- Joined
- Apr 8, 2010
- Posts
- 7,701
- Reaction score
- 32,457
- Location
- South Adelaide
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- South Adelaide Panthers
Combo of that & Brayshaw doing the opposite in the champs?Reckon that’s why he slipped to us?
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

Combo of that & Brayshaw doing the opposite in the champs?Reckon that’s why he slipped to us?
Because he had a really ordinary champs.
All Stars >>>>>>>>>>>>>> Championships.
All Stars >>>>>>>>>>>>>> Championships.
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
Joe Baxi. Must remember that one.
Its posts like this that make me long for the next "Rebecca's Journey" epic to appear here or thereabouts.
Nah. I think Luke is an absolute gun, but there is literally 0 defensive pressure in the All Stars compared to champs. I'd be rating championships form as a better indicator of composure and resilience, and probably a better indicator of ability in the less flashy parts, which all in all I'd consider more important than looking sexy with no pressure whatsoever.
I wouldn't be surprised if recruiters think along those lines as well, hence the so called 'bolsters' ala Clayton Oliver who go early after not being picked for champs but tearing up school footy.If that’s the way you want to look at it then school footy > champs. In school footy there’s no zones and tagging is allowed.
Problem is LDU did not perform in the under 18 champs, hwnce why he did not make the all Aust un 18 sideNah. I think Luke is an absolute gun, but there is literally 0 defensive pressure in the All Stars compared to champs. I'd be rating championships form as a better indicator of composure and resilience, and probably a better indicator of ability in the less flashy parts, which all in all I'd consider more important than looking sexy with no pressure whatsoever.
Problem is LDU did not perform in the under 18 champs, hwnce why he did not make the all Aust un 18 side
You are dead right pardon me. I should have said he was inconsistant He did have some fantastic moments. PS not having a go at him i would never bag any of our players period.That's incorrect imo. He might not have been consistent and did have quiet patches of games but he was still good overall, and excellent for periods.
Still averaged more possessions comfortably ahead of Dow who did make all aust.
Interestingly 3 of the top 5 didn't make all Aust
You are dead right pardon me. I should have said he was inconsistant He did have some fantastic moments. PS not having a go at him i would never bag any of our players period.
I wouldn't be surprised if recruiters think along those lines as well, hence the so called 'bolsters' ala Clayton Oliver who go early after not being picked for champs but tearing up school footy.

hate to be 'that guy', but we wont know how well LDU will translate to AFL football until he is out there during an AFL game, even then it could take him a few pre-seasons worth of experience to develop into the player the club thinks he will become. They need to make sure that Ziebell and Cunnington are giving him the support he needs in the midfield, if he is too gain confidence in himself. Don't wanna kill his confidence from the beginning. Here's hoping he goes down as North champion.![]()
Why are people casting little bits of doubt over LDU? He had the ability to drag his side (Dandenong Stingrays) back from 51 points down in an elimination final and win the game of his own boot. He will be a club champion one day
I think there has been a few question marks over his attitude around draft time but who knowsWhy are people casting little bits of doubt over LDU? He had the ability to drag his side (Dandenong Stingrays) back from 51 points down in an elimination final and win the game of his own boot. He will be a club champion one day
Look at who had the #1 pick. Brisbane considered him a flight risk and rightly so as you could tell he was estatic to reamin in Victoria. The ranking system isn't worth a cent as here is another example: Will Walker. where was he rated? I bet you it wasn't anywhere near number 23. Ranking systems are a bit of a wank if you ask meHe was a potential number 1 all the way until he landed at North Melbourne. Suddenly some ranking systems had pushed him down to pick 9-.
That all came from freo, who were trying to play funny buggers with us with Brayshaw, Cerra and LDU.I think there has been a few question marks over his attitude around draft time but who knows
