Preview Round 2 - Pies V Tigers (team in OP: Aish, Grundy, Reid and Oxley in)

[Kappa]

[***Mod edit: selected team added to OP***]

Collingwood

FB: Jack Frost, Nathan Brown, Tom Langdon
HB: Jackson Ramsay, Ben Reid, Marley Williams
C: James Aish, Adam Treloar, Levi Greenwood
HF: Jarryd Blair, Darcy Moore, Jordan De Goey
FF: Alex Fasolo, Travis Cloke, Corey Gault
Foll: Brodie Grundy, Scott Pendlebury, Taylor Adams
Int: Brent Macaffer, Jack Crisp, Ben Sinclair, Adam Oxley
Emg: Matthew Goodyear, Alan Toovey, Jeremy Howe

IN: James Aish, Brodie Grundy, Adam Oxley, Ben Reid
OUT: Dane Swan (foot), Jarrod Witts (hand), Steele Sidebottom (suspension), Brayden Maynard (omitted)
NEW: James Aish (20, Brisbane)




[***End of Mod edit***]


May as well turn our attention to next week...

Out - Sidebottom (Suspended)
Swan (injured)
Brown (injured)
Witts (dropped)
Macaffer (useless)


In - Reid (desperately needed)
Grundy (can't be weaker than Witts)
Aish (May as well see what he can do)
Marsh (Deserves a game)
White (Eh...)


Plenty more players who should be dropped but unfortunately there is no one to replace them with.

We desperately need to delist Frost and replace him with someone half good... the sooner the better.

Maynard not AFL standard currently

Corey Gault.. what a surprise, non existent as usual.

Cloke ... absolutely pathetic, no other words. Disgusting.

Langdon.. overrated on this board, massively overrated. Has no hurt factor and his defensive efforts are weak.



I doubt Howe is ready to go, but if he is then get him in too.



Very important we show something this week. Another gutless performance and the vulchers will already be out for Buckley's head.

Oh wait.. thank god we already gave him an extension

 

[Ketchup]

Out: cocaine
In: performance enhancing drugs

 

[Finnishpie]

Out: Swan, Sidebottom (will get 3), Brown, Williams (ankle), Witts.

In: Aish, Grundy, Oxley, Howe, Reid (please God!)

At least we have a relatively easy next month. Next week is the hardest.

 

[BoxMatrix]

What should happen:

Out- Maynard, Cloke, Witts, Swan, Brown, Langdon, Sidebottom, Caff

What will happen:

Out- Swan, Brown, Sidebottom.

Our selectors are gutless wonders.

 

[ThexderX]

AFL out, VFL in.

 

[Kappa]

Out: cocaine
In: performance enhancing drugs

Look on the bright side.. at least the boys will be having a good night tonight

You can find some really top quality things to snort or pop in Sydney, the players will be happy. They get their pay cheque and can do whatever drugs they want as well.. what a life.

 

[Stifler's mom]

Outs - baby and bath water

 

[mike123]

In: Grundy, Phillips, Goodyear, Aish (play him at half back we need skill down there), Reid, Marsh (carved up Jack Reiwoldt last time), Jeremy Howe

Out: Witts/Gault (don't care who), Maccaffer (Good bloke but not a good footballer), Swan (Injured) Maynard (Made Lumumba look like Pendlebury in the ball handling department, Brown(if injured) Frost(if Brown's ok), Langdon (useless), Sidebottom(suspended)

 

[Soaring Magpie]

If macaffer, frost and witts are playing next week our match commitee are taking the piss

 

[Saintly Viewed]

In: guys taking a cold shower before the game (wake them up)
out: posts that think being nasty to players will make them play better

 

[pablo disco bar]

What happened to brown??

Maynard should never of played

Hope swans career isn't over

Good start ey

 

[Rusty Beam]

May as well turn our attention to next week...

Out - Sidebottom (Suspended)
Swan (injured)
Brown (injured)
Witts (dropped)
Macaffer (useless)


In - Reid (desperately needed)
Grundy (can't be weaker than Witts)
Aish (May as well see what he can do)
Marsh (Deserves a game)
White (Eh...)


Plenty more players who should be dropped but unfortunately there is no one to replace them with.

