Recommitted Clayton Oliver [UFA 2030] - clubs are interested, Melbourne willing for the right price

[JayJ20]

Adelaide would be a great fit for Oliver. Essendon too, but it looks like Oliver wants Adelaide.
I hope Essendon at least throw everything at it to lure him.

 

[Kreuuuzeurns]

Oliver to North for pick 2. Pick 2 and pick 5 to West Coast for pick 1. Potentially a pick in the teens heading to eagles as well.

Melbourne turn Oliver and Freo's first pick into Reid. Eagles draft Curtin at 2 and best available at the other pick(s).

Oliver and pick 5 for Harley Reid

 

[Bald]

nowhere near enough. Adelaide's F1 will probably be like 13 or something. Oliver is worth 2 in the top 5 or 3 firsts.

3 firsts hey?

10, 17 and a F1.

 

[danster168]

Oliver to North for pick 2. Pick 2 and pick 5 to West Coast for pick 1. Potentially a pick in the teens heading to eagles as well.

Melbourne turn Oliver and Freo's first pick into Reid. Eagles draft Curtin at 2 and best available at the other pick(s).

kidding yourself. Oliver a proven generational talent for a speculative pick 2 that has a 50% chance of busting. Laughable proposal. What are the odds that Harley Reid is a 4 time AA bnF winner, 3 time AA and 2 AFLCA 's by 26? 1% chance? Maybe 2% chance.

The odds of Harley Reid surpassing Oliver is next to zero.

 

[croweater 41]

 

[ABAB]

nowhere near enough. Adelaide's F1 will probably be like 13 or something. Oliver is worth 2 in the top 5 or 3 firsts.

It will be very easy to get another 1st rounder with the 3 early 2nd rounder picks.......

 

[Dom sheed pocket]

nowhere near enough. Adelaide's F1 will probably be like 13 or something. Oliver is worth 2 in the top 5 or 3 firsts.

I cant see any club other than North having capacity to make that deal, so if that is Melbournes bottom line (and not just yours) than they’d be better off deciding at their board meeting tonight not to trade him.

Pick 4 and a future first is likely the best deal Melbourne could hope for.

 

[Sydney Kicker]

kidding yourself. Oliver a proven generational talent for a speculative pick 2 that has a 50% chance of busting. Laughable proposal. What are the odds that Harley Reid is a 4 time AA bnF winner, 3 time AA and 2 AFLCA 's by 26? 1% chance? Maybe 2% chance.

The odds of Harley Reid surpassing Oliver is next to zero.

You aren't trading for what Oliver has done in the past. You're trading for what he will do in the future. And what's this 50% chance of busting coming from?

 

[hippyhippy]

Why wouldn’t Adelaide do that trade?

They would... someone start the car

I'm highly doubtful any of this is actually true...

This just came out of nowhere... unbelievable any non SA player would pickup Adelaide lmao...

Imho... if any of this is true... it seems that MFC is the one who's trying to get rid of him it seems and his price is lower... AFC is not chasing him promising him massive money

 

[The Inbetweener]

I reckon Melbourne leaked this to put a rocket up him and have next to no interest in trading him unless it was for ridiculous overs.

 

[sleep]

Oliver to North for pick 2. Pick 2 and pick 5 to West Coast for pick 1. Potentially a pick in the teens heading to eagles as well.

Melbourne turn Oliver and Freo's first pick into Reid. Eagles draft Curtin at 2 and best available at the other pick(s).

Ur trade value all over the shop

Clarry > Harley Reid.

 

[BaliDemon]

kidding yourself. Oliver a proven generational talent for a speculative pick 2 that has a 50% chance of busting. Laughable proposal. What are the odds that Harley Reid is a 4 time AA bnF winner, 3 time AA and 2 AFLCA 's by 26? 1% chance? Maybe 2% chance.

The odds of Harley Reid surpassing Oliver is next to zero.

Don’t even bother mate. All they read is “attitude problem” by some cadet journo and then think we’ll turf him for a mid first round pick and steak knives.

If he was their player they’d be saying exactly the same thing you are.

 

[sleep]

Big Sav 4 Clarry.

Lets GO!

 

[Big_Birdy]

nowhere near enough. Adelaide's F1 will probably be like 13 or something. Oliver is worth 2 in the top 5 or 3 firsts.

He is a great player but he is not worth more than Chris Judd was in 2007. Not even close all things considered.

 

[Gavin Excell]

If I was a Dees fan I'd be pretty disappointed in how the club has handled, reacted to all this

 

[boncer34]

Laughable from the Dees posters already.

You'd have thought they'd learnt from the Jackson or Hogan trades what realistic trades look like.

Instead we've got 2 top 5 picks, 3 firsts, 2 firsts and 3 2nds etc coming from them. Prepare to be disappointed, again, if he goes.

 

[danster168]

You aren't trading for what Oliver has done in the past. You're trading for what he will do in the future. And what's this 50% chance of busting coming from?

do you honestly think Clayton Oliver won't get another 5 All-Australians, 5 bnf's by the time he is done? crazy talk. He's one of the all time greats who is in his prime and never plays poor games. He's 26, not 36.

 

[BaliDemon]

You aren't trading for what Oliver has done in the past. You're trading for what he will do in the future. And what's this 50% chance of busting coming from?

Cool. Another 3 B&Fs, another 3 AA guernseys, maybe another 2 AFLCA MVP awards. Maybe a Brownlow why not?

He’s 26yo.

 

[croweater 41]

Laughable from the Dees posters already.

You'd have thought they'd learnt from the Jackson or Hogan trades what realistic trades look like.

Instead we've got 2 top 5 picks, 3 firsts, 2 firsts and 3 2nds etc coming from them. Prepare to be disappointed, again, if he goes.

But Dodo

 

[sydney_gws]

Oliver and pick 5 for Harley Reid

This is ok. Harley Reid is considered more valuable than normal, say 4500 points
Pick 5 is 2000, leaving Oliver valued at 2500 points which is pick 2.

 

[Golumless]

I reckon Melbourne leaked this to put a rocket up him and have next to no interest in trading him unless it was for ridiculous overs.

If that wild scenario was true, why would Oliver even care. He's got his payday.

All Melbourne risk is turning that contract into an albatross with that kind of stupidity.

 

[xLeCrAs2x]

Unsure if already posted but WOW

The last place I’d thought he may potentially end up

 

[danster168]

Laughable from the Dees posters already.

You'd have thought they'd learnt from the Jackson or Hogan trades what realistic trades look like.

Instead we've got 2 top 5 picks, 3 firsts, 2 firsts and 3 2nds etc coming from them. Prepare to be disappointed, again, if he goes.

haha, are you for real? comparing Oliver to Jackson and Hogan? Oliver is on track to be the greatest demon ever. Hogan and Jackson are in the minor leagues compared to Oliver. Jackson we said could be generational. Oliver is. No-one in the history of the game can match him in the contest.

Reid plus 2 first rounders
Or if it's Adelaide, it's 3 first rounders with 2 in the top 10, one in the top 5. Otherwise, we can have the goat play for us for 7 more years

 

[rye]

If I was a Dees fan I'd be pretty disappointed in how the club has handled, reacted to all this

seems to be something rotten at melbourne. cant keep their dirty laundry in house

 

[Kreuuuzeurns]

9 + F1 + 21 + McAdam

Maybe throw in 24 with 33 going back

Still unders but you couldn’t ask for much more if you were kicking him out.

Dees go and get Reid or GC pick 4 from there.