2010 AFC Drafting Game - Who had the best team?

[BACCS]

Now that the season is well and truly over, it is probably a good time to make judgements of each other's teams.

Here they all are again:

Wall-e's Warriors:
B: Johncock - Thornton - Frawley
HB: Hurn - Hurley - Kennelly
C: Sidebottom - Ablett - Grimes
HF: Hartlett - Kennedy - Mundy
F: Rioli - Koschitzke - Gumbleton
R: Ryder - Higgins - Cotchin
I: Moran - Yarran - Shuey - Russell

Emrg: Richards - Harding - Joseph - Wright

Roo2macca's team
B: Heritier O'Brien Tayte Pears Greg Broughton
HB: Paul Duffield Mitch Brown Adam Selwood
C: Jason Winderlich Marc Murphy Brent Moloney
HF: Ryan O'Keefe Nick Riewoldt (C) Brad Johnson
F: Stephen Milne Jesse White Trent Hentschel
R: David Hille Bernie Vince Brad Sewell (VC)
I: Dayne Beams Marcus Drum Cameron Wood Luke McGuane
EMG: Ben Cunnington Rory Sloane Daniel Pratt Jack Redden

Crowsarethebest team
FB: ----H.Shaw------D.Fletcher-------P.Bower----
CHB:---J.Kelly-------N.Maxwell------S.Goodwin
C:------M.McVeigh----L.Hayes-------C.Morton
CHF:---D.Wells-------J.Brown--------P.Chapman
FF:-----M.Morton-------B.Hall--------L.Davis
RR:----M.Gardiner----S.Black--------B.Cousins

Bench:L.Hansen------W.Minson-----D.Headland-------S.O'Bree

EMG:B. Waters----K.Reimers------A.Rance----T.Scully

BACCS Brigade :
B: McGrath - Rutten - J. Macdonald
HB: Enright - Patfull - Gram
C: Embley(VC) - Sylvia - Simpson
HF: Ziebell - Petrie - Sherman
F: Monfries - Lecras - Osborne
R: Clark - Swallow(C) - Cross
I: Prismall - Welsh - Suban - Mcglynn

EMG: Mayne - Greenwood- Dennis-Lane - Warren

The NY Assclowns : (Kristof's team)

FF: Liam Jurrah , Quinten Lynch , Jared Brennan
CHF: Alan Didak , Buddy Franklin , Richard Tambling
C: Leigh Montagna , Dane Swan , Ryan Griffen
CHB: Farren Ray , Sam Fisher , Tarkyn Lockyer
FB: Stephen Hill , Lewis Roberts-Thomson , Troy Chaplin

1st R: Josh Fraser , Jobe Watson , Jude Bolton

RES: Steven Salopek , Tyrone Vickery , Andrew Walker , Dustin Martin

EMER: Kelvin Moore , David Armitage , Ben McEvoy , Nathan Jones

Riggy's Raticates:

F: J.Watts - B.McKinley - D.Motlop
HF: S.Byrnes - J.Riewoldt - J.Akermanis
C: L.Power - D.Cassisi - J.Trengove
HB: A.McLeod - C.Bolton - R.Shaw
B: J.Rivers - B.Lake - H.Slatterry
R: D.Brogan - J.Bartel - P.Dangerfield
INT: Al.Davey - B.Symes - S.Taylor - L.Picken
EMG: C.Bird - A.Morabito - D.Stewert - P. Davis
Ams4crows's team
B: Scott McMahon / Scott Thompson(K) / Jason Blake
HB: Darren Milburn / Harry Taylor / Brendan Goddard
C: Brent Stanton / Brett Kirk / Paul Hasleby
HF: Mitch Hahn / Matthew Pavlich / Liam Anthony
F: Matt Campbell / Daniel Bradshaw / Adam Schneider
R: Hamish McIntosh / Matthew Boyd / Scott Thompson(A)
Int. Jamie Charman / Shane Tuck / Ricky Dyson / Heath Scotland
Emg. Gary Rohan / Brett Burton / Benjamin Speight / Andrew McQualter

Colin D'Cops' Superstars

B: L. Gilbee / D. Glass / C. Newman
HB: G. Birchall / J. Waite / A. McPhee
C: C. Bateman / J. Corey / C. Bruce
HF: M. Bate / C. Cornes / B. Staker
F: T. Varcoe / B. Fevola / A. Buchanan
R: D. Cox / J. Lewis / M. Priddis
I/C: S. Mumford / A. Carrazzo / D. Myers / C. Young

EMG: M. Seaby / M. Stokes / R. Tarrant / R. Ladson

Ringo200's Stars :
B: Adcock Merett Hargrave
HB: Hodge Grundy Drummond
C: Jack Mitchell Aa. Davey
HF: S. Johnson Mooney Nahas
F: B. Harvey Hawkins T. Walker
R: Hudson Judd Jackson
Int. Hampson Polkinghorne Hooker Lew. Jetta
Emg. Jamison McKernan Rodan Schoenmakers

