Remove this Banner Ad

List Mgmt. 2025 Trade/FA Thread (Cont’d)

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Would not touch May with a 10 foot pole. He's the kind of bloke that is a culture killer at your club and would definitely impact your team negatively on field as people won't be comfortable playing with him. Just look at Melbourne.

No thanks.
Well coaching staff is most likely targeting him, so you might get disappointed.

Talent and defensive smarts wise, he would definitely be an upgrade over Dean and even Frampton.
 
We need to start using secret hand signals!
Not sure if you have heard, but this man is in town at the moment. Perhaps he can show us few hand signals that we can use next year.

Snoop Dogg Singing GIF by The Voice
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

I just looked up uncontracted players for 2025 and Bodie Ryan from the hawks is still uncontracted.

Cousin of Jacob Ryan and similar height but plays more of a Maynard role(got that dog in him).

He might be a good money ball option.
 
Ashcroft B2B Norm Smith medallist. Has he now taken over as the best player in the competition? IMO, unfortunately l think he has....
No need to overreact, there are a lot better players than Ashcroft that haven't won a Norm Smith and don't even play in a GF, although Bucks winning a Norm Smith in a losing team does put him on a god like level though.
 
Hope you’re right but other than blind hope there has been close to zero evidence of this!

hope isn’t a plan !
Parker and Roan have shown a decent ability and good composure so I think they make it. HH has also shown plenty before the knee. Allan I'm not so sure. Has had chances and years in the system but lacks something. Maybe just real belief as seems to sheep dog the packs and hang back.
 
Yes - and that’s what its been abbreviated to by commentators.
They are different rules. Just because the media stir things up doesn’t mean it needs to be expanded. All rules where the umpires judge intent are just reducing the quality of the game. The AFL have seen failure to keep the ball in play as crowd enhancing. I see it as a garbage rule that is not enforced consistently. The proposed last possession rule between the arcs is a long way from last touch. The potential issue will be bad umpiring which we have and delays if they use replays for decisions.
 
Would not touch May with a 10 foot pole. He's the kind of bloke that is a culture killer at your club and would definitely impact your team negatively on field as people won't be comfortable playing with him. Just look at Melbourne.

No thanks.
If you want to be competitive against Brisbane next year, you're going to need may. This culture killer was instrumental in winning their flag. Winter is over and the snowflakes have melted
 
I suspect the club won't end up with May due to cultural reasons, but you can see below why the club is doing its due diligence around him.

Frampton had an ok season, however even in a down year for May, he is a much more effective player across nearly all of the key defensive categories highlighted below.

It looks marginal, but the club would be viewing this as a way to upgrade a position in our starting 23 for no draft cost, while also offering the depth at KPD and positional flexibility with Moore/Howe if they wanted to consider playing either as a forward if required.

1759017939486.png
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Ashcroft B2B Norm Smith medallist. Has he now taken over as the best player in the competition? IMO, unfortunately l think he has....

Well put it this way, he gets to play alongside the best midfield in the game.

So he is able to shine without a tag most weeks.

If we want to see what Nick’s ceiling is, we need a lot more than just ‘finals De Goey’.
 
No need to overreact, there are a lot better players than Ashcroft that haven't won a Norm Smith and don't even play in a GF, although Bucks winning a Norm Smith in a losing team does put him on a god like level though.
Im talking about a 21 year old in his 3rd season having already won 2 Norm Smith medals. You have to admire the talent of this guy.
The game has been fortunate to see Naicos and Ashcroft come in over the last few years, because these two will be dominant for many seasons to come..
 
Last edited:
Well put it this way, he gets to play alongside the best midfield in the game.

So he is able to shine without a tag most weeks.

If we want to see what Nick’s ceiling is, we need a lot more than just ‘finals De Goey’.
Naicos is a champion, and his time to shine will come, if it hasn't already. But he definitely needs help in our midfield, and l really hope Butters is a priority for us in the next 12 months...
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Ashcroft B2B Norm Smith medallist. Has he now taken over as the best player in the competition? IMO, unfortunately l think he has....
I hate these comparisons between the two, why can’t we just appreciate that Washcroft and Naicos are two generational talents and we get the pleasure of seeing them battle it out for the next 15 years
 
What are u talking about. Where did l compare Ashcroft to Nick, buddy?
You said he’s taken over as the best player in the competition.
Nick is the best player.
 
Hope you’re right but other than blind hope there has been close to zero evidence of this!

hope isn’t a plan !
Parker, Steele & Harrison have all impressed at AFL level & Allan has had moments. Zero evidence?
 

Remove this Banner Ad

List Mgmt. 2025 Trade/FA Thread (Cont’d)

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top