The official "X v Y" thread

[DeadlyAkkuret]

Anthony
Beams
Otten
Rich
Robinson

Alphabetical?

Lol

 

[Roos4eva]

Foley

Griffen is to inconsistent

How about if getting Griffen resulted in changing J Brown for Deledio?

 

[Teak_Pies]

Anyone
Didak vs Fevola vs Roughhead vs S Johnson ?

J Brown vs chappy?

 

[Hawkers Hero]

Already have Fev and Im tossing up between Stevie J and Roughead myself - cant split them

If I had to choose 1 from the 4 though Id go with Fev without a doubt - huge year coming up IMO

 

[Teak_Pies]

What about J Brown vs Chappy

 

[Speck]

Brown for me. I have Chapman but his hammies are suspect and Brown is due for a big year.

Petrenko or Dawson for emergency? This could matter as S Hill may not play.

 

[Teak_Pies]

Petrenko, he is definitely playing

 

[trossa]

N Krakouer or Skipworth? Skipworth is named on the extended bench for R1

 

[Teak_Pies]

S Johnson vs Fevola.

 

[alternatevista]

N Krakouer or Skipworth? Skipworth is named on the extended bench for R1

Sam Newman reckons Skipworth is going to win the game for them, so go him.

 

[Cudi]

For my second emergency:

Suban Vs Broughton

Broughton has not been named and Suban has on the extended bench

 

[Windas_Magic]

N Krakouer or Skipworth? Skipworth is named on the extended bench for R1

Skipworth WILL play

 

[alternatevista]

S Johnson vs Fevola.

Fev is due for a good year I think.

For my second emergency:

Suban Vs Broughton

Broughton has not been named and Suban has on the extended bench

Pretty much answered yourself. Do you want a player that has no chance of playing, or a slim chance of playing?

 

[Fitty]

Nathan Krakeour or Hentchel?

and

Sam Fisher or Chris Newman?

Someone help me out

 

[Stanton_Legend]

Nathan Krakeour or Hentchel?

and

Sam Fisher or Chris Newman?

Someone help me out

Hentschel and Fisher

 

[Windas_Magic]

Nathan Krakeour or Hentchel?

and

Sam Fisher or Chris Newman?

Someone help me out

Not sure with the first one but i would go with Fisher over Newman.

Beams V Robinson?

I know Robinson has been selected to play tonight but will he hold his spot in the team?

 

[Pendles!]

Not sure with the first one but i would go with Fisher over Newman.

Beams V Robinson?

I know Robinson has been selected to play tonight but will he hold his spot in the team?

i had the same problem and then decided Danger..

Suban, Broughton or Cheney?

 

[freo grover]

Petterd V Hurley????

 

[Goosecat]

I need a 83k or 94k bench defender to replace Broughton who fremantle hasn't put in their round 1 squad. I've already got Petrenko. Any suggestions?

 

[SnappyHappy]

Suckling. Not sure if he will get a game all year though?

Skipworth + Bartel

OR

Ziebell + Ablett

 

[Baxter23]

Suckling. Not sure if he will get a game all year though?

Skipworth + Bartel

OR

Ziebell + Ablett

The 2nd for sure

 

[SnappyHappy]

Troy Simmonds OR Brad Ottens

 

[SJ]

Troy Simmonds OR Brad Ottens

Ottens.

 

[BIGANT]

Cuz
& vs !?!?
Raines

 

[MightyRoar]

The 2nd for sure

All depends whether or not u think Ziebell is going 2 play much this year. If he does then I'd say the 2nd......on the other choice tho I think Skipworth will b given every opportunity this year and between Bartel and Ablett well u can toss a coin in my opinion!! So really much of a muchness......ya not gunna loose out on either option!!

Now as I have been F@#ked in the ass from injuries already wat r peoples thoughts on the following at this stage....obviously alot will depend on who goes well from the weekends matches;

Raines out 4 Geary or Pettard

Cosuins out 4 Hayes or Murphy M.