Analysis The Rebuilds of West Coast and Richmond and their Future Prospects

[Morro]

If you can’t spell some one’s name correctly you aren’t knowledgeable enough to comment on their junior playing career.

Pretty simple.

Even by your lofty standards, this is horse shit, but I know you would die on this hill if you had to which is both commendable and embarrassing

 

[Morro]

If you think Ginbey's kicking is bad, at 67.2% efficiency, you must think your dual best and fairest winner's is horrific beyond belief, at 53%




Queue "Yeah, but.." in T-minus 3, 2, 1.....

We do, TT is a terrible kick. He also plays inside mid, not int he backline where hitting a target should be easier

 

[Obeanie1]

You are making comparisons between a player who has been in the system for 3 years, against a kid , coming off a knee reco, who has played 7 games.
Good flex by you nevertheless

Pretty sure we were l comparing 1st year stat's when Ginbey started in the midfield.

So like for like. 1st year stat's v 1st year stat's.

Only difference is Hotton returning from injury.

A couple of Tigers posters hate Ginbey because Lalor was injured in a marking contest pre season. So they are grinding the axe and basically trolling Ginbey. And they don't like it when the comparisons to their kids output at the exact same stage in their careers doesn't look great.

It's a bit of a theme actually.

So no flex at all, just comparing players 1st year stats and output.

 

[Morro]

Pretty sure we were l comparing 1st year stat's when Ginbey started in the midfield.

So like for like. 1st year stat's v 1st year stat's.

Only difference is Hotton returning from injury.

A couple of Tigers posters hate Ginbey because Lalor was injured in a marking contest pre season. So they are grinding the axe and basically trolling Ginbey. And they don't like it when the comparisons to their kids output at the exact same stage in their careers doesn't look great.

It's a bit of a theme actually.

So no flex at all, just comparing players 1st year stats and output.

yeah nah same same eh

 

[Rich01]

Pretty sure we were l comparing 1st year stat's when Ginbey started in the midfield.

So like for like. 1st year stat's v 1st year stat's.

Only difference is Hotton returning from injury.

A couple of Tigers posters hate Ginbey because Lalor was injured in a marking contest pre season. So they are grinding the axe and basically trolling Ginbey. And they don't like it when the comparisons to their kids output at the exact same stage in their careers doesn't look great.

It's a bit of a theme actually.

So no flex at all, just comparing players 1st year stats and output.

Yeah I’m not sure why all the talk on Ginbey. He’s an important player for you guys all right. Just like Nathan Broad was over his career for us. If he can have a career similar to Broad that would be a great result.

 

[Shueygod]

Even by your lofty standards, this is horse shit, but I know you would die on this hill if you had to which is both commendable and embarrassing

Common sense.

 

[THE_GUN]

You are making comparisons between a player who has been in the system for 3 years, against a kid , coming off a knee reco, who has played 7 games.
Good flex by you nevertheless

Amazing

Imagine comparing a player to a 18 year old kid that barely got back on the park for a few games after a knee
lets give him a chance to delete that post and or edit it to another player instead. Im sure he didnt mean that

 

[THE_GUN]

Yeah I’m not sure why all the talk on Ginbey. He’s an important player for you guys all right. Just like Nathan Broad was over his career for us. If he can have a career similar to Broad that would be a great result.

If Ginbey reaches broad heights im sure most eagles supporter would love that
They do have 1 thing in common apparently both gave Jeremy cameron a bath ( broad did anyway )

 

[Shueygod]

Didn’t know 18 was too young to know how to hit a target by foot.

 

[Worm4]

Amazing

Imagine comparing a player to a 18 year old kid that barely got back on the park for a few games after a knee
lets give him a chance to delete that post and or edit it to another player instead. Im sure he didnt mean that

Im sure he did mean it . It was one of the more bizarre flexes ive seen on Bigfooty in my 25 years on here.

 

[THE_GUN]

Im sure he did mean it . It was one of the more bizarre flexes ive seen on Bigfooty in my 25 years on here.

