Who is Carl-tanks Best No. 1?

[Collins-Langford-Ayres]

Looks like they have unearthed another ripper. In nearly a full team of Blues stars against half a Hawks side, Sam Walsh sent the Tankers faithful into erectile joy by getting a few touches, making a tackle stick and showing up a few of his navy blue witches-hat teammates.

So when careers end, who is your choice of the greatest Carltank number 1 pick? It's tough - they've had a few...

 

[NetworkNerd]

I'd vote Marc Murphy but he isn't an option in the poll

 

[A Cut Above]

Voted Sam Walsh. 0 AFL games played yet still comfortably ahead Murphy, Clearasil & Sqibbs

 

[jackster83]

Can you add this year's pick #1 to the poll?

kthxbai

 

[Hawk Dork]

Voted Sam Walsh. 0 AFL games played yet still comfortably ahead Murphy, Clearasil & Sqibbs

Just oozes potential

 

[Socrates2]

It's hard to say but it's fair to say they would have been better players at other clubs.Carlton has ruined these players by overplaying them too early.

 

[Hawk Dork]

It's hard to say but it's fair to say they would have been better players at other clubs.Carlton has ruined these players by overplaying them too early.

and picking hem so early in the drafts.
Imagine being the best young talent,ready to make a name for yourself and getting picked by Carlton it would be soul destroying.

 

[Dinsdale]

Just oozes potential

he's Carltons (new) Jarrad Waite.

 

[Mofra]

he's Carltons (new) Jarrad Waite.

Walsh to North in 2028 confirmed

 

[Socrates2]

Another good question would be, 'Is Ben Silvagni the worst player ever drafted?'
By all reports he's Bambi on ice and is below VFL seconds standards.

 

[hawkman]

Looks like they have unearthed another ripper. In nearly a full team of Blues stars against half a Hawks side, Sam Walsh sent the Tankers faithful into erectile joy by getting a few touches, making a tackle stick and showing up a few of his navy blue witches-hat teammates

Gibbs, Murphy, Kreuzer and Weitering all started out that way too. The issue will be can he avoid being dragged into the Carlton black hole of wasting talent

 

[Zoom]

Probably this guy:

 

[Pessimistic]

Is that Welsh or Watts?

 

[Pessimistic]

Another good question would be, 'Is Ben Silvagni the worst player ever drafted?'
By all reports he's Bambi on ice and is below VFL seconds standards.

Dad can hoover up all the GWS rejects just to make him look good

 

[Groin guru]

What a train wreck Weitering has been. Zac Dawson-like in his impact as a KPP

 

[Mofra]

What a train wreck Weitering has been. Zac Dawson-like in his impact as a KPP

Carlton friend loves him but thinks he's the softest KPP seen in Carlton colours. Runs off the ground screaming for the doctor if he gets a mozzie bite.

They have one good KPD - Marchbank. Jones is mediocre but looks spectacular doing it.

Carlton's best players were not no 1 picks. Docherty (sadly), Cripps and Curnow are head and shoulders above the rest. Marc Murphy is ok but about as inspiring as homebrand white bread.

 

[Groin guru]

Carlton friend loves him but thinks he's the softest KPP seen in Carlton colours. Runs off the ground screaming for the doctor if he gets a mozzie bite.

They have one good KPD - Marchbank. Jones is mediocre but looks spectacular doing it.

Carlton's best players were not no 1 picks. Docherty (sadly), Cripps and Curnow are head and shoulders above the rest. Marc Murphy is ok but about as inspiring as homebrand white bread.

I agree. On a mongrel scale Weitering is a -2. Need be a competitive animal to play that position. Might end up being another Jack Watts.

Docherty is a huge loss. I hope he gets back to his pre-injury form.

 

[brett15]

thread title could be "who is Carlton's best player?' and there'd be just as much confusion

 

[Mofra]

thread title could be "who is Carlton's best player?' and there'd be just as much confusion

Gibbs, easily.

 

[Isaac Cumming No 1]

Looks like they have unearthed another ripper. In nearly a full team of Blues stars against half a Hawks side, Sam Walsh sent the Tankers faithful into erectile joy by getting a few touches, making a tackle stick and showing up a few of his navy blue witches-hat teammates.

So when careers end, who is your choice of the greatest Carltank number 1 pick? It's tough - they've had a few...

View attachment 623470

Lambs to the slaughter. I can't watch.

 

[chelseacarlton]

This might your best work to date, not that it would too difficult to top, but yes, your best work.

 

[Black Flag]

gibbsy.

footy output + sales value = greatest eva net output.

 

[Thrawn]

Carlton friend loves him but thinks he's the softest KPP seen in Carlton colours. Runs off the ground screaming for the doctor if he gets a mozzie bite.

They have one good KPD - Marchbank. Jones is mediocre but looks spectacular doing it.

Carlton's best players were not no 1 picks. Docherty (sadly), Cripps and Curnow are head and shoulders above the rest. Marc Murphy is ok but about as inspiring as homebrand white bread.

You mention Murphy but not Simpson?