Remove this Banner Ad

Analysis 2017 List Management Discussion Part II

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Great to speculate, but I think Jones is not a tradeable commodity this year as nobody can really accept his emergence after being a whipping boy for so long.

If Jones can hold this form till the end of next year IMO he will have very good currency.
If he continues this form for another year he is a top 5 defender in the league and untradable. His form has been nothing short of outstanding in a very poor team. He is you g enough to play well into our dynasty and so far has been better than any defender on our list.

Good on him.
 
Team for next season.


B: Plowman------------Marchbank----------*New Player

H: Docherty------------Weitering------------Simpson

C: *New Player--------Cripps--------------*New Player

H: C.Curnow----------*New Player--------Cunningham

F: Silvagni---------------McKay----------------Pickett

R: Kreuzer, Gibbs, Murphy


Bench: Jones, E.Curnow, SPS, Wright

Emerg: Bryne, A. Silvagni, Macreadie, Williamson, Kerridge, Palmer

Out: Thomas, White, Casboult, Graham, Lamb, Sumner
 
Watched him closely tonight, wasn't completely sold. Needs work still, could be a good get for a low price. Depends how he fits into GWS long term plans. They are going to have to play hard ball sometime.
SOS loves him isn`t that enough.............
 
I'm cheering for the Giants to win the flag this year, making an exodus of young talented players more likely :)

It might work in the opposite. If they play and win like they did against the dogs, they will walk in the flag, and then there is no telling how those youngsters will react to being part of a dynasty
 
...
Levi shopped himself around last year too. Hawthorn were desperate for a Forward/Ruck..............................

..........they preferred Tyrone Vickery.

That's something to chew on...

Last year Hawthorn would have to have traded for Casboult. They traded for Mitchell and O'Meara. Vickery was a FA.

This year Casboult is a FA, (and Vickery is a fail).
 

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Is Hopper AND Whitfield worth pick 2 alone?
I don't think either of those two will ever be A graders
Love to see Kelly in navy next year

With a surplus of defenders I would be off loading from there and say Marc Murphy to reconstitute our midfield
The defender I would be putting up for a trade is jw
Jones is our best lock down defender ( Alex silvagni can help
Rowe I see as finished
Marchbank can do the weitering
Plowman is getting better and better
And the one that I believe is a hybrid defender lock down and intercept and the best of the whole lot potentially is my man in defence Macreadie
I truly think this guy will fill out and be the absolute bees knees defender
Probably needs two to three more years

We can afford to let weitering go because I'm hoping he has enough currency for a straight out swap ( might be wishful)
Kelly is an absolute must to get to the club moving forward
I would also do Marc for another midfielder or package
I just don't see him in plans moving forward
Will lose the captaincy and needs a reset
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top