Traded Adam Treloar [traded w/ #28 to Collingwood for #7, #65, 2016 first rounder]

[geelong_crazy26]

Straight swap of Motlop for treloar will get the deal done if Motlop wants out.
Could be a fantastic win win scenario, better than anything Collingwood could offer

 

[BOMBERS 4 LIFE!!!!]

Reckon GWS will be wanting picks with the academy players coming through

Probably right hope EFC is in the mix though.

 

[bird_man]

Reckon GWS will be wanting picks with the academy players coming through

They have enough picks there for academy players as it is.

We give them Carlilse.

They would probably be happy with Carlisle IMO (with some steak knives) but Treloar has got to agree to go to Essendon...

 

[Toadvine]

Straight swap of Motlop for treloar will get the deal done if Motlop wants out.
Could be a fantastic win win scenario, better than anything Collingwood could offer

Might want to take off your blue hoops when describing that deal as a win/win. Treloar is a much better player than Motlop.

 

[Giant Pete]

Straight swap of Motlop for treloar will get the deal done if Motlop wants out.
Could be a fantastic win win scenario, better than anything Collingwood could offer

Straight swap for Motlop? Don't you think we should throw in Cameron as well?

 

[Wayne Swan]

Reckon GWS will be wanting picks with the academy players coming through

GWS don't need players, they have seven or eight first rounders playing NEAFL every week! They certainly don't need mid rangers.

In a trade situation they will only take top liners, like a Carlisle. For Treloar it would need to be a top five and a low 20s pick at the minimum, a sort of Dayne Beams trade. That therefore limits who they would trade with and those teams are unlikely to suit Treloar. If a Collingwood wanted Treloar, they will need to do some other trade outs first to get the necessary mix of picks to satisfy GWS.

GWS do need a lot of points to pick up their three best academy players so picks would interest them most.

 

[Red Bull]

They would probably be happy with Carlisle IMO (with some steak knives) but Treloar has got to agree to go to Essendon...

And the mail is Carlisle wants to stay in Melbourne ...

 

[BOMBERS 4 LIFE!!!!]

They have enough picks there for academy players as it is.

They would probably be happy with Carlisle IMO (with some steak knives) but Treloar has got to agree to go to Essendon...

Sheeds come on down.

 

[BOMBERS 4 LIFE!!!!]

And the mail is Carlisle wants to stay in Melbourne ...

And hopefully at Essendon.

 

[Red Bull]

And hopefully at Essendon.

Well he has plenty of spare time on his hands atm , i guess we can expect him to re-sign any day now ??

 

[naturally north]

You can Thanks the AFL for looking after you very well

Probably should keep the cup at AFL House be a nice touch I think.

 

[Bucksboys]

And hopefully at Essendon.

No one is going to pick him if he cops a 2 year ban, that's probably the only way you keep him

Any chance it gets backdated if he does get banned?

 

[BOMBERS 4 LIFE!!!!]

Well he has plenty of spare time on his hands atm , i guess we can expect him to re-sign any day now ??

Rob Kerr (head of EFC's football department) has said negotiations between Dodoro and Carlilses manager have ramped up so we shall find out soon.

Reckon he's going to stay.

 

[Bucksboys]

Straight swap of Motlop for treloar will get the deal done if Motlop wants out.
Could be a fantastic win win scenario, better than anything Collingwood could offer

Jesus.. we are hoping Witts and a 1st rounder gets it done but I fully expect them to want either steak knives or a swap of later rounds as well

You aint getting the youngest (by a large margin) top 12 possession accumulator in the league for Notlop

 

[BOMBERS 4 LIFE!!!!]

No one is going to pick him if he cops a 2 year ban, that's probably the only way you keep him

Any chance it gets backdated if he does get banned?

I think so.

 

[Red Bull]

I think so.

Good to know ...

 

[dlanod]

I am close with the treloar family. He is still undecided.

But i believe he has narrowed it down to staying at GWS or a move to port.

I heard he was interested in a code switch to the Central Coast Mariners or the NQ Cowboys.

 

[scatman john]

I heard he was interested in a code switch to the Central Coast Mariners or the NQ Cowboys.

spot on.
i'm guessing you saw that footage of him practising corners and free kicks with tony popovic at toongabbie primary school's astroturf half pitch?
gave me chills. going to be a scary prospect

 

[markm106]

They have enough picks there for academy players as it is.

They would probably be happy with Carlisle IMO (with some steak knives) but Treloar has got to agree to go to Essendon...

GWS don't need players, they have seven or eight first rounders playing NEAFL every week! They certainly don't need mid rangers.

In a trade situation they will only take top liners, like a Carlisle. For Treloar it would need to be a top five and a low 20s pick at the minimum, a sort of Dayne Beams trade. That therefore limits who they would trade with and those teams are unlikely to suit Treloar. If a Collingwood wanted Treloar, they will need to do some other trade outs first to get the necessary mix of picks to satisfy GWS.

GWS do need a lot of points to pick up their three best academy players so picks would interest them most.

I could be wrong just thought they need to draft certain amount of players. after academy players would be left with little in terms of picks under new points system. Meaning having very late picks. But agree they have plenty of young players.

 

[markm106]

I honestly think Essendon will struggle to attract top line players from other clubs at this point in time. Seriously think the WADA thing has knocked the current crop of players around.

 

[Wild Bill]

They have enough picks there for academy players as it is.

They would probably be happy with Carlisle IMO (with some steak knives) but Treloar has got to agree to go to Essendon...

Even hird said essendon would not be a very attractive team to join. They have always struggled to get quality players. Goddard the only one I can remember this century.

 

[BOMBERS 4 LIFE!!!!]

I honestly think Essendon will struggle to attract top line players from other clubs at this point in time. Seriously think the WADA thing has knocked the current crop of players around.

I reckon that's a bit of a myth.

Imo if the player thinks EFC is the best fit for him he'll will come regardless of the Wada could hanging over the club.

 

[Red Bull]

I reckon that's a bit of a myth.

Imo if the player thinks EFC is the best fit for him he'll will come regardless of the Wada could hanging over the club.

Yep ,
Chapman , Giles , Cooney and Gwilt are living proof that efc are capable of landing the big ones ...

 

[MightyDons4]

Yep ,
Chapman , Giles , Cooney and Gwilt are living proof that efc are capable of landing the big ones ...

They've got nothing on Tutt, Whiley, Jones or Jaksch

 

[calder_daddy]

Might want to take off your blue hoops when describing that deal as a win/win. Treloar is a much better player than Motlop.

I don't really see much of a problem with it, GWS did offer GFC 2 first round picks in last season trade period which geelong knocked back, so they are obviously keen on him.
1 player for 1 instead of using 2 draft picks.
Can't see it happening but I've read worse trades and seen worse happen