List Mgmt. 2023 Trade & List Management Thread II - Goldy&Bucket➡️✅/'24 EoFR & #44➡️Stephens&#25✅/#21&#25➡️Fisher&#17✅/'24 EoFR➡️#18✅

[Lore]

Hello Shinboners!

The embedded resources below are kept up to date by the trade board mods (as much as possible – we are human after all). Enjoy!

Spoiler: 2023 Draft Order

Spoiler: 2024 Draft Order, aka Future Picks

Spoiler: Blue Tick Rumours

 

[big_e]

Imagine instead of giving our #1 draft pick each year a particular number like Pies used to, we just gave them hbf and guilt tripped them one bloke won a bnf having never played there before.


I was like this too but remembered Troy and Adam came before Joel.

Also Jason and Cameron before Travis.

FWIW, I'm also the youngest child.

 

[Lomas]

West Coast flew to Tasmania to meet a bloke you work with?

And people lay sh*t on me about attention to punctuation!

 

[JGreezy]

West Coast flew to Tasmania to meet a bloke you work with?

Thats just thorough back ground checking.

I once walked by Harley Reid at lake weeroona. WC flew over to chat with me.

 

[Kanga1996]

Melbourne want 3 to get to 1 .. Don’t do it North.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[amaz199]

Melbourne want 3 to get to 1 .. Don’t do it North.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

We won't. It'll undo all the work we've done up to this point.

 

[Kimbo]

Adding whatever value is required to #2 and trading up for Reid

It's been my belief the club wants Harley, that they see him as a force multiplier for the young group we've already established and a 'September player' as Clarko puts it, and I won't begrudge the club for spending multiple pics to secure him. It's not hard to imagine all of Brady's moves thus far have been to do just that.

Good post, with a big nod to your use of ‘force multiplier’ to explain why 1 player may end up better than 2 in this instance.

Similarly, when you look over the list you laid out, the potential is there and age-wise more ready than many think. It just needs the yeast, and on-field I think Harley may be it.

 

[Bazzbot13]

Melbourne want 3 to get to 1 .. Don’t do it North.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Only way Melb get 3 is if its involved in a trade with WC that delivers us 1.

 

[RHLK]

What's that, there's only 6 decent footballers, and we have dibs on 2 of them?

 

[R00StaR]

I think Curtain and McKercher leaves a much bigger statement and fills a lot more holes

Sanders and Curtin for mine and hopefully bid up into the O'Sullivan range.

 

[justroyal]

Sanders and Curtin for mine and hopefully bid up into the O'Sullivan range.

100% it makes all that noise north made about him sound like they wasted a whole lot of ****ing time

 

[roos_fanatic08]

Best kid in it and no one is changing my mind.

If he had a little bit more speed he’d be on par with Reid. Only thing holding him back is a bit of athletic point of difference.

On field, he does just about everything perfectly.

 

[Zebrah]

Go to footywire, search the last 10 drafts and look at picks 2,3,15,17,18.

2014 the stand out, but overall it shows you why we need to keep top picks and if we can move to 1 by bundling 2 and a combo of 15,17&18…we should do it.

 

[Roos1991]

His kicking skill is a dash overrated. He is capable of hitting really nice long kicks and his short kicking is neat, but he is prone to mis-kicking them.

In saying that, his kicking isn’t the main reason why you are drafting him. It’s his explosiveness, speed, ability to accumulate the footy, ability to break tackles and ability to open up the game up.

On a side note outside of Sanders who is a beautiful kick and decision maker I think the kicking skill of all of the top midfielders is a bit overrated this year. McKercher, Duursma, & Watson are all prone to over kicking the footy.

It'd probably be criticized here but I really hope we take Sanders at 3. His balance, vision and placement of the footy remind me of Sam Mitchell, except he'll end up with a much stronger frame and his leadership is something the club could do with more of.

 

[4cunningTonneTruck]

Reid and Watson have always been the 2 I want the most. I would be very happy if we could someone manufacture getting those 2 without giving up too much

 

[Roostorm]

I commend Brady for getting our current draft hand…can’t recall us ever having this many at our disposal.
As for the media ….they’re board stiff and have dead space to fill in until next Friday..hence these bonkers trade scenarios. I’ve lost count of how many of them eagerly suggest we sell the farm and then some, then head into the draft with a reduced hand. Whilst giving other clubs a leg up with their suggestions. So I’ll look at each clip of these so called experts …have a chuckle…and move on.
I’m sure after what we have acquired, Brady and co will look into what’s the reasonable risk in the possibility of gaining the cats, gws or even pick one. (if that’s what they’re thinking) If they are way out there bonkers crazy, we walk away. As mentioned on this board, play our cards right and make considered moves, this is shaping up as a club defining draft… Just look at the melts going on in the media and on socials from other clubs and supporters…they know it… s+$# them as it us against them.
I’ve always been of the thought get as many top quality players as you can, without significantly trading away your advantage….Just look at Harry and George.
So until then I’ll trust what Brady is cooking up, and laugh at these media muppets creating their own trade scenarios in their heads, that becomes newsworthy so they can be paid for so called journalism. After all it is the silly season….and so far it’s looking rather glorious.

