Remove this Banner Ad

Bluemour Melting Pot XX - Snark Free Zone

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Hope you're right with this one as the end of first round for Ellis would be ridiculous. The secret herbs and spices compo formula surely needs to take the quality of the footballer into account and not just the contract size.

I've said it before and I'll say it again.

If FA compo is here to stay, it needs to be based on the contract offer from the current team.

It's supposed to compensate a club for a player walking out on them. Who cares what the new club is paying the player. If the current club doesn't rate them highly or is happy to let them leave, why do they need compo?
 
Great news re: Daniher

Will be interesting to see what the deal is, if one gets done.

Joe is a massive loss if he gets over his injuries, but there has to be some doubt there.

Where do Essendon go from here? I do not believe they will go into a season with McKernan and Brown as their key forwards.

Watch them make a massive play for Cameron now.
 
I've said it before and I'll say it again.

If FA compo is here to stay, it needs to be based on the contract offer from the current team.

It's supposed to compensate a club for a player walking out on them. Who cares what the new club is paying the player. If the current club doesn't rate them highly or is happy to let them leave, why do they need compo?
Well said ferrisb.....I would go as far to say get rid of free agency altogether.....although the AFL say that they won't because of the PA.

We currently have a system that players can get traded to a club of their choice these days regardless if they're contracted or not, and a deal happens 99% of the time. Let the market sort itself out, without the AFL providing compensation through free agency.

That is how we how we help get equalisation across the board, where GCS would get 2 first round picks from the Tiggs for Lynch through a trade rather than 1 through compensation, and the Tiggs actually have to give something up to get an a-grader.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

I've said it before and I'll say it again.

If FA compo is here to stay, it needs to be based on the contract offer from the current team.

It's supposed to compensate a club for a player walking out on them. Who cares what the new club is paying the player. If the current club doesn't rate them highly or is happy to let them leave, why do they need compo?
Yes, but you're too smart by half and are missing one key consideration - something that works easily, is transparent and consistent can't be manipulated by the AFL as needed.
 
Last preseason it was Doc on a trampoline, this preseason its Charlie playing basketball. Cant our players just play videogames like normal kids their age? Mitch Robinson even has a twitch stream and he never injures himself in preseason. Coincidence?
Well Doc does play video games as he was actually playing against my young bloke on PlayStation last year I didn’t believe him but true story

Same age bracket as my boy is 25
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Great news re: Daniher

Will be interesting to see what the deal is, if one gets done.

Joe is a massive loss if he gets over his injuries, but there has to be some doubt there.

Where do Essendon go from here? I do not believe they will go into a season with McKernan and Brown as their key forwards.

Watch them make a massive play for Cameron now.

Can no afford
 
So what i don't understand with the Papley situation is what Sam Edmund said regarding him not caring about where in Melbourne he goes too. With our ITK's confirming Papley --> Carlton does that mean this was false?
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

How many pages have we dedicated now to Charlie's injury? Sh*t Happens

Any bluemours? Who's the mystery man? Was there a shooter on the grassy knoll? Any chance we could move on please
yeah, that'll happen...….
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top