Hypothetical - Would you like your team to finish bottom this year in order to get Judd?

[nick_savo]

If the team that finished bottom was most likly going to get Judd at the end of the year, Would you like it to be your team?
This is hypothetical because Judd most likely will not go anywhere.

 

[Mi Eagles Dominate]

If the team that finished bottom was most likly going to get Judd at the end of the year, Would you like it to be your team?
This is hypothetical because Judd most likely will not go anywhere.

we already have him so its hard to say....
i really dought that anyone would say yes to this question..
Carlton supporters may claim thats what they were trying to do last year though lol

 

[AxelFoley]

It depends really.
At the start of the season everyone has high hopes of their team being successful so at the moment I would definetly say no.
However if by round 18-19 the Dons are lingering in the bottom 4 I wouldnt really mind though considering its not just hypothetically getting Judd, its also the number 1 draft pick as well.

 

[SWANNIES RULE]

No. Because you don't -need- players like Judd to win premierships.

 

[Mi Eagles Dominate]

No. Because you don't -need- players like Judd to win premierships.

second that. and pluss if your club is so bad that it finishes last then even 3 off judd in the same team will not garentee you the gold

 

[bus24]

Well, if you're no hope of winning the premiership or even doing anything of note in Setember, why not?

So

Yes

 

[Ed_Gein]

No. We've been in the last 2 GF's without him. Don't need him.

 

[Calcium Man]

Yes. Richmond has the worst midfield in the comp, mainly because we do not have a player of star quality in there. It has basically meant that Deledio has been our most dangerous midfielder and been tagged heavily. Judd would take a lot of the attention of our young blokes.

 

[parrot]

If the team that finished bottom was most likly going to get Judd at the end of the year, Would you like it to be your team?
This is hypothetical because Judd most likely will not go anywhere.

I guess witht the terrible state of the Pies list, a spoon finish by the Pies is a strong likelihood rather than a hypothetical over the next few years. The Pies could get him with their #1 PSD pick, but I'm pretty sure Judd will come to trade terms with a better quality Club before the pre-season draft. I'm not really too fussed if the Blues don't put a serious offer on the table, because apart from the dollars, what is more of a concern is the number of quality younger players we'd have to give up.

 

[Ted Ed Fred]

I'd like to see Hawthorn finish bottom then not pick him

 

[Ted Ed Fred]

I guess witht the terrible state of the Pies list, a spoon finish by the Pies is a strong likelihood rather than a hypothetical over the next few years. The Pies could get him with their #1 PSD pick, but I'm pretty sure Judd will come to trade terms with a better quality Club before the pre-season draft. I'm not really too fussed if the Blues don't put a serious offer on the table, because apart from the dollars, what is more of a concern is the number of quality younger players we'd have to give up.

LMFAO

Do you write your own material mate?

 

[nick_savo]

LMFAO

Do you write your own material mate?

Yeh, and the sand thing is he really belives what he is writing, quite sad actually

 

[Tarkyn_24]

If it was a certainty he was leaving the Eagles, yes. Anything else, no.