It is a shame if that is the case as injury trolling is probably 1 of the worst things that cannot be accepted
I have had a fair bit to do with Shueygod whilst he supporters a rabble i dont think he would have trolled hotton deliberately

 

[Worm4]

It is a shame if that is the case as injury trolling is probably 1 of the worst things that cannot be accepted
I have had a fair bit to do with Shueygod whilst he supporters a rabble i dont think he would have trolled hotton deliberately

His old man was an oldie but a goodie during Carltons crapness early 2000's. I wish we picked him up to be honest

 

[THE_GUN]

His old man was an oldie but a goodie during Carltons crapness early 2000's. I wish we picked him up to be honest

Hotton of the Taj variety looks special and alot of Shai Bolton about him
Just hope the kid has a injury free career and shows his talents

His brother is now also at Punt Road in our VFL team

 

[Shueygod]

Didn’t realise Hottons knee made him incapable of hitting a target by foot, really unfortunate sign for the future.

Probably a waste of a pick if he can never overcome that.

 

[Meteoric Rise]

Didn’t realise Hottons knee made him incapable of hitting a target by foot, really unfortunate sign for the future.

Probably a waste of a pick if he can never overcome that.

You are backing Ginbey to have a better career than Taj Hotton, or not?

 

[THE_GUN]

You are backing Ginbey to have a better career than Taj Hotton, or not?

Thats like comparing Nathan Broad to Shai Bolton in talent

 

[Meteoric Rise]

Thats like comparing Nathan Broad to Shai Bolton in talent

I just want to get it straight what he is saying here. Reuben was a 2 score involvement a game midfielder before being banished to defence, where he has continued to butcher the Sherrin.

So the bar is set low for Taj, who would seriously need to be destroyed by injuries to not surpass the human gimp Ginbey.

 

[Shueygod]

You are backing Ginbey to have a better career than Taj Hotton, or not?

Ginbey is more likely to be All Australian than Hotton 100%.

 

[Meteoric Rise]

Ginbey is more likely to be All Australian than Hotton 100%.

Not sure how you figure that, but let's run with it.

You must think Darcy Byrne-Jones has had a better career than Nick Vlastuin then.

 

[THE_GUN]

Not sure how you figure that, but let's run with it.

You must think Darcy Byrne-Jones has had a better career than Nick Vlastuin then.

Could also be a long term replacement for Liam Duggan if he plays to his potential

 

[Shueygod]

Not sure how you figure that, but let's run with it.

You must think Darcy Byrne-Jones has had a better career than Nick Vlastuin then.

What an odd comparison.

Could also be a long term replacement for Liam Duggan if he plays to his potential

He’s already better than Duggan, will be a better version of Vlastuin if he plays to his potential, and I rate Vlastuin very very highly.

 

[Meteoric Rise]

Could also be a long term replacement for Liam Duggan if he plays to his potential

Duggan knows how to miss an opposition chest from 30 metres. Gumbey doesn't.

 

[THE_GUN]

What an odd comparison.

He’s already better than Duggan, will be a better version of Vlastuin if he plays to his potential, and I rate Vlastuin very very highly.

Vlastuin will be a 300 game 3 x premiership player that has proven to be a GUN defense player over nearly 15 years
To be a better version of Vlastuin he would really have to get a move on

At the same age Vlastuin was averaging 2 possessions more with 7% less time on ground and 10% better disposal efficiency.

Lets hope for the eagles sake he does become the next Vlastuin and not Duggan

 

[Shueygod]

Vlastuin will be a 300 game 3 x premiership player that has proven to be a GUN defense player over nearly 15 years
To be a better version of Vlastuin he would really have to get a move on

At the same age Vlastuin was averaging 2 possessions more with 7% less time on ground and 10% better disposal efficiency.

Lets hope for the eagles sake he does become the next Vlastuin and not Duggan

Yep, Vlastuin is/was a star. If you liked watching him you’ll love watching Ginbey the next 10+ years.

 

[ShereKhan]

Fantastic cherry picking, very well done mate.

Ginbeys best position is defence
Bo Allan you can’t even spell his name right, don’t tell us what his best position is.
Hough
Hewett clearly haven’t watched his clearance work, has had no preseasons since getting to the club and still had a very good year through the middle.

'Very Good Year' through the middle....really?

Hewett v Thomson Dow

Rating: 7.52 v 6.94
Disposals: 16.3 v 18.5
DE%: 64.3% v 72.1%
SI's: 4.0 v 3.2
Tackles: 3.5 v 2.9
Clearances: 3.3 v 2.7
Goals: 0.5 v 0.1

Thomson Dow was just delisted.