2015; Player X or Player Y or Player Z

[Lums23]

Witts *coll vs Hickey *stk

I'd strongly consider going one short on principle over picking ****-Witts

 

[Double the Fist]

I'd strongly consider going one short on principle over picking ****-Witts

Ummm... there is something I am not getting? A gag? He's no good?

I'm confused!

 

[Lums23]

Ummm... there is something I am not getting? A gag? He's no good?

I'm confused!

It was a joke. He's not much chop, so the joke was that I would rather have no one...

 

[Double the Fist]

It was a joke. He's not much chop, so the joke was that I would rather have no one...

Sorry.

 

[JPod_31]

Josh Kelly v Botempelli

 

[PoopingHindi]

Witts *coll vs Hickey *stk

Hickey. i've been considering him myself
my main concern is that the new ruck scoring will hurt him and he doesnt do a lot of the other things that will earn you SC points.
...then theres the knee and foot problems he had last year. and i dont think he's fully fit yet

that said, i've still got him penciled in at R2

 

[Conz9]

Considering Dane Swans popularity, would it be crazy to go with a Dale Thomas, Jack Ziebell, Higgins, Wright, Bonts, taylor adams or basically anyone else at the 400k mark and save yourself some cash + uniqueness??? also hypothetically, which of these options is likely to score the highest?? thanks hahaha

 

[MightyMark]

Considering Dane Swans popularity, would it be crazy to go with a Dale Thomas, Jack Ziebell, Higgins, Wright, Bonts, taylor adams or basically anyone else at the 400k mark and save yourself some cash + uniqueness??? also hypothetically, which of these options is likely to score the highest?? thanks hahaha

There is a reason he is popular. Could end up behind the eight ball taking a risk with guys like Adams or Ziebell.

 

[TN25]

Considering Dane Swans popularity, would it be crazy to go with a Dale Thomas, Jack Ziebell, Higgins, Wright, Bonts, taylor adams or basically anyone else at the 400k mark and save yourself some cash + uniqueness??? also hypothetically, which of these options is likely to score the highest?? thanks hahaha

Yes it would be crazy, Swan is a proven scorer and will score much more than those mentioned

I'd say Bontempelli would score the most out of those though, plenty of midfield time and I doubt he'll get tagged

 

[SureBuddy]

Considering Dane Swans popularity, would it be crazy to go with a Dale Thomas, Jack Ziebell, Higgins, Wright, Bonts, taylor adams or basically anyone else at the 400k mark and save yourself some cash + uniqueness??? also hypothetically, which of these options is likely to score the highest?? thanks hahaha

Yea I am not sold on Swan, he bloody burnt me so hard last year and it still keeps me up at night!

Ziebell maybe... Thomas maybe.... Higgins maybe.... Actually I think all the players you listed could potentially average 95-100, but could easily aeverage 75-80. All risky options.

Another risky option, thoughts on Cloke returning to form this year? Is bloody dirty cheap and has hopefully a fit and able Jesse White offering some assistance.

 

[Lums23]

Considering Dane Swans popularity, would it be crazy to go with a Dale Thomas, Jack Ziebell, Higgins, Wright, Bonts, taylor adams or basically anyone else at the 400k mark and save yourself some cash + uniqueness??? also hypothetically, which of these options is likely to score the highest?? thanks hahaha

Keep in mind, it's only really worth having a POD if they're going to score as well if not better than the popular player

 

[rocker_oz33]

I'm not sold on Swanny either..........also burnt oh ouch.

But hes proven he should hold better than 90/95 av thats good value for starting F4.

 

[SnappyHappy]

Mumford, Beams & Hamling
vs.
Naitanui, Montagna & Shaw

 

[SureBuddy]

I'm not sold on Swanny either..........also burnt oh ouch.

But hes proven he should hold better than 90/95 av thats good value for starting F4.

I agree, but rather just find the extra 70-100k and get Bartel / Franklin / Lids / Goddard / Martin etc.

 

[MightyMark]

Mumford, Beams & Hamling
vs.
Naitanui, Montagna & Shaw

Second option but Maybe with Steven instead of Joey

 

[SnappyHappy]

Second option but Maybe with Steven instead of Joey

Yeah still considering Joey v Steven. Just unsure of my midfield strength if I downgrade Beams to Montagna.

Would make it: Ablett, Pendlebury, Wines, Griffen, Montagna, Rook, Rook, Rook

 

[TN25]

Mumford, Beams & Hamling
vs.
Naitanui, Montagna & Shaw

Option 2, but with Steven instead of Joey

 

[hoddo]

Mumford, Beams & Hamling
vs.
Naitanui, Montagna & Shaw

3 proven scorers versus 2 makes it option 2 ... and stick with Joey.

 

[SnappyHappy]

3 proven scorers versus 2 makes it option 2 ... and stick with Joey.

Or option 3 - Naitanui, Beams & KK

 

[Pedro]

Yea I am not sold on Swan, he bloody burnt me so hard last year and it still keeps me up at night!

Ziebell maybe... Thomas maybe.... Higgins maybe.... Actually I think all the players you listed could potentially average 95-100, but could easily aeverage 75-80. All risky options.

Another risky option, thoughts on Cloke returning to form this year? Is bloody dirty cheap and has hopefully a fit and able Jesse White offering some assistance.

You're worried by Swan burning you on one hand and then ask the question re Trav Cloke on ther other Out of the frying pan and into the fire!!!

I was a bit worried about Swanny myself to be honest, but I've seen him train 3 times since Xmas and play the intra club. He looks a totally different person from this time last year. Even in the drills they can't get the footy off him. He just continually runs to the right spot to get it. Nothings a certainty of course, but he's not going anywhere from my team

 

[hoddo]

Or option 3 - Naitanui, Beams & KK

I still prefer option 2. Beams is great, but we don't know how the move to Brisbane will affect his scoring. KK could possibly break out this year ... could! But you're relying on him doing that. Way too speculative for me.

 

[SureBuddy]

You're worried by Swan burning you on one hand and then ask the question re Trav Cloke on ther other Out of the frying pan and into the fire!!!

I was a bit worried about Swanny myself to be honest, but I've seen him train 3 times since Xmas and play the intra club. He looks a totally different person from this time last year. Even in the drills they can't get the footy off him. He just continually runs to the right spot to get it. Nothings a certainty of course, but he's not going anywhere from my team

Just chucking an option out there dude, would never pick him lol. Appreciate your feedback on Swanny, that's good to hear.

 

[toxic]

Just chucking an option out there dude, would never pick him lol. Appreciate your feedback on Swanny, that's good to hear.

Sorry i never replied to the original but you lost me at Jesse White helping

 

[TheOz]

Swan has to be the lockiest lock of all locks this season.

 

[Hack_Watts]

Griffen-Luey-Lycett

Vs

Neale-Lycett-Bonts