List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade Talk 2015

[Anzacday]

I gave up on him the day I saw him get knocked about like a pinball, he's not like Blair who is a tiny tree stump and hard to move, he just gets brushed aside and he doesn't look like he can get much bigger to offset that.

Blairy is now known as stumpy?
I seriously laughed at that for some reason.

 

[The Prince 29]

Patty apparently worth pick 9, 28 and a fringe player ~50

Trelour is somehow worth 7 (2015) and 18 (2016), surely getting something else here.

Wrangle GC's pick 19 somehow and give that for this year (Seedsman and our lowest acquired pick (24) from St.Kilda?)

7 and 19 get it done, preferably 19 and next years first rounder.

 

[MooreTreloar]

Wow we smashed throw 1000 pages today.

Well done guys.

Interested to see how many pages we get once a trade happens.

 

[TradeDraft]

Thousands of rumors are initiated by the media, yet he stuck by his guns had the guts to stand by his conviction/ source, deserves credit for doing so and is some what vindicated with todays news for doing so.

Chose to give Pie Time the benefit of the doubt instead of taking him to task.

Trade Not Done and Still Reports that Dave Mattews has not Budged Yet

 

[TradeDraft]

Wow we smashed throw 1000 pages today.

Well done guys.

Interested to see how many pages we get once a trade happens.

Could we have 1050 by Tommorow?

 

[MooreTreloar]

Wow we smashed throw 1000 pages today.

Well done guys.

Interested to see how many pages we get once a trade happens.

Perhaps not many actually. All talk would move to that players respective thread I guess.

 

[Apex36]

Off topic, but the Richmond board has reached a critical mass of sodium. Ventured in to their trade thread, saw some guy posting about how Aish had chosen to come to Melbourne so that didn't exclude them.
I politely pointed out that he had specifically nominated Collingwood. Goddamn, the venom spat at me was ludicrous, to the point that it was reportable. Didn't bother though, the mods over there would probably say that I was inflammatory and just ban me instead lol.

 

[MooreTreloar]

Could we have 1050 by Tommorow?

It's possible we've got over 40 today.

 

[boxy99]

Off topic, but the Richmond board has reached a critical mass of sodium. Ventured in to their trade thread, saw some guy posting about how Aish had chosen to come to Melbourne so that didn't exclude them.
I politely pointed out that he had specifically nominated Collingwood. Goddamn, the venom spat at me was ludicrous, to the point that it was reportable. Didn't bother though, the mods over there would probably say that I was inflammatory and just ban me instead lol.

It would have been worth it

 

[sirlothie]

Damn those infernal rules! Why can't we go back to the pre equalisation VFL days...

We may as well... Players just go where they want to go anyway.

 

[Tbone McGraw]

Off topic, but the Richmond board has reached a critical mass of sodium. Ventured in to their trade thread, saw some guy posting about how Aish had chosen to come to Melbourne so that didn't exclude them.
I politely pointed out that he had specifically nominated Collingwood. Goddamn, the venom spat at me was ludicrous, to the point that it was reportable. Didn't bother though, the mods over there would probably say that I was inflammatory and just ban me instead lol.

Were you vaccinated before you went on there?

 

[swoop42]

Thousands of rumors are initiated by the media, yet he stuck by his guns had the guts to stand by his conviction/ source, deserves credit for doing so and is some what vindicated with todays news for doing so.

Chose to give Pie Time the benefit of the doubt instead of taking him to task.

I say again he just repeated what had already been said earlier by Anderson and claimed it as his own.

 

[MAGPIE2013]

Could we have 1050 by Tommorow?

we can have it in 3 min if the treloar deal is announced now

 

[KJpie]

Trade Not Done

Thanks for that Dave

 

[DNine]

dekka really has his work cut out for him self

With out delistings and patty k retiring that left 7 players to fill.

The Howe trade will most likely be Kennedy plus a pick and the Aish deal will most likely be 2 picks or a player and a pick which will leave us 9 players short.

