It's Time To Delist The Muppets!

[Breakthelines]

Who is going to be delisted now we have finished trade week.....

Pies Gained: Wood & Pick #96 (Jaxson Barham)

Pies Lost: Pick #14 & Davies (Delistment was going to happen anyway)

Who will join Buckley, Clement, Licca & Davies?

 

[BEEG]

Who is going to be delisted now we have finished trade week.....

Pies Gained: Wood & Pick #96 (Jaxson Barham)

Pies Lost: Pick #14 & Davies (Delistment was going to happen anyway)

Who will join Buckley, Clement, Licca & Davies?

Toovey Niccols will be delisted Mccaffer will stay Rookie list and Wellingham and Clarke will be elevated

 

[OniAu]

so glad how the trade week has turned out for us , havent traded away any young guys, got our ruckman and got ben davies to another club to give him the chance he deserves.

happy here!

add richards to the delist list

 

[sirlothie]

so glad how the trade week has turned out for us , havent traded away any young guys, got our ruckman and got ben davies to another club to give him the chance he deserves.

happy here!

add richards to the delist list

Yeah I'm rapt but personally I had slim hopes we could upgrade to an earlier 2nd round pick for Lonie...

Hiney is gonna have his work cut out this year...

This will prove if he really is a genius Having said that I don't think in this draft we could have done better than Wood at 14...

 

[Kirby]

I'd say there are still 2 players left to chop before the draft if we elevate Clark (certainty) and Wellingham (possibly).

If it was up to me it would be bye bye Lonie and Toovey.

 

[Bloben]

This year we were one ruckman short with only 3 (fraser, stretch, Bryan). If the story is true about not renewing Richards contract, that says to me that we are looking at drafting another ruckman. We really need to have 4 as a minimum. If we don't want to draft a ruckman then neither Richards or Bryan should be delisted.

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

Bucks, Clement and Licca retired, and Richards and Toovey would be the first two cut, with Lonie potentially behind them.

Marty Clarke to be elevated, possibly alongside Sharrod Wellingham.

If we were to elevate both, we would still use picks #31, #47, #63 and get Jaxson Barham at #79.

 

[sirlothie]

This year we were one ruckman short with only 3 (fraser, stretch, Bryan). If the story is true about not renewing Richards contract, that says to me that we are looking at drafting another ruckman. We really need to have 4 as a minimum. If we don't want to draft a ruckman then neither Richards or Bryan should be delisted.

I hope we get Sampler's man Renton with our first, take a punt on a in and under mid with our 3rd rounder.

We could do with another key defender prospect to develop but with our picks and depth of draft I doubt there is much on offer... Someone really needs to step up next year at FB/CHB... O'Brien will get the first crack at CHB IMO, Presti at FB and Wakelin if there is a 3rd tall... Maxwell in the mix somewhere of course too.

 

[OniAu]

also i know theres a lot of hate for toovey on this board lol
im not defending

but wasnt he only drafted last year? anyone know the details of what pick etc?

 

[4#Didak#4]

We are not well positioned in the draft this year at all. Please Derek have something up your sleeve. Hopefully the draft is as thin as it sounds.

If we have some talent lined up late in the draft we may cut more than 2 but if not we may just cut one or 2 & sit tight. Bring on the Irish rookies.

 

[sirlothie]

also i know theres a lot of hate for toovey on this board lol
im not defending

but wasnt he only drafted last year? anyone know the details of what pick etc?

He started on the Rookie list in 2006 and had a good year with Willy... this year he went back a step though and in the few AFL games he got he seemed to be lacking something, looked slightly out of place.

I'd say his position is looking hairy because we aren't short on his type...

Apparently he held down a KP at Willy but at 189cm he wouldn't cut it as KP for Collingwood...

 

[shawthing09]

I see us making a maximum of 4 picks in the draft and 2 elevations so 6 list spots at max. With Davies Licca Celement and Bucks all gone that is 4 already. If we need 2 more delistings Richards and Toovey are the favourites with Lonie, Cook and Iles as extremely unlikely and possibly unfair candidates.

 

[OniAu]

He started on the Rookie list in 2006 and had a good year with Willy... this year he went back a step though and in the few AFL games he got he seemed to be lacking something, looked slightly out of place.

I'd say his position is looking hairy because we aren't short on his type...

Apparently he held down a KP at Willy but at 189cm he wouldn't cut it as KP for Collingwood...

thanks for that understanding why some people are favouring him to be delisted , for some reason i thought he was only taken in last years draft , i dunno why.

its pretty much theres no positions for him as far as i can see, the positions he would fit into he wouldnt be first option.

 

[doppleganger]

Shows we are travelling pretty well when we dont really have to many muppets to delist!

Even a bloke like Davies managed to find himself a spot on another top4 teams list!!

Very good list atm

 

[sirlothie]

thanks for that understanding why some people are favouring him to be delisted , for some reason i thought he was only taken in last years draft , i dunno why.

its pretty much theres no positions for him as far as i can see, the positions he would fit into he wouldnt be first option.

Yeah it's true, he kind of like how Lonie, Holland end up. They aren't that bad players but we just have better in their positions now.

It's a good problem

 

[Bloben]

Shows we are travelling pretty well when we dont really have to many muppets to delist!

