Henderson/Tippett

$162,000 left in the bank

 

[Hard Ball Get]

How many dogs players do you have?

If 2 or less then go Griffen.

I don't subscribe to that theory.

I don't think it really matters hoy many players you have from one side (within reason)

 

[foxy_dal]

Help need Guys, Tell me What you think?

Backs: Shaw, Ladson, Johncock, Walker, Nash, Ellis, Nicoski:
res proud/Hansen

Mids: Goodes, Hayes, Thompson, Stanton, Stevens, Houli:
res Tuck/Proud

Rucks: Kosi, Simmonds
res Leuenberger/Meesen

Ford: Franklin, Fevola, Hall, Murphy, Didak, Monfries, Hawkins:
res Henderson/Tippett

$162,000 left in the bank

Not the worst i have seen, you said Proud twice and i don't think he is listed as a centre. Downgrade Luenberger to Hampson and use the extra cash to fix up your backline. Just a few things that might help.

 

[Pie Legend]

I don't subscribe to that theory.

I don't think it really matters hoy many players you have from one side (within reason)

Agreed, unless u hav 3 + in the same position

 

[sdsdsdsd]

Help need Guys, Tell me What you think?

Backs: Shaw, Ladson, Johncock, Walker, Nash, Ellis, Nicoski:
res proud/Hansen

Mids: Goodes, Hayes, Thompson, Stanton, Stevens, Houli:
res Tuck/Proud

Rucks: Kosi, Simmonds
res Leuenberger/Meesen

Ford: Franklin, Fevola, Hall, Murphy, Didak, Monfries, Hawkins:
res Henderson/Tippett

$162,000 left in the bank

people in bold i dont really like, i would chuck kozi in the forward line and get cox

 

[sdsdsdsd]

Do u guys think that Johnstone a good pickup at 430k and pierce at 400k?

 

[Athomas]

I don't subscribe to that theory.

I don't think it really matters hoy many players you have from one side (within reason)

I don't really subscribe to that theroy unless it's your team.
Which in your case it is.

I have 4 Eagles in my 22 atm.
Trying to make it 3. Argh.

 

[westies]

Not the worst i have seen, you said Proud twice and i don't think he is listed as a centre. Downgrade Luenberger to Hampson and use the extra cash to fix up your backline. Just a few things that might help.

Cheers for that, Bird is my other mid res

 

[westies]

people in bold i dont really like, i would chuck kozi in the forward line and get cox

Any reason why you don't like them?

 

[sdsdsdsd]

Any reason why you don't like them?

Just think theres better players for that value, hayes, gilbee, n brown, deledio etc

 

[smmorrow]

people in bold i dont really like, i would chuck kozi in the forward line and get cox

Don't like Goodes?

He's one of the first choices for me when it comes to underpriced guns.