If we trade Seedsman and a pick to get a higher pick that will leave us 10 players to get

We will get Treloar with our first and get one back this year would then be back to 9 players to fill.

Frost will get elevated and maybe Abbott.

good luck dekka

Wouldn't mind topping up with a couple of boys from our two's. Ash Close, Ben Moloney, Michael Still, Ryan Pendlebury and Nick Gray would all be worth looking at. And then there is Mitch Brown.

 

[FireKrakouer]

I say again he just repeated what had already been said earlier by Anderson and claimed it as his own.

I believe he said it a full day before Anderson did?

 

[JollyBallsUp]

So we have Conflicting Reports:

• Jon Ralph Saying Dave Matthews in Holding the Trade Up
• AFL.com.au(Peter Ryan and Nick Bowen) Saying the Trade is Close

So who to Believe

Yes, the trade is close but is being held up by Dave Matthews

 

[MooreTreloar]

So I also circled Etihad a few times in my lunch break and... Nothing.

It's like they just don't let randoms in suits in.

 

[swoop42]

Really surprised it hasn't been talked about more on this thread. Everything just gets muddled up with Treloar, Aish and Howe talks - even though we have separate threads for each of those topics. Would love to get any idea of what everyone thinks the best way to fill this need (pure small forward) is. Because god knows we need it.

The harder edged Varcoe we saw this year is akin to Thomas.

Remember he played many weeks off half back which wasn't our intention when we drafted him.

Anyone who saw Elliott kick that boundary line goal on Anzac Day could see a similarity to Didak.

As he continues to improve his midfield work he'll become a Didak like threat but with strengths in other areas.

Fasolo is very much in the Medhurst mould being an above average mark for his height and an opportunist at ground level capable of kicking the mercurial goal.

We don't have anyone similar to Leon but I maintain Sidebottom is our best natural crumber and with the addition of Treloar and improvement of others he could see more forward time which would be a plus.

If we end up retaining a pick in the 20's then a Rioli or Milera should he still be available might be of interest.

 

[pie time]

It's alright some of you will continue to beat me down, one day I will get credits for what I say, yes the Anderson thing came out but I have a completely different source to him which is a lady I am dating, which happens to be A T'S cousin my source is as close to him as you can get, can't help but say thanks to those who stick by me I will give good positive sources in the future that will fruition.

 

[JollyBallsUp]

Off topic, but the Richmond board has reached a critical mass of sodium. Ventured in to their trade thread, saw some guy posting about how Aish had chosen to come to Melbourne so that didn't exclude them.
I politely pointed out that he had specifically nominated Collingwood. Goddamn, the venom spat at me was ludicrous, to the point that it was reportable. Didn't bother though, the mods over there would probably say that I was inflammatory and just ban me instead lol.

His just frustrated that Richmond have not been able to attract any significant talent other than Yarran and even then Richmond are doing there best to botch that deal up. In reality Richmond are about 6 trade days way from another rebuild.

 

[Troglodyte]

Can someone tell me who Dave Matthews is, please, and how he is holding up the trade for Treloar?

 

[loki04]

LOL. Never anything easy for us. Bet if Geelong wanted him Melbourne would accept a packet of chips.

Yep and Hawks

They give up shit for gold and other teams ask them would you like fries with that!

 

[Soups]

Can someone tell me who Dave Matthews is, please, and how he is holding up the trade for Treloar?

CEO of GWS. Haven't seen anything about holding up the trade, so someone else might be able to say something about that?

 

[KJpie]

I say again he just repeated what had already been said earlier by Anderson and claimed it as his own.

I read your initial reply and answered in kind, therefor there is no point in "say again".

I was simply giving a fellow poster a thumbs up and some credit for what I believed to be the right call.

I get that you don't agree with me crediting Pie Time for the call.

I respect that, now can you respect my right to give him credit and please move on.