Even a bloke like Davies managed to find himself a spot on another top4 teams list!!

Very good list atm

very good point

 

[FIGJAM]

Delist: Alan Toovey - Toovey in action after creating yet another spotfire.

 

[Myzer]

i think lonie will get one more year to prove himself. i think holland is in some trouble. toovey should go. he played well in the game v richmond with 3 goals but his remaining games were poor to say the least. he seemed lost out there.

i would have like to see us trade lonie & davies for a second round pick rather than just give davies away for 96.

 

[Breakthelines]

Retired:

Buckley
Clement
Licca

Traded:

Davies

Gained:

Wood

Picks In Draft:

31, 47, 63, 79, 95 & 96 = (Jaxson Barham)

Delist:

Toovey
Richards
Cox
Macaffer (Rookie)
Nicholes (Rookie)

Giving Us:

6 places on our list to work with. Upgrade Clarke & retain Wellingham...Dyas onto rookine...leaving us 2 rookie spots also.

 

[Bloben]

Retired:

Buckley
Clement
Licca

Traded:

Davies

Gained:

Wood

Picks In Draft:

31, 47, 63, 79, 95 & 96 = (Jaxson Barham)

Delist:

Toovey
Richards
Cox
Macaffer (Rookie)
Nicholes (Rookie)

Giving Us:

6 places on our list to work with. Upgrade Clarke & retain Wellingham...Dyas onto rookine...leaving us 2 rookie spots also.

No way should we delist Cox. That would leave us 5 spots. Wellingham and Clarke up and draft 3. Not a deep draft so would rather keep the talent we have.

 

[bradrowe#32]

Delist:

Toovey
Richards
Cox
Macaffer (Rookie)
Nicholes (Rookie)

Giving Us:

6 places on our list to work with. Upgrade Clarke & retain Wellingham...Dyas onto rookine...leaving us 2 rookie spots also.

Why??

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Senior list

Out
Buckley
Clement
Licuria
Davies

In
Barham (father-son)
Clarke (rookie promotion)
Wood (trade)

Thats net only 1 lost player
Take Barham with our fourth pick (79) and that leaves us with two more to delist

Richards
Toovey

If we want to take Barham with our fifth pick (95) that leaves us with another player to delist

Lonie

If we want to take Barham with our sixth pick (96) God knows whos next on the block

maybe Iles

Rookie list
Clarke - promoted
Wellingham - retained
Nicholls - dropped
McAffer - no harm in retaining for one more year in a shallow draft

Dyas - brought in

 

[FIGJAM]

Retired:

Buckley
Clement
Licca

Traded:

Davies

Gained:

Wood

Picks In Draft:

31, 47, 63 = (Jaxson Barham)

Delist:

Toovey
Richards
Macaffer (Rookie)
Nicholes (Rookie)

Giving Us:

Upgrade Clarke & Wellingham...Dyas onto rookie...leaving us 3 rookie spots also.

Edited to show you my opinion and to fix factual errors.

Please understand that we are not obliged to use Pick 96. That we a gift trade.

In:
1. Cameron Wood
2. Martin Clarke
3. Sharod Wellingham
4. Jaxon Barham
5. Second Round Draft Pick
6. Third Round Draft Pick

Out:
1. Nathan Buckley
2. James Clement
3. Paul Licuria
4. Ben Davies
5. Guy Richards
6. Alan Toovey

-------------------

Whilst the three legends leaving the Club cannot be ignored, neither can the fact that they were not solely responsible for our good performance this year.

With C-Wood, Irish and The Boot, we have three guys I rate very highly (and thus far we have only dropped a first round pick).

Add Barham who has a bit to work with for a last round pick, and we're looking like we've had a good draft 6 weeks before the draft is held!

Then draft wisely with the second and third round picks and we've got plenty to look forward to.

 

[XD9X]

also i know theres a lot of hate for toovey on this board lol
im not defending

but wasnt he only drafted last year? anyone know the details of what pick etc?

There was discussion backward and forward about whether Toovey would make it, the no's where only just winning, then stepped out Toovey one night, and showed us maybe yes's that the "no's" were well and truley right, and Toovey was banished pretty much by Mick and the supporters that night.

Description; Do you know that Marajuana add where the kid drops an easy chest mark, and the coach says "I don't know what has gotten into him", we Toovey did those drops, again, and again, and his kicks went side ways, and he missed handballs, got caught for holding the ball, and that was just in the one play. He looked like a school kid, who won the daunting prize of playing for your favourite AFL club. Unfortunately his club was ours. But we said that night, not for long Toovey old chap, like Tooheys Blue, it is tossed to the side, whilst we have another dip at trying to get a kid with the guts to play AFL footy. As the footy gods where giving out guts, Toovey thought they said Nuts, and as a pr0n star, Toovey is your man, but as a footballer, the nuts don't cut it.

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

In:
1. Cameron Wood
2. Martin Clarke
3. Sharod Wellingham
4. Jaxon Barham
5. Second Round Draft Pick
6. Third Round Draft Pick

Out:
1. Nathan Buckley
2. James Clement
3. Paul Licuria
4. Ben Davies
5. Guy Richards
6. Alan Toovey

Agree except I wouldnt promote Wellingham - better off to use an extra draft pick, bump Barham back, and have additional depth.