List Mgmt. We Got Him! Beams Trade Discussion (Not the Hype Thread)

[loyallion]

I always thought that a Drafted Player automatically got a 2 year Contract ( Well first rounders Anyway)

 

[cheekyLionsFan]

Yep they cant leave for 2 years but we can trade after 1

 

[jackess]

Is Aish a free agent yet?

 

[Ironmonger]

" (e) Drafted Player Bound for 23 Months
(i) Subject to Rule 6.2(e)(ii), any Player selected by a Club at the National Draft Selection Meeting or otherwise included on the Primary List of a Club, shall be ineligible to be included on the Primary List of any other Club for a period of 23 months from the date upon which he is selected or included on the Primary List."

Immediately below that it says that that rule doesn't apply when the player is 'exchanged under rule 9', effectively meaning it doesn't apply if they're traded.

The intent of that section is to stop players from nominating for the draft and then deciding they'd rather wait a year and see who takes them next.

 

[cheekyLionsFan]

Yep. Replied with that

 

[Bucking Beads]

Should Pies fans still be squawking Crazy Vossy when they've got Buckley doing a number on their club??

 

[iBeng]

I wouldn't be against us taking Sewell for a few years, Ala when we got Moloney

 

[jackess]

Sewell is finished. Can barely run. Has no upside apart from leadership.

 

[Simba Moyo]

Can't wait for this trade to go through so I can stop hearing the ludicrous delusions of grandeur from Collingwood supporters rambling about trade hypothetical involving Aish/Redden etc and how 'clever' Gold Coast are.

Plus, the added benefit of seeing Dayne in a Lions kit for the first time

 

[Football Pope]

Should Pies fans still be squawking Crazy Vossy when they've got Buckley doing a number on their club??

Welcome to Star Bucks.......

 

[John]

I think some of us should get off our highhorse until the trade actually happens. Gloating over something that has not happened is fraught with danger.

 

[chopperduck]

Especially banging on about Pick 4 is fair and all you'll get. We all know the end deal will be more than that. Anyone who feels we got ripped off or overpaid either really haven't seen Beams play much or put way too much stock in draft picks. I'd do picks 4,25 and Crisp 9am Monday if the Pies agreed to it. 4 and 25 to turn Crisp in Beams is a worth it every day of the week and twice during trade period. I'm far from convinced that Crisp is the next Brownlow medalist based off 4 or 5 games.

 

[Betty Noir]

I think some of us should get off our highhorse until the trade actually happens. Gloating over something that has not happened is fraught with danger.

I agree. Pick 24, Merrett AND Polkinghorne for Pendlebury AND Beams... and that's IT...take it or leave it.

 

[Big Sauce 21]

I agree. Pick 24, Merrett AND Polkinghorne for Pendlebury AND Beams... and that's IT...take it or leave it.

Reckon we could chuck in Hawksley to sweeten it

 

[SpartanLion]

 

[Viceregal]

Reckon we could chuck in Hawksley to sweeten it

Don't rate SOS?

 

[Big Lion]

Pick 4/5, Merrett and Crisp should get it done.

 

[mike123]

Pick 4/5, Merrett and Crisp should get it done.

If you use a third club. We don't need Crisp or Merrett.

 

[carnthemlions]

I think some of us should get off our highhorse until the trade actually happens. Gloating over something that has not happened is fraught with danger.

That's if it actually happens(there's always room for one of the three parties involved to **** things up).

 

[Big Sauce 21]

If you use a third club. We don't need Crisp or Merrett.

Doubt Collingwood would turn that down

 

[mike123]

Doubt Collingwood would turn that down

Well we will, unless there is a third party involved. Crisp and Merrett won't be in our best 22.

 

[Big Lion]

If you use a third club. We don't need Crisp or Merrett.

Who do you have in mind? Dangerfield? Will be very hard to get. Let me guess the trade goes like this Dangerfield to pies, we get Beams, Adelaide get pick4/5 and Aish.

 

[Big Lion]

Well we will, unless there is a third party involved. Crisp and Merrett won't be in our best 22.

Surely you jest, Merrett would be straight in. Not trying to be rude but have you even seen Crisp play?

 

[Football Pope]

If you use a third club. We don't need Crisp or Merrett.

Yeah,...but if we trade Essendon to you...who do you play Anzac Day?

 

[Big Sauce 21]

Well we will, unless there is a third party involved. Crisp and Merrett won't be in our best 22.

Time to stop being delusional, Hanley, Rockliff, Zorko etc wont happen. Collingwood will have to deal with a similar trade if not less. GC wont offer much more. Don't know why your fans are flogging themselves over Jesse Lonergan, No better than Crisp and has already had soft tissue injuries.