2019 Rookies

[WaynesWorld19]

Who will give way for Ollie Wines when he returns, Drew?

Not on yesterdays performance

 

[MowShow]

If you have any dpp and want to swap josh Corbett will get games in a few weeks you’d think
Forward line


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Unfortunately doesn't look like I'll have that flexibility this week with majority already locked..

Best mid rookie yet to play?

 

[gcsunsfc]

Unfortunately doesn't look like I'll have that flexibility this week with majority already locked..

Best mid rookie yet to play?

Bailey Scott
LDU more expensive

They're the only rookies named for today

Schultz in the fwd line

 

[SavDog23]

Question for Saints fans.
Who has the best JS and scoring potential out of Wilkie and Joyce?
Wilkie better in the 3rd quarter but seems like Joyce has the friendlier SC scoring role.
Is it worth going Wilkie > Joyce or should I hold?

 

[Judd_Magic]

Question for Saints fans.
Who has the best JS and scoring potential out of Wilkie and Joyce?
Wilkie better in the 3rd quarter but seems like Joyce has the friendlier SC scoring role.
Is it worth going Wilkie > Joyce or should I hold?

I'd like to know who Saints fans reckon will be the best scorer between these 2.

 

[Jiska]

Question for Saints fans.
Who has the best JS and scoring potential out of Wilkie and Joyce?
Wilkie better in the 3rd quarter but seems like Joyce has the friendlier SC scoring role.
Is it worth going Wilkie > Joyce or should I hold?

Are you asking if you should use a trade to dump someone who scored 70 to someone who scored 67?

No.

 

[SavDog23]

Are you asking if you should use a trade to dump someone who scored 70 to someone who scored 67?

No.

Yeah, i'm not to worried now. When I posted it though Joyce was on 55 while Wilkie was on 25 in the 3rd quarter.

 

[SterlingArcher]

Taylor the next Finlayson?

 

[atlas1]

Yeah, i'm not to worried now. When I posted it though Joyce was on 55 while Wilkie was on 25 in the 3rd quarter.

Depends who has the best JS when Brown returns next week.

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Taylor the next Finlayson?

How much?

 

[SterlingArcher]

How much?

Well Fanfooty had him at $117k and I blew my load.

Cleaned up and double checked elsewhere because I knew he played last year and turns out he's 270k.

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Well Fanfooty had him at $117k and I blew my load.

Cleaned up and double checked elsewhere because I knew he played last year and turns out he's 270k.

yeah nah too much.

Need to find a rookie to dump that turd collins

 

[SterlingArcher]

yeah nah too much.

Need to find a rookie to dump that turd collins

Yep if he was actually rookie priced it'd be a no brainer. 270k is just another likely awkward price when his scoring reverts in a game that isn't a 12 goal win with no forward pressure.

 

[SterlingArcher]

yeah nah too much.

Need to find a rookie to dump that turd collins

Wilkie 70 Hore 58 are 2 though. Hore 2 at 1/4 time and managed 58 so not bad, Wilkie got a few intercepted contested marks and spoils so could be alright but is battling with Battle for that role and Battle got more of it.

Assuming you have Clark/Duursma/Scrimshaw + 1 of Moore/Burgess which would be the norm.

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Wilkie 70 Hore 58 are 2 though. Hore 2 at 1/4 time and managed 58 so not bad, Wilkie got a few intercepted contested marks and spoils so could be alright but is battling with Battle for that role and Battle got more of it.

Assuming you have Clark/Duursma/Scrimshaw + 1 of Moore/Burgess which would be the norm.

Collins, Scrimshaw, Clark, Duursma, Hore - Maybe Collins to Burgess NFI

 

[SterlingArcher]

Collins, Scrimshaw, Clark, Duursma, Hore - Maybe Collins to Burgess NFI

One of Joyce or Wilkie from Saints will be alright - I still reckon one is coming out for Brown for round 2, but pick the other one - 70 from Wilkie, 67 from Joyce, both cheap normal rookie price, whichever one keeps their spot is likely to have very decent JS (Rowe, Marsh well behind).

Burgess is likely to be reasonably limited as a mark and kick forward. He'd need to kick 3 to get over 60 while Wilkie and Joyce don't need to do anything too impressive as they pick up easier cheap stats and also some intercept ones.

