Remove this Banner Ad

Official Club Stuff Carlton Academy - Next Gen & Father/Son/Daughter Discussion II

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

**** it, just tank and let the AFL know why it was done.
We’re playing the youth and we’ll see how it goes. Also, your impulsive rule changes made it too hard to enable us to rightfully draft our F/S nominee if we were too successful without getting bent over in the process.
And let the AFL know that it'll affect crowd sizes and TV audience as a result.
 
We used pick 3 to draft Smith. We traded 2 picks in the teens for pick 3. Having to use 2 first round picks to match a bid for Cody isn’t the same thing.
We turned 2 first round picks into 1 player.

I really don’t see the difference.

We get given a first round pick next year, so we need another.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

**** it, just tank and let the AFL know why it was done.
We’re playing the youth and we’ll see how it goes. Also, your impulsive rule changes made it too hard to enable us to rightfully draft our F/S nominee if we were too successful without getting bent over in the process.
Great idea..
Let's tank to get Cody...

And have a mass exodus of players who want to play for a club that wants to win..

**** me dead..
 

Remove this Banner Ad

**** it, just tank and let the AFL know why it was done.
We’re playing the youth and we’ll see how it goes. Also, your impulsive rule changes made it too hard to enable us to rightfully draft our F/S nominee if we were too successful without getting bent over in the process.
It’s a smart idea. The clubs message to its members needs to be that we’re playing youth for the next 1-2 years in order to develop our lust and improve our depth. The members would happily suck up another 1-2 years of mediocrity if it helps us do all this and then grab Cody plus another top 5 gun in 2026 as well as a free agent like butters with our extra Curnow-less (TDK/JSOS/….) salary.

It does probably spell the end for Cripps, Newman, Saad and Hewett though which is fine as the replacements are going to be guns and built for the modern game.
 
It’s a smart idea. The clubs message to its members needs to be that we’re playing youth for the next 1-2 years in order to develop our lust and improve our depth. The members would happily suck up another 1-2 years of mediocrity if it helps us do all this and then grab Cody plus another top 5 gun in 2026 as well as a free agent like butters with our extra Curnow-less (TDK/JSOS/….) salary.

It does probably spell the end for Cripps, Newman, Saad and Hewett though which is fine as the replacements are going to be guns and built for the modern game.
I think that Hewett has a couple of years left in him. It'd definitely spell the end of Williams though.
 
Yeh but not the same


If we ‘hid’ Cody everyone would be aware of what we are doing
You could argue that the U17 pre-GF game in 2023 (this years rookies) was full of better players than what next years draft looks like.

Players like Faull, O’Sullivan, Langford, Lalor, Travaglia, Reid, Moraes, Lindsay, Kako, Hotton, L.Camporeale, Ashcroft all on one team that all showed good AFL level footy in 2025.

The other team had; B.Camporeale, Draper, Marshall, Smith and Trainor. And Ben getting the Best on ground. And they won despite having less drafted players (or at least players than got regular footy in 2025).

On a side note I’d be expecting Ben to be starting midfield in 2026.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

I read the futures game thread in the afl draft free agency section

Seems like a lot of fans think Walker is 1, if not 1, 2 behind dougie

Saw a Brett Deledio comparison which is pretty exciting. Gonna be a jet
 
I read the futures game thread in the afl draft free agency section

Seems like a lot of fans think Walker is 1, if not 1, 2 behind dougie

Saw a Brett Deledio comparison which is pretty exciting. Gonna be a jet
I've seen people compare him to the following players over the past year or two:
  • Chris Judd
  • Dustin Martin
  • Scott Pendlebury
  • Marcus Bontempelli
 
A lot of mid 2024 power rankings had Lalor 9/10 or even later. A lot can change in a year of junior football.

Cody's plane of improvement has to level off and others will emerge.

Obviously there is no hiding him, but I suppose we will look to limit his exposure.
 
[QUOTE="Red_man2008, post: 89813501, member:
On a side note I’d be expecting Ben to be starting midfield in 2026.
[/QUOTE]
I expect Ben to become a regular participant in our midfield in 2026, nit sure what you mean by “starting midfield”.

He will be “blooded” as much as possible through the season. Will be interesting if he gets a “second position” or has to wait for inside time.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Official Club Stuff Carlton Academy - Next Gen & Father/Son/Daughter Discussion II

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top