KungFu's Pandas :
B: Sam Gilbert, Chris Tarrant, Jarrad Harbrow
HB: Brad Dalziell, Dale Morris, Jarrad McVeigh
C: Bryce Gibbs, Brock McLean, Scott Pendlebury
HF: Brett Deledio, Luke McPharlin, Daniel Giansiracusa
F: Brad Green, Justin Westhoff, Robbie Gray
R: Aaron Sandilands (VC), Cameron Ling (C), Adam Cooney
I: Todd Goldstein, Callan Ward, Michael Johnson, Matt Rosa
E: Richard Douglas, Nick Salter, Shaun Grigg, Lindsay Thomas

crows98's team
FF: Henderson ~ Tippett ~ Porplyzia
HF: Hooper ~ Tredrea ~ Medhurst
C: Masten ~ K. Cornes ~ Pearce
HB: Mackie ~ Dawson ~ Doughty
FB: Firrito ~ Scarlett ~ Gibson
Ruck: Leuenberger ~ Kerr ~ Boak
Interchange: Lobbe ~ Robinson ~ Everett ~ Ballantyne
Emer: Rusling ~ Griffin ~ Hitchcock ~ Wonaeamirri

cammo84's team
FF: M. Kreuzer ~ J. Anthony ~ M. Williams
HF: J. Hill ~ J. Roughead (HAW) ~ C. Knights
C: D. Rich ~ L. Ball ~ D. Mackay
HB: N. Van Berlo ~ N. Bock ~ M. Mattner
FB: J. Surjan ~ A. Carlile ~ S. Gilham
Ruck: N. Naitanui ~ S. Burgoyne ~ T. Edwards
INT: I. Maric ~ C. Jones (STK) ~ S. Stevens ~ T. Swift
EMG: N. Krakouer ~ G. Urquhart ~ J. Schulz ~ B. Dick


Campbell's Chunky team -
B: Roger Hayden Simon Presti, Campbell Brown
HB: Xavier Ellis Tom Williams Brad Ebert
C: Adam Goodes Joel Selwood Travis Johnstone
HF: Dale Thomas Travis Cloke Max Rooke
F: Robert Murphy Brad Ottens Eddie Betts
R: Darren Jolly Nick Dal Santo Nathan Foley

Interchange: Rhys Palmer, James Gwilt, Steven King, Nathan J Brown (Coll)

Emergencies: Patrick Veszpremi, David Zaharakis, Easton Wood, Tom Rockliff

I personally think Wall-e and roo2macca had the two best all round teams, with most of their players living up to pre season expectations. Wall-e just wins out for me though. So, what are your thoughts?

Mine was bad, I know.

 

[Dirty Bird]

Mine was bad, I know.

You think yours is bad?
look down a few
thank god I have the Coleman medalist to carry my team over the line!

ps - I think I'm going to go with Crows are the best

 

[TubbsFarquhar]

Is there going to be a game this year? I would've thought it would've started by now. I hope there is because it was a good way of chewing some time away in the off-season last year.

 

[ringo200]

I'd be up for it again if we have it.

 

[cammo84]

I can quite safely say mine was the worst team of the lot. At least 10 of my 25 either had injury-plagued seasons or just didn't get game time. Who would've thought a 50 goal forward in Anthony would struggle to get game time? I picked Bock and Roughead with my first two picks, big mistake. For some reason, I thought I was getting a huge bargain when I got Mark Williams late in the draft. Shows what I know about footy!

I voted for Kristof, his centre line caught my eye: C: Leigh Montagna , Dane Swan , Ryan Griffen. Had Buddy, Hill, Didak, plus Dustin Martin on the bench - that team would have won plenty of games. No decent ruckmen though, but the midfield would have been unstoppable.

Not gonna bother next year, too much effort. Will watch with a keen interest though.

 

[Mego Red]

I'm in.

 

[Mego Red]

Anyone want to send around some PM's inviting folks to join? I'd be up for a start around the 26th or 27th.

 

[alex_is_on_fire]

I'd like to join in. Sounds like fun

 

[TubbsFarquhar]

Anyone want to send around some PM's inviting folks to join? I'd be up for a start around the 26th or 27th.

I'm not even sure if the game is going ahead, Kung Fu usually runs it and he hasn't started a thread on it yet.

 

[KUNG FU]

Hey guys. Good to hear there's a bit of enthusiasm for this again. Unfortunately I'm in no position to run it or participate again this year. Hopefully someone puts their hand up to run it. It's real simple and not too time consuming, just a lot of Ctrl + C & Ctrl + V really, very few PMs if everyone does their part and a log on once a day.

On a personal note, my team was a hunk of shit, but I'm very happy with my selections of Douglas (second year in a row I picked our B&F smoky with a very good value selection at #297, having picked up Vince last year at #192). Goldstein was another I was happy he went on with it.

Good luck & happy holidays.

 

[TubbsFarquhar]

Hey guys. Good to hear there's a bit of enthusiasm for this again. Unfortunately I'm in no position to run it or participate again this year. Hopefully someone puts their hand up to run it. It's real simple and not too time consuming, just a lot of Ctrl + C & Ctrl + V really, very few PMs if everyone does their part and a log on once a day.

On a personal note, my team was a hunk of shit, but I'm very happy with my selections of Douglas (second year in a row I picked our B&F smoky with a very good value selection at #297, having picked up Vince last year at #192). Goldstein was another I was happy he went on with it.

Good luck & happy holidays.

I'll be more than happy to run it this year. Doesn't appear to be too difficult to run. Just a lot of updating on picks. I'll probably start the thread on the 26th.

 

[BACCS]

I'll be more than happy to run it this year. Doesn't appear to be too difficult to run. Just a lot of updating on picks. I'll probably start the thread on the 26th.

I probably won't be on tomorrow, but I'm in.

 

[Mego Red]

Looking forward to it. Do we have ten teams? R2M might want to pm some of last year's folks.

 

[TubbsFarquhar]

Looking forward to it. Do we have ten teams? R2M might want to pm some of last year's folks.

Normally, Kung Fu started the thread and people posted saying that they were happy to join. I might just try my luck with that at first. We're looking at a minimum of 12 teams and a maximum of about 20.