 

[Judd_Magic]

One of Joyce or Wilkie from Saints will be alright - I still reckon one is coming out for Brown for round 2, but pick the other one - 70 from Wilkie, 67 from Joyce, both cheap normal rookie price, whichever one keeps their spot is likely to have very decent JS (Rowe, Marsh well behind).

Burgess is likely to be reasonably limited as a mark and kick forward. He'd need to kick 3 to get over 60 while Wilkie and Joyce don't need to do anything too impressive as they pick up easier cheap stats and also some intercept ones.

Yeah reckon I will be dumping Burgess for 1 of the 2 saints rookies.

Don't care about my Moore to Burgess link anymore....

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Griffin Logue a chance to return?

Can't be as bad as Collins

 

[ubeaut]

So who to field next week
Butters vs Carlolton
OR
Scott vs Lions?
Assuming Kentstable and Walsh already picked

 

[Jiska]

Unfortunately I missed the GC vs StK game.

Can someone who saw it give me a rundown on Burgess, Collins, Joyce and Willkie?

And what’s the JS of the latter two? I see they got similar scores but Joyce gave away six free kicks. Would have scored 90 without that.

 

[JC Hawks]

So who to field next week
Butters vs Carlolton
OR
Scott vs Lions?
Assuming Kentstable and Walsh already picked

Definitely Scott you would think.

 

[OhhhhhCyril]

Get rid of Scrimshaw peepz..

View attachment 636816

Definitely has work to do, but I think he stays.. still a bit unknown when the likes of skull, chad and howe come back. Recon we can still make us a bit of coin

 

[SterlingArcher]

Unfortunately I missed the GC vs StK game.

Can someone who saw it give me a rundown on Burgess, Collins, Joyce and Willkie?

And what’s the JS of the latter two? I see they got similar scores but Joyce gave away six free kicks. Would have scored 90 without that.

Burgess an inexperienced mark and kick key forward. Will likely have a spike game somewhere he takes a few and kicks 3 but average will be closer to 40 than 60.

Collins got a lockdown role, didn't get the opportunity to fly for marks as much. Injured in the last 30 seconds I think? Seemed to go hard at a contest right at the very end and I didn't notice any talk of an injury beforehand.

Joyce and Wilkie JS will be known on Thursday when Brown comes back. He`s a definite best 22 but I`d back Joyce and Wilkie to be ahead of Rowe and Marsh. I`d guess Joyce ahead as Battle takes the intercept role over Wilkie. Also Joyce was outscoring Wilkie for all bar the last 5 minutes so read into that what you will (Wilkie potential for faster scoring, Joyce more consistent perhaps). Whoever kerps their spot round 2 should be safe.

 

[Jiska]

Burgess an inexperienced mark and kick key forward. Will likely have a spike game somewhere he takes a few and kicks 3 but average will be closer to 40 than 60.

Collins got a lockdown role, didn't get the opportunity to fly for marks as much. Injured in the last 30 seconds I think? Seemed to go hard at a contest right at the very end and I didn't notice any talk of an injury beforehand.

Joyce and Wilkie JS will be known on Thursday when Brown comes back. He`s a definite best 22 but I`d back Joyce and Wilkie to be ahead of Rowe and Marsh. I`d guess Joyce ahead as Battle takes the intercept role over Wilkie. Also Joyce was outscoring Wilkie for all bar the last 5 minutes so read into that what you will (Wilkie potential for faster scoring, Joyce more consistent perhaps). Whoever kerps their spot round 2 should be safe.

Sounds like Collins not worth keeping if he’s going to be asked to do lockdown roles. Burgess either, but with lack of alternatives he may as well sit at F8 and enable the Moore swing option from defense. Collins to Joyce looks a good move assuming he keeps his spot. The extra 60k I bank leaves me with $320k in the bank for an easy upgrade from either Balta or Burgess to Sheed (what an upgrade that is!!)

 

[SterlingArcher]

Sounds like Collins not worth keeping if he’s going to be asked to do lockdown roles. Burgess either, but with lack of alternatives he may as well sit at F8 and enable the Moore swing option from defense. Collins to Joyce looks a good move assuming he keeps his spot. The extra 60k I bank leaves me with $320k in the bank for an easy upgrade from either Balta or Burgess to Sheed (what an upgrade that is!!)

In terms of the 2nd trade, I think that's where I`m headed too.

Got Danger mids currently for this reason and 450k in the bank. Giving Kent and Balta another week but 1 is very likely to end up as Macrae (if Kent)/Coniglio/Sheed/Rockliff depending on the size of my balls.