Delisted Callum Ah Chee - Joins Adelaide via the PSD

[Crow till I die]

 

[ABAB]

ANB isn’t a dual premiership player Cal was actually playing injured for most of the season

He is a premiership player, same age when requested for a trade but was contracted.

 

[Soggy2112]

ANB isn’t a dual premiership player Cal was actually playing injured for most of the season

How many premierships a player has won is not super relevant to this discussion.

Rhys Stanley won 1 more premiership than Jim Stynes, does that make him a better player?

 

[cleanhands]

ANB isn’t a dual premiership player Cal was actually playing injured for most of the season

So you sold a broken down nag

 

[blueiris]

How many premierships a player has won is not super relevant to this discussion.

Rhys Stanley won 1 more premiership than Jim Stynes, does that make him a better player?

Ok don’t go asking for anything more than a 3rd when a Crom player comes out of contract that’s fair yeah

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

ANB isn’t a dual premiership player Cal was actually playing injured for most of the season

It's a mystery why Petracca with only 1 flag was traded for more than what the Crows were offering for Ah Chee.

Crazy that Curnow with no flags was traded for more than premiership hero Starcevich.

 

[blueiris]

So you sold a broken down nag

Broken down nag look again he was a duel premiership winner

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Ok don’t go asking for anything more than a 3rd when a Crom player comes out of contract that’s fair yeah

Murphy is all yours...

 

[blueiris]

It's a mystery why Petracca with only 1 flag was traded for more than what the Crows were offering for Ah Chee.

Crazy that Curnow with no flags was traded for more than premiership hero Starcevich.

Because Gold Coast and Swans do fair trades funny that

 

[blueiris]

Murphy is all yours...

Nah I’m good you keep him we have better defenders than him

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Because Gold Coast and Swans do fair trades funny that

Whoosh!

Premiership don't suddenly add a 2x premium for uncontracted players.

Easy to trade overs when gifted cheap talent with the northern academies. 1st round picks treated like confetti.

 

[ABAB]

Because Gold Coast and Swans do fair trades funny that

Everyone is saying it's overs because they were contracted funny that. Those clubs with Academy draftee throw picks like confetti, we would have done the same I guess funny that.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Nah I’m good you keep him we have better defenders than him

He's a forward!

Do you even watch football?

Granted i would prefer not to watch him either.

He's been delisted to make room for Ah Chee.

 

[blueiris]

Whoosh!

Premiership don't suddenly add a 2x premium for uncontracted players.

 

[blueiris]

He's a forward!

Do you even watch football?

Granted i would prefer not to watch him either.

He's been delisted to make room for Ah Chee.

I don’t watch Adelaide why would I watch Adelaide

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Agreed, Dom letting players go for nothing is incompetent.

 

[crowman2]

No it isn’t the thread has been how crom think not giving a fair trade

it’s about getting the best deal for your club

If the crows get him through the psd then they achieved what they set out to do

Conversely if we do get him that way Brisbane have failed to achieve the best for their club

Have I quoted anything incorrectly let me know

 

[blueiris]

Everyone is saying it's overs because they were contracted funny that. Those clubs with Academy draftee throw picks like confetti, we would have done the same I guess funny that.

No one said it was over what they said was a pick inside 25 Adelaide didn’t even bother looking for one

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

I don’t watch Adelaide why would I watch Adelaide

So you boycott Lions v Crows games.

That's wierd!

 

[blueiris]

So you boycott Lions v Crows games.

That's wierd!

Why is that weird not everyone watches every match

 

[ABAB]

No one said it was over what they said was a pick inside 25 Adelaide didn’t even bother looking for one

I was talking about what CGS and Sydney gave but both Petracca and Curnow were contracted.

 

[Soggy2112]

I have listed now going back the last 6-7 years, a number of trades involving players of similar age, ability and experience to Ah Chee. All of them involved similar picks to what Adelaide offered, and none of them include a pick slide similar to what people are suggesting Adelaide should have agreed to. If you can present a trade that indicates why Adelaide should have done so, please do.

In fact, looking back, there is one trade I did find.

Ablett, pick 24 and a future fourth was traded from Gold Coast to Geelong in exchange for pick 19 and a future second.

That, is effectively the same trade that Brisbane suggested for Ah Chee. Come on now…

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Why is that weird not everyone watches every match

I watch all Crows games.

Haven't missed a game since we came in the competition.

So why did you say Murphy was a defender if you don't watch our games?

You just make shit up?

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Question to the Crows faithful in here, if another club does pick up Ah Chee in the PSD will it change your thoughts on Reid's approach to the trade negotiations?

 

[Soggy2112]

Ok don’t go asking for anything more than a 3rd when a Crom player comes out of contract that’s fair yeah

Depends on the player.

If say, Ben Keays asked to leave, and a future second and future third was offered, I’d consider that a fair trade.

 

[blueiris]

Depends on the player.

If say, Ben Keays asked to leave, and a future second and future third was offered, I’d consider that a fair trade.

Of course you would because Ben has done absolutely nothing in he’s career