 

[roos_fanatic08]

It'd probably be criticized here but I really hope we take Sanders at 3. His balance, vision and placement of the footy remind me of Sam Mitchell, except he'll end up with a much stronger frame and his leadership is something the club could do with more of.

I’d be thrilled if he ended up at North, because I rate him so highly.

It’s a hard sell though, because he is a one paced centre square midfielder, too similar to players we already have.

Reid offers a point of difference because of his power and ability to play multiple positions. McKercher offers a point of difference because of his speed. Duursma offers a point of difference because of his ability forward of centre.

 

[Kimbo]

Reid + Sanders or Duursma

 

[Shermanator]

Go to footywire, search the last 10 drafts and look at picks 2,3,15,17,18.

That sounds like hard work.. can’t you just post them here?..

 

[Shermanator]

Reid and Duursma would be like having Dusty and Burgoyne (love that comparison whoever said it earlier) together in September.

They’re both built for the big stage.

 

[berniemccarthy]

I commend Brady for getting our current draft hand…can’t recall us ever having this many at our disposal.
As for the media ….they’re board stiff and have dead space to fill in until next Friday..hence these bonkers trade scenarios. I’ve lost count of how many of them eagerly suggest we sell the farm and then some, then head into the draft with a reduced hand. Whilst giving other clubs a leg up with their suggestions. So I’ll look at each clip of these so called experts …have a chuckle…and move on.
I’m sure after what we have acquired, Brady and co will look into what’s the reasonable risk in the possibility of gaining the cats, gws or even pick one. (if that’s what they’re thinking) If they are way out there bonkers crazy, we walk away. As mentioned on this board, play our cards right and make considered moves, this is shaping up as a club defining draft… Just look at the melts going on in the media and on socials from other clubs and supporters…they know it… s+$# them as it us against them.
I’ve always been of the thought get as many top quality players as you can, without significantly trading away your advantage….Just look at Harry and George.
So until then I’ll trust what Brady is cooking up, and laugh at these media muppets creating their own trade scenarios in their heads, that becomes newsworthy so they can be paid for so called journalism. After all it is the silly season….and so far it’s looking rather glorious.

Brady has done a decent job so far but he has been gifted pick 3 and 3 priority picks. Blind Freddie could have done a decent job with the cards he was dealt.

 

[Shermanator]

Brady has done a decent job so far but he has been gifted pick 3 and 3 priority picks. Blind Freddie could have done a decent job with the cards he was dealt.

Who is this Blind Freddie fella and why isn’t he already on our recruitment team?..

 

[Roostorm]

Brady has done a decent job so far but he has been gifted pick 3 and 3 priority picks. Blind Freddie could have done a decent job with the cards he was dealt.

And I’m sure Brady and Freddie will continue to do well in both their jobs.

 

[Masked Avenger]

In racing terms, it seems Curtin has the blows.

A bit puzzling.

On the vision, he looks athletic, composed and is an above average kick. Being a lefty doesn't hurt either.

He's definitely physical and he's well built for an 18yo. He's also rising 196cm.

Our backline is terrible. Worst backline we've had in 50 years yet we see points of difference in midfielders in this crop!

He's been top 4 all year so we'd be hardly be reaching at 2 or 3.

His recent comments about playing under Clarko were impressive too.

Can't see too many knocks on him.

 

[danj]

Brady has done a decent job so far but he has been gifted pick 3 and 3 priority picks. Blind Freddie could have done a decent job with the cards he was dealt.

Fair call but now it’s all birds, hands, bushes. Hopefully we come out with a brace and not empty handed.

 

[muttley45]

It'd probably be criticized here but I really hope we take Sanders at 3. His balance, vision and placement of the footy remind me of Sam Mitchell, except he'll end up with a much stronger frame and his leadership is something the club could do with more of.

Agree, the other thing about Sanders is he is in our friggin NGA Academy, and it will be hard watching him perform for any other team, some more than others.