Remove this Banner Ad

Autopsy Rd 5 Did Blues win? They shit it in!

Which players do you think played well in Round 5?


  • Total voters
    281
  • Poll closed .

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

He good, real good.
But I’ve seen, Jezza, Doull, SOS, Sticks, Dominator, Diesel wear the jumper.
He’s not yet in front of them and others yet.
You can't get in front without the team around you to win flags. Thats the be all and end all.
Stats and individual prowess are nothing in football. Its about the team.
 
I'm not getting into long discussions as I want to enjoy the win and Carlton more. I'll just say you're wrong

So you're going to act all high and mighty like you have some incredible insight but then not elaborate?

If we don't have anyone who can play a `role` like Polson while also simultaneously getting involved in general play more than 4 disposals I`d be bewildered. You can have a `role` of pressuring or defense - but you can 100% get more than 4 handballs too.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

I said the same thing a few weeks ago and said it again today..... Paddy Cripps is the best player to EVER wear the navy blue
He's good, he's got some serious players ahead of him. Lets have another look at this when his career is over.
 
Starting to think recruiting Daisy was one of the smartest things we’ve done. Wasn’t meant to be the superstar we wanted. But he bleeds navy blue and he’s the old head we need
100%, apart from the letting Eddie go bit
 
He good, real good.
But I’ve seen, Jezza, Doull, SOS, Sticks, Dominator, Diesel wear the jumper.
He’s not in front of them and others just yet.

Wow! No Judd?

Wasn’t privileged enough to see Jezza, Doull and Dominator but did see the rest and I still say he’s better than all of them
 
He good, real good.
But I’ve seen, Jezza, Doull, SOS, Sticks, Dominator, Diesel wear the jumper.
He’s not in front of them and others just yet.
Throw Juddy in there as well.
 
Lighthearted wish list although Pickett and Williamson in particular will concern us by seasons end if they don't get in a block of games without getting injured again.

Willo will be fine

Pickett, ball is in his court now, we will all know what decisions he has made, the second he steps back out for his first game with the VFL
 
Great win today. If you're not happy with that you aren't a Carlton supporter.

:whitecheck: Well done to Bolts. He coached really well today and made some excellent changes.

:whitecheck: Gibbons playing half forward/wing/midfield got the best out Gibbons and gave us more midfield depth. But when the change was made Gibbo needed to step up and he did.

:whitecheck: Love Jack in the team. I've wanted him there all year, but its good to see that he earned his spot through good form and then continued that form.

:whitecheck: Walsh is a vanilla freak. Unbelievable debut year so far.

:whitecheck: Levi Casboult. I'm not a fan but he was brilliant today. One of his best games for the club.

:whitecheck: Harry McKay. In the unpopular opinion thread I recently said that he is going to be our best young player not named Walsh. I should delete the post because I doubt it's unpopular now.

:whitecheck: Our defense. Credit to our entire defense today. The forwards were on fire but our defense did a great job once again.

:whitecheck: SPS. It's hardly surprising that we easily won a game where he had 35 possessions. What an exciting talent.
 
You can't get in front without the team around you to win flags. Thats the be all and end all.
Stats and individual prowess are nothing in football. Its about the team.

Agreed, and everyone of the above players have.
If he continues to play at the level he is and hold up number 17 he rightly becomes their peer.
If he does, it will be the most important one to me that I have seen.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Yeah it's in the past....last week even.

One tall too many last week and we looked much better for it today.

I still see it differently. Our disposal efficiency was up from 71 to 79 from last week. If we had mirrored that against the Suns, we would have spanked them
 
Nah he's the new craig Bradley, just doesn't kick quite as well. I mean those long 50 metre goals from the boundary line way.. Absolute gun. Just to think he's played how many games?
It’s funny to think about all the negativity about Walsh prior to us drafting him on this board. This kid is going to be such a consistent performer just like Cripps is. It’s hard to believe he is a first year player, he’s never going to be an absolute game-changer like Martin or Cripps, but he will deliver for us time after time.
 
Ugh replay not until 10 am tomorrow, thanks for nothing Foxtel, you buzz kills :(

Watching replay now on Foxtel now, weird how set top box Foxtel doesn’t have it available

Depending on which Foxtel box you have, you can download the game.

ON DEMAND > ANYTIME (CATCH UP) > SPORT > AFL LATEST ROUND
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Just back from the six your round trip from and to
Footy is a harsh business thy and I love and have utmost respect for anyone wearing the CFC on his chest. I’m just looking at what I think makes us better. If Plowman stays in then I support him 100%, I’m not the supporter that watches the game and criticises every time he makes an error i always support the boys. But after the game I’m entitled to analyse without the rose coloured glasses. And you know what if willo comes in and doesn’t improve the team I’ll be the first one calling for Plowman to come back in.
You won't get the chance I'm afraid. The plow is highly respected from within, Playing extremely well and would need to put in five shockers before there would be the slightest chance of playing in the twos.
 
He good, real good.
But I’ve seen, Jezza, Doull, SOS, Sticks, Dominator, Diesel wear the jumper.
He’s not in front of them and others just yet.

Agree. Kouta at his best as well. Judd

If Cripps keeps going he will be in the conversation but not yet IMO.

and that's not a criticism at all
 
He good, real good.
But I’ve seen, Jezza, Doull, SOS, Sticks, Dominator, Diesel wear the jumper.
He’s not in front of them and others just yet.

Priveledged to have seen all of the above play.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Autopsy Rd 5 Did Blues win? They shit it in!

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top