2015 Draft, Trades and Free Agency rumours.

[Simba Moyo]

That might be stretching it. He was picked at 30 and had played 27 games. Not sure he had jumped all the way up to being worth a top 15 pick.

Just purely based on form. Obviously there's no way that would of happened, just more of an example of how talented Yeo is

Maybe not top 15, but 15-20 would have been closer to his value than 28

 

[Scotty_222]

Have heard Jobe Watson is considering a move to Gold Coast.

Makes a bit of sense, he will be needing a fresh environment and he is a big fan of US sport where its more common for stars to move clubs. He might also be looking f or a club that can challenge in his final few years.

im not sure about that one

 

[Theo X]

Lets put some facts on the table RE Hawks and FA
Ins... Chips , Simpkin ( of the rookie list)
Outs ... Ellis , Buddy , Young and now Suckling ...all premiership players and Murphy
No teams been hit harder than us to my knowledge .

Melbourne in relative terms has.

In: Shannyn Byrnes, Tom Gillies
Out: Frawley, Rivers, Moloney, Sylvia

 

[Leuy LongerCombo]

Melbourne in relative terms has.

In: Shannyn Byrnes, Tom Gillies
Out: Frawley, Rivers, Moloney, Sylvia

In: Shannyn Byrnes, Tom Gillies
Pick 3, 23, 47, 48

Out: Frawley, Rivers, Moloney, Sylvia

 

[halfback dasher]

Melbourne in relative terms has.

In: Shannyn Byrnes, Tom Gillies
Out: Frawley, Rivers, Moloney, Sylvia

Out of interest Theo what was compo for each of them ?

 

[Theo X]

Out of interest Theo what was compo for each of them ?

See post above, I'll assume he;s right on picks. Point is they were all easily best 22 players for us. Mark Neeld being the semi-**** he is, picked up Byrnes as a FA before he was delisetd, so we ended up getting watered down compo for Moloney and Rivers.

Ellis, young, Suckling and Murphy were all fringe 22 for you, hence in relative terms. Obviously losing Buddy was massive.

 

[eth-dog]

Pretty sure we haven't lost a player via FA (we lost Monfries through a trade even though he was a FA) and gained Goddard and Gwilt.

 

[halfback dasher]

Pretty sure we haven't lost a player via FA (we lost Monfries through a trade even though he was a FA) and gained Goddard and Gwilt.

Cooney and Chapman ?

 

[Theo X]

Cooney and Chapman ?

Trades I think they were, albeit for token picks.

 

[eth-dog]

Cooney and Chapman ?

Trades.

 

[halfback dasher]

Trades.

Ok

 

[fronkalicious]

Trades I think they were, albeit for token picks.

Pick 37 isn't a token pick

 

[Theo X]

Pick 37 isn't a token pick

Sorry. Proceed to give your detailed expert definition of a token pick if you like

 

[Pannalstaroz]

Pick 37 at Melbourne is a "token pick", but, in all fairness, anything below pick 2 is also considered a token pick

 

[TBellicious]

According to Sam McClure...
Aish to Collingwood for their first round pick in 2016
While Pies first round pick this year part of Treloar deal.

 

[TheLastEmperor]

According to Sam McClure...
Aish to Collingwood for their first round pick in 2016
While Pies first round pick this year part of Treloar deal.

They could end up paying a high price for Aish. I think it's a bad idea trading future 1st's unless the player is a proven gun

 

[Pannalstaroz]

According to Sam McClure...
Aish to Collingwood for their first round pick in 2016
While Pies first round pick this year part of Treloar deal.

Overs?

 

[TradeDraft]

Overs?

Maybe - Maybe not.

Sam a Reliable source?

 

[Pannalstaroz]

Maybe - Maybe not.

Sam a Reliable source?

Not really, but if you throw enough darts.....

 

[Dannnnnnnnnn]

Maybe - Maybe not.

Sam a Reliable source?

I'd like to think that he's reliable, but not valid.

That is, his information is consistently wrong.

 

[TheLastEmperor]

Maybe - Maybe not.

Sam a Reliable source?

Scoops one of the most reliable

 

[Unknown Identity]

McClure's mail is usually spot on.

 

[yyou]

If the rumors of Nathan Wilson leaving are true would a straight swap suffice? Not sure why we would be chasing brown as we have our own KPD coming back from ACL. Tim mohr

Brown = not required
= not that good
= coming off an injury
= are you serious?!

 

[eth-dog]

McClure is massively overrated. Has as many hits as he does misses.

 

[TradeDraft]

McClure is massively overrated. Has as many hits as he does misses.

Same as anyone who Reports on Trade Week