Diehard Saint
Brownlow Medallist
The best recruit they got was Choco Williams. I think he would’ve been a huge player in their premiership year.Took over at way different periods of development though too. You can't really measure them against each other because we had 10 years of rebuild and spent up on players and staff for him. Goody came in after Roos had straightened them up but they were still a pretty psychologically weak and patchy side.
If you gave both coaches the same list at the same time you could measure it but it's pointless holding them up against each other.