List Mgmt. 2025 Trade/FA Thread (Cont’d)

[soreplums]

we will have a player worth 4 x no5 picks, Naicos

We wouldn’t want to give him or Josh up though.

 

[NQPieman]

Disagree, Hill is on a 4 year deal which gives Collingwood the upper hand.
Sure he had personal issues, but no comparison to JUH!
Hills problems seem also to have been ironed out.
Cleary is talking shit imho!
Worse case we keep him kills it in the next 2 years!
Then you might have Tasmania breathing down his neck
Pies hold the cards with Hill, its overs or he stays!
Both outcomes i would be content.
Would probably be happier if he stays
Arguably when Hill is firing there is no more dangerous small forward then him

What is a fact is any pies player up for trade in any given year ain't worth a bag of beans according to the media, but anyone we go after is suddenly a star on the rise or a gun even if they're 33. Remember when Noble wasn't worth two bob last year but we all knew different and he went to brain it at the suns.

 

[ksardog]

We wouldn’t want to give him or Josh up though.

that wasn't the question

 

[ksardog]

What is a fact is any pies player up for trade in any given year ain't worth a bag of beans according to the media, but anyone we go after is suddenly a star on the rise or a gun even if they're 33. Remember when Noble wasn't worth two bob last year but we all knew different and he went to brain it at the suns.

yeh, so what has changed from every other year?

 

[Pragmatic Shill]

For anyone that can access the article GW has already addressed this.

August 15 the Age “Greame Wright opens up on Carlton, the Voss call and leaving the Pies” he was asked directly about Elliott and part of the response was “I presume he stays at Collingwood. I wouldn’t think he’s leaving…”. My take is they asked the question a while back (which Gleeson seemingly already knew) and Elliott has indicated he’s not interested. I doubt this update is anything more than a check in that it’s still a no.

Direct quote:

“I presume he stays at Collingwood. I wouldn’t think he’s leaving, that’s my view, but I’d certainly be open-minded if Jamie is a free agent and wanted to move. But I haven’t heard that he’s moving.”

 

[MooreDaicos]

There will be a club that will make out like bandits when Tassie poaches one of their players.

The draft picks compensation will be elite.

Yes but who do we sell to get it? (Not Daicos)

 

[MooreDaicos]

Darcy moore is the only OOC player in 2028

Nope, not going through that again. His father did it in 1983, Darcy stays!

 

[gtrain23]

10 pages have I missed anything?
Or we still going on about how much of a flog may is and how we can change JUH?

 

[Scodog10]

Direct quote:

“I presume he stays at Collingwood. I wouldn’t think he’s leaving, that’s my view, but I’d certainly be open-minded if Jamie is a free agent and wanted to move. But I haven’t heard that he’s moving.”

In other words it won’t happen, but they’ve asked the question. Good on ‘em I say because it’s the exact same thing we’ve done with Curnow.

 

[MooreDaicos]

10 pages have I missed anything?
Or we still going on about how much of a flog may is and how we can change JUH?

We're talking about Tassies pick 5 and who we can sell. NOT Daicos x 2 or Moore.

 

[gtrain23]

We're talking about Tassies pick 5 and who we can sell. NOT Daicos x 2 or Moore.

This is getting way out of hand
Tassie won’t even agree to a stadium and we want pick 5?

 

[Doc1763]

This is getting way out of hand
Tassie won’t even agree to a stadium and we want pick 5?

if they offer 5 pick 1s for Nick, I'll think about it, then say no.

 

[jmac70]

Darcy moore is the only OOC player in 2028

I don’t think Hobart is cool enough for our Mr. Darcy.

 

[yeah man]

The comedy show continues

 

[jmac70]

The comedy show continues

These blokes need to STFU

 

[BillyElliott]

These blokes need to STFU

They've been banging on about Ashcroft all week. There was this other bloke called Rowell who won the Brownlow... but the only player they can think of for Tassie, is Nick.

 

[Scodog10]

The comedy show continues

The beauty is he’ll still be contracted so we’ll still hold the whip hand. Given the long term future of the club is tied to Nick I don’t think we’ll last long into 2028 before he extends because this shit will get tiring real quick.

 

[TW Sherrin]

if they offer 5 pick 1s for Nick, I'll think about it, then say no.

and David Putney

 

[Dead Eye Didak]

They've been banging on about Ashcroft all week. There was this other bloke called Rowell who won the Brownlow... but the only player they can think of for Tassie, is Nick.

What about Sam Darcy? He's a Unicorn, apparently....

 

[sideswipe]

The comedy show continues

Pretty sure the afl wouldn’t let Tassie blow their sign on dollars like that. What a moron.

 

[iGNITER]

and David Putney

I want my picks back and I want David GOD DAMN Putney, just because I feel like it.

​

 

[gouki88]

Pretty sure the afl wouldn’t let Tassie blow their sign on dollars like that. What a moron.

It would be absurd mismanagement of trying to build a list from scratch, to my eye.

Twomey does tend to get sucked into this kind of navel-gazing

 

[gouki88]

I don’t think Hobart is cool enough for our Mr. Darcy.

Bet he’d love Dark Mofo & all the hiking

 

[WanderingDude]

Everyone would have their own view on this, but for someone earning well over a mil a year, I am not sure it would move the needle when it would require a move to Tassie, ceasing to be a one club player, etc. If we are talking about Nicky D, I don't think that would be a compelling number on its own.

Just to present the opposing view the sign on bonus, player salary and marketing opportunities as a marquee player would be huge. The AFL is designing it to be hard to resist. The hard part would be lack of on field success.

 

[Scodog10]

Pretty sure the afl wouldn’t let Tassie blow their sign on dollars like that. What a moron.

He chose $3m because that’s the maximum they can spend on a single player with the sign on bonus. He also chose 2028 not 2029 when he enters FA because they no longer have access to the bonus in 2028.