We desperately need to delist Frost and replace him with someone half good... the sooner the better.

Maynard not AFL standard currently

Corey Gault.. what a surprise, non existent as usual.

Cloke ... absolutely pathetic, no other words. Disgusting.

Langdon.. overrated on this board, massively overrated. Has no hurt factor and his defensive efforts are weak.



I doubt Howe is ready to go, but if he is then get him in too.



Very important we show something this week. Another gutless performance and the vulchers will already be out for Buckley's head.

Oh wait.. thank god we already gave him an extension

Come one Kappa you can do better (I agree with all your outs by the way)

Ramsay (Needs to go. So reactive, unsure, fumbly and non creative)

Other possible in's need to come from: Toovey, Wills and Phillips

Oh how I miss Heater and Leon off half back.

 

[Piesinmyeyes]

Take off your rose colored glasses people, first one dropped has to be Sinclair, nowhere near up to AFL standard. Can't believe he has support each week. Gault is a deceiver and caff might be past it sadly. Bring in Aish, Howe, Grundy, Reid and Toovey. Even give Crocker a run.

 

[Rusty Beam]

Come one Kappa you can do better (I agree with all your outs by the way)

Ramsay (Needs to go. So reactive, unsure, fumbly and non creative)

Other possible in's need to come from: Toovey, Wills and Phillips

Oh how I miss Heater and Leon off half back.

Actually at this stage I'm also missing Harry off half back.

 

[legendstatus]

I feel redeemed about my comments on Maynard - that's all I've got after tonight.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Scodog10]

What's the go with Brown? I saw that he came off, but no idea other than it looked like it must be a groin.

Where do you start with that mess...

 

[1980GFVideo]

We would have been thrashed by Sydney if we played them this week based on what we put out on Thursday so two evenly matched teams keen to atone.

Pendles doesnt put two average ones together so concerned about him next week and with Treloar coming to the party straight up our midfield will need to step up.

Good game as I think both sides are at the same level it just depends who brings what to the game.

 

[Number 10]

Frost has to go and never come back.
Frost out, forever.

Let start building a proper backline with guys who can kick. Just one would nice.

 

[Unknown Identity]

OUT: Swan (inj), Sidebottom (susp), Witts, Gault, Macaffer, Brown (inj), Sinclair/Maynard

IN: Aish, Reid, White (Plays Fwd and 2nd Ruck), Howe, Marsh, Phillips, Grundy,

 

[doodles98]

I can't believe our preseason form could be so deceptive!!!. I mean who'dve ever thought preseason form could mean absolutely nothing come round 1?? weird hey. Btw.. Superb backline Bucks has created... Maynard, Langdon, Ramsay, Frost and Sinclair... and we have Goldsack, Toovey, Marsh and Oxley as backup!! It's looking good back there Bucks

 

[Jonno94]

I knew we would regret not playing Reid, Grundy and Aish. They have to play next week along with Howe.

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Out
Witts
Maccacfer
Maybnard/Sinclair
Swan
Brown

In
Grundy
Aish
Reid
Howe
Marsh

Thats really only dropping two players with two injuries and Grundy/Witts being line ball. Stick with Gault Cloke Moore but drop Cloke in coming weeks

 

[Jonno94]

I can't believe our preseason form could be so deceptive!!!. I mean who'dve ever thought preseason form could mean absolutely nothing come round 1?? weird hey. Btw.. Superb backline Bucks has created... Maynard, Langdon, Ramsay, Frost and Sinclair... and we have Goldsack, Toovey, Marsh and Oxley as backup!! It's looking good back there Bucks

Its a huge concern that the club has ignored and thought we could cover with average players.

 

[Kappa]

I can't believe our preseason form could be so deceptive!!!. I mean who'dve ever thought preseason form could mean absolutely nothing come round 1?? weird hey. Btw.. Superb backline Bucks has created... Maynard, Langdon, Ramsay, Frost and Sinclair... and we have Goldsack, Toovey, Marsh and Oxley as backup!! It's looking good back there Bucks

Our backline is bottom 4 in the AFL, easily.

 

[mike123]

What happened to brown??

He was actually playing football. It was making the rest of the team look bad so we took him off to keep up appearances.