Mega Thread The new Bucks mega-thread. It's Official. 2 Year Deal for Bucks.

[BringouttheGimp]

Yeh but we never got flogged mate

never got flogged

The football we played was absolute shyte and a disgrace to watch

never got flogged

'Lose by 3 goals.. we played shit.. imagine we improved'.. one of my fav excuses re

 

[jmac70]

Could say the same about you I suppose but at the end of the day the last 6 years results speak for themselves and it all points to Bucks having no idea

The beauty is that he only needs to turn it around this year, and all the previous ones will be forgotten.

 

[Jasper84]

The beauty is that he only needs to turn it around this year, and all the previous ones will be forgotten.

Apparently the first year already has been forgotten.

 

[BringouttheGimp]

The beauty is that he only needs to turn it around this year, and all the previous ones will be forgotten.

He'll improve if he crosses of every excuse and points the finger at himself..

 

[TradeDraft]

Apparently the first year already has been forgotten.

That was MM Team and then Bucks Destroyed It

 

[TKiL]

The beauty is that he only needs to turn it around this year, and all the previous ones will be forgotten.

Quite true - success does wonders for footy fans - especially demanding, critical Pie fans - should we make finals and win 1-2 games Nathan will be nearly beyond reproach - on the other hand -no progress or slip further down the ladder and it won't be pretty - esp on this board - we will have some idea within 6-8 weeks

 

[jmac70]

That was MM Team and then Bucks Destroyed It

No, he actually coached that team to a prelim. Despite Malthouse sniping from the sidelines, a massive injury list and the passing of jmac.

 

[TradeDraft]

No, he actually coached that team to a prelim. Despite Malthouse sniping from the sidelines, a massive injury list and the passing of jmac.

So you think JMAC Death had the Same Impact as Darren Millane's Death?

 

[jmac70]

So you think JMAC Death had the Same Impact as Darren Millane's Death?

It didn’t help.

 

[TradeDraft]

It didn’t help.

Now I think about it. It would not Help and Could explain the Dip in Form end of 2012 Season but you hope now they be more Settled With it then back then

 

[Jasper84]

That was MM Team and then Bucks Destroyed It

I must admit, the forward line was certainly well drilled and coordinated in MM's premiership team. We should probably pay credit where credit is due.

 

[Jasper84]

So you think JMAC Death had the Same Impact as Darren Millane's Death?

Milane died in the off season. Jmac died just before the WC final and his funeral was just before the Sydney final. It would of had a massive impact on the boys.

 

[Carringbush2010]

Some of the garbage football we played last yr.. seems like it matters for shit. I can't do another yr of it.. I'll move to Liverpool.

He better get it right.[/QUOTE]

Gimp I'll remind you that is not just the coach who is solely responsible, more than just the coach to blame. The club as a whole my friend

 

[BringouttheGimp]

The review has been done.. so no more excuses in 2018. If the review is used as an excuse to start from scratch.. I really can't stand for that.

 

[BringouttheGimp]

I must admit, the forward line was certainly well drilled and coordinated in MM's premiership team. We should probably pay credit where credit is due.

Our midfield were kicking a ridiculous number of goals as well.. run through the list in 2010.. Even Jolly kicked a shit load of goals. We got that bored we were kicking behind the stick jobs for fun re. It wasn't all about our forward line.

 

[parvey]

Apparently the first year already has been forgotten.

You mean the one he inherated from Malthouse?

 

[Jasper84]

You mean the one he inherated from Malthouse?

Nah, the one whose forward line Buckley coached into two grand finals.

 

[parvey]

This statement may be the greatest example of Proof by Assertion, I've ever seen. It's almost beautiful in its own way.

So what is your proof to the contrary? The wonderful last 4 years in which we have gone progressively backwards, having a good vocabulary in no way proves a point of view unless you have proof and you my friend have a great way with words but no substance to back up your claims, so enlighten us as to why Bucks is such a great coach

 

[parvey]

Nah, the one whose forward line Buckley coached into two grand finals.

Bwaaaa, is that it, lol

 

[jmac70]

So what is your proof to the contrary? The wonderful last 4 years in which we have gone progressively backwards, having a good vocabulary in no way proves a point of view unless you have proof and you my friend have a great way with words but no substance to back up your claims, so enlighten us as to why Bucks is such a great coach

No one on this board has said he is a great coach.

 

[parvey]

No one on this board has said he is a great coach.

I reckon you have my friend and Jasper also does otherwise you wouldn't get so worked up when people doubt him

 

[Jasper84]

So what is your proof to the contrary? The wonderful last 4 years in which we have gone progressively backwards, having a good vocabulary in no way proves a point of view unless you have proof and you my friend have a great way with words but no substance to back up your claims, so enlighten us as to why Bucks is such a great coach

Never said Buckley is a great coach. In fact I thought he should of been sacked post 2016. My issue is with people passing opinions as facts and when a person argues that A caused B without evidence to support the claim.

 

[left at home]

Apparently the first year already has been forgotten.

And the second year as well.

 

[TKiL]

Never said Buckley is a great coach. In fact I thought he should of been sacked post 2016. My issue is with people passing opinions as facts and when a person argues that A caused B without evidence to support the claim.

Football clubs / teams / on field performance depend on many interconnected moving variables - unlikely it will ever be the case that "A caused B"

 

[TKiL]

I feel we need to relax. I think we're gonna be top 4 ? This year
Fairly confident 1/2 a gorilla at $26. (Get on gimp)
Funny but when bucks is right to go. The following guys should be looked at
R shaw proven coach Now in longmires inner circle assistant heater
Caracella quality pies man
We have had 3 outside coaches
Mathews. Left a huge mess
Malthouse. Left a huge mess
Hafey Left a mess
Track record 2 flags with lots and I mean lots of drama

Simplistic assertion here - esp Hafey and Matthews

PS you forgot John Cahill