Round 3 Trades (with POLL)

[MrChristo]

Isaac Heeney #supercoach averages

2019
LOSES (2) =76
less than 20 disp (2) =76

2018*
LOSES (8) =84
WINS (14) =103

less than 20 disp (7) =84
20 or more disp (15) =102

How many games do we see Sydney winning though?
Maybe 4 wins through until Rd. 14, I reckon. Even then I reckon they drop 1 of the next 'winnable' 2.

Injured. Poor team. Move on. (and possibly buy back later at a huge discount.)

 

[Andrew Birch]

So CARL playing Old Man Simpson in a different role this year ......owners will be over-joyed

What role might that be? I thought he was playing the same role as the last few years...

 

[gutsroy]

Not SC related but for anyone that wants a good laugh, go to the swans board and take a gander at the OP for the round 3 preview thread. Leaves nothing to the imagination on where they think Mills and Heeney should be playing. It's a great write up and very funny.

Saw that the other day, too. Very cutting.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Trade Simpson to a better performing premo in def
Or
Trade to Rockliff via dursma dpp
Or
Hold Simpson


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Post team.

Simmo been poo you might have more pressing issues.

 

[Requiem]

Andrew Birch, you know I love Caleb Daniel, do you think he will be a top 6 this season?

 

[Andrew Birch]

Andrew Birch, you know I love Caleb Daniel, do you think he will be a top 6 this season?

I like him, but I'm not that bullish about him, otherwise I would have started him myself. I reckon he'll average low 90's. Top10-15

 

[Requiem]

I like him, but I'm not that bullish about him, otherwise I would have started him myself. I reckon he'll average low 90's. Top10-15

That's my feeling too, cheers for the second opinion.

Forwards are really hard to predict this year, especially the top 6.

 

[Daniel McL]

Forwards are really hard to predict this year, especially the top 6.

Dangerfield, Hawkins, Menegola, Kelly, Dahlhaus, Parfitt

Simples

 

[Requiem]

Dangerfield, Hawkins, Menegola, Kelly, Dahlhaus, Parfitt

Simples

 

[rocker_oz33]

Dangerfield, Hawkins, Menegola, Kelly, Dahlhaus, Parfitt

Simples

Stop posting my forward line campaigner...

 

[BEEG]

Requiem still on the Heeney train?

 

[Waspy79]

Heeney and Witherden are my only ‘mistakes’.

Are Newman and Kelly worth the loss of 2 trades?

It would be ruthless to cut Witherden after an 87 average but it is tempting.

 

[BEEG]

Whats the best options for my team? Thanks in advance

View attachment 646884

Greene to Parker
Heeney to Kelly

Use the spare cash next week on upgrading Goldy to Grundy

 

[Requiem]

Requiem still on the