List Mgmt. 2014 Draft Trade FA Megathread

[TheLastEmperor]

The Mccartin thing worries me a bit
Lever done an ACL?? Too risky

Lever has missed the entire season recovering from an ACL. He's rated from his output last year as a bottom-ager. I think the chance of a player doing an ACL if they've already had an ACL is something like 20%. It can be a big risk. Jon Patton case in point.

 

[lethalsaints]

Feeling thoroughly underwhelmed with this trade period after all the talk of being aggressive with our salary cap space. Not one trade.

Maybe the Stanley thing is a backup to get a third pick. In case the trade of 1 for two top 10 picks doesn't eventuate.

 

[Stewart66]

Is that for real?
Even if it is I think teams that can have just one dedicated ruck will do better by being able to bench four of the hardest runners.

Hawthorn just won the flag with 2 Ruckman both not quick .

The problem is not about for Rhys is Longer is an aggressive monster at centre clearances will only get better.
Stkilda clearly think Hickey is better also around stoppages with 2nd & 3 efforts .

 

[lethalsaints]

Lever has missed the entire season recovering from an ACL. He's rated from his output last year as a bottom-ager. I think the chance of a player doing an ACL if they've already had an ACL is something like 20%. It can be a big risk. Jon Patton case in point.

Not a good sign at a young age, as a bottom 3 club I don't think we can afford that risk

 

[Barrels]

Hes looking the ace in the lower pack

Yep, but again; he won't get past Carlscum at pick 19, so...

 

[lethalsaints]

Yep, but again; he won't get past Carlscum at pick 19, so...

Hurry up and trade 19 Carlton. Man I hate them so bad...
My old man and brother barrack for them, tried to force me to do the same.

 

[Hayes4PM]

SOMEBODY DO SOMETHING. At least we still have pick 1 I guess

 

[Barrels]

Hurry up and trade 19 Carlton. Man I hate them so bad...
My old man and brother barrack for them, tried to force me to do the same.

Even if it's not the Scum, the Injectors are passingly interested at #20...

 

[Baughb]

Hurry up and trade 19 Carlton. Man I hate them so bad...
My old man and brother barrack for them, tried to force me to do the same.

Child abuse.

 

[SK_MD_#7]

How does Matt Sully feel about your man love for Reece McKenzie, Barrels?

you're doing the rounds.....

 

[lethalsaints]

Child abuse.

They've been pretty quiet for the last decade. My brother gave me heaps when Bris beat us.
He went into hiding when GWS rolled the blue maggots

 

[Barrels]

How does Matt Sully feel about your man love for Reece McKenzie, Barrels?

you're doing the rounds.....

Would still rookie Sully though... We do need another KPD...

 

[CALL ME SNAKE]

The Mccartin thing worries me a bit
Lever done an ACL?? Too risky

Brett Stewart - NRL Manly, AUST & NSW State of origin player

Dale Weightman- 274 games Rich. VIC team 20 times.

Sir Steve Redgrave- Rowing Gold medals at 5 consecutive Olympic games.

All type 1 diabetics. ( plenty more can be named as well )
Dont worry

 

[lethalsaints]

Brett Stewart - NRL Manly, AUST & NSW State of origin player

Dale Weightman- 274 games Rich. VIC team 20 times.

Sir Steve Redgrave- Rowing Gold medals at 5 consecutive Olympic games.

All type 1 diabetics. ( plenty more can be named as well )
Dont worry

I know I worry too much and overreact.
We cant afford to get to wrong is all

 

[sixtosaint]

Brett Stewart - NRL Manly, AUST & NSW State of origin player

Dale Weightman- 274 games Rich. VIC team 20 times.

Sir Steve Redgrave- Rowing Gold medals at 5 consecutive Olympic games.

All type 1 diabetics. ( plenty more can be named as well )
Dont worry

Raphael clarke to

 

[tbarker]

I hate to say it but Essendon will be our major challenger for pick 1 in the drafts next year.

Would spew for weeks on end if they finished last because of their blatant cheating & then got Boyd with pick 1.

Jeez - hadn't thought of that one. Surely not.

 

[lethalsaints]

Raphael clarke to

 

[bird_man]

Can't say I'm against trading Stanley, not too fussed either way, but I think it would make more sense to trade Armitage. He is 2 years older, would get us a higher draft pick and most importantly, we have the cattle coming through that can replace him in the midfield.

 

[BrianSpeaking]

We are holding out for Freos first pick, a 50-50 chance they buy Rhys with it.
Personally I'm happy with Paddy or Petracca if we keep one, I just think Brayshaw has a limited ceiling and think that TMP is a little 'timid'.
If we take 4 and 7 I'd go LaVerde at 4 in a heartbeat and Lever at 7.

 

[lethalsaints]

13. Fremantle

 

[saintsrfreak]

Can't say I'm against trading Stanley, not too fussed either way, but I think it would make more sense to trade Armitage. He is 4 years older, would get us a higher draft pick and most importantly, we have the cattle coming through that can replace him in the midfield.

*2 years older

 

[lethalsaints]

We are holding out for Freos first pick, a 50-50 chance they buy Rhys with it.
Personally I'm happy with Paddy or Petracca if we keep one, I just think Brayshaw has a limited ceiling and think that TMP is a little 'timid'.
If we take 4 and 7 I'd go LaVerde at 4 in a heartbeat and Lever at 7.

At least 13 has value

 

[bird_man]

*2 years older

Sorry, I meant to write 3, but I still would have been wrong.

 

[Barrels]

Raphael clarke to

too*

 

[sverik25]

Whilst I realise other clubs' supporters will see pick 21 as overs for Stanley, I'm not sure I want us to let him go for that. (Having said that I would definitely do it for pick 14).

As others have said, Rhys has finally been able to play an injury free year in his best position and we are just starting to see the benefits of that. I have this horrible feeling that he will go to Geelong and be a very useful player for them.

Also, my Dad is a Geelong supporter and hopes Stanley doesn't end up at the Cattery.

Can't we both just be happy: St Kilda keeps Stanley and Geelong keeps pick 21.

Then I'm happy and my dad is happy.

Sounds like Rhys is gone though.