Autopsy Round 4, 2020: St.Kilda v Richmond *MADDIE'S MATCH*
- Thread starter George
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Banned
- #127
Brilliant win and the club pulled the right strings with changing Ryder with Kent.
The entire team were great today. The belief and confidence to keep taking it on from HB is a credit to Ratts and the group.
I loved seeing Marsh & Battle forward they take the heat off Membrey and King. In Marsh we have found a more energetic CHF then Bruce.
Butler is on All Australian form line if he keeps playing the way he is.
Hill was damaging with his run his is a freak.
Jones is a energy bunny and finds space.
Steele probably played his best game without being a tagger.
Kent was actually really good and sets up a lot of play.
The back 6 apart from a couple of brain fades were fantastic.
Ross did a decent job on Martin, I just wished he would take the tackle at times.
Marshall is better suited to be the No 1 ruckman.
Only downer was Gresham he was really out of it today. Then he suffered that horrific eye injury - doubt he backs up next week.
Plus it was great to have my man Battle back, he just brings winners attitude and skill to the team.
The entire team were great today. The belief and confidence to keep taking it on from HB is a credit to Ratts and the group.
I loved seeing Marsh & Battle forward they take the heat off Membrey and King. In Marsh we have found a more energetic CHF then Bruce.
Butler is on All Australian form line if he keeps playing the way he is.
Hill was damaging with his run his is a freak.
Jones is a energy bunny and finds space.
Steele probably played his best game without being a tagger.
Kent was actually really good and sets up a lot of play.
The back 6 apart from a couple of brain fades were fantastic.
Ross did a decent job on Martin, I just wished he would take the tackle at times.
Marshall is better suited to be the No 1 ruckman.
Only downer was Gresham he was really out of it today. Then he suffered that horrific eye injury - doubt he backs up next week.
Plus it was great to have my man Battle back, he just brings winners attitude and skill to the team.
Last edited:
- Oct 2, 2010
- 20,024
- 71,983
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
How good is fast, high scoring footy!
That game was huge for Membrey. Best he's looked all year. Looked like the leader the club wants him to be. That mark in the 4th quarter was insane.
Butler is the pick up of the year. He's changed our forward line dynamic and just makes things happen.
Carlisle was excellent. Coffield's best game - growing in confidence each week. Same with Long. Apart from that 1 mistake, Paton was good again.
How Battle wasn't into the side until now is a mystery. He was great. Marsh's role made sense. King didnt do much but he will have learnt a lot from playing on such good defenders - just keep playing him.
But the biggest take away was that Marshall must ruck by himself. He is a ruckman, not a forward. He will get beat in hit outs but his influence around the ground when he is near the ball is unmatched.
Really proud of everyone tonight.
That game was huge for Membrey. Best he's looked all year. Looked like the leader the club wants him to be. That mark in the 4th quarter was insane.
Butler is the pick up of the year. He's changed our forward line dynamic and just makes things happen.
Carlisle was excellent. Coffield's best game - growing in confidence each week. Same with Long. Apart from that 1 mistake, Paton was good again.
How Battle wasn't into the side until now is a mystery. He was great. Marsh's role made sense. King didnt do much but he will have learnt a lot from playing on such good defenders - just keep playing him.
But the biggest take away was that Marshall must ruck by himself. He is a ruckman, not a forward. He will get beat in hit outs but his influence around the ground when he is near the ball is unmatched.
Really proud of everyone tonight.
Diehard Saint
Brownlow Medallist
)
just a guess but that eye is a worry
His ball use is infinitely better than Dunstans. I'd take Hannebery into a game over Dunstan and Seb Ross.
How much better life is when we just kick straight for goal.
It really is a simple game.
It really is a simple game.
yeah makes a lot of difference - 10 more goals than last week.
- May 17, 2014
- 4,198
- 5,532
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Long Marshall Membrey Hill Hanna great games....and battle lock him in please
was caught out by one of the best around today , he will grow with more games and by finals I hope he is in full gear.
Does anyone else have to confirm when they like someones post? I've had it happen to me a couple of times now tonight.
- Oct 13, 2016
- 806
- 3,892
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Think we can shelve the two ruckman idea.. Marshall should be first name picked each week, he’s a star
- May 17, 2014
- 4,198
- 5,532
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
No crowds no pressure
- Jun 7, 2015
- 916
- 2,335
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
So many kicks from the goals square as well
Yeah we are clearly getting shots from better parts of the ground
Most eye injuries are the eye.
paddygunner
Senior List
- Jan 12, 2014
- 251
- 653
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Quality I50 deliveries giving us better looks
Feels good!
I didn't expect to be this happy!!
Having Battle , Marsh , Kent in the team just seems to give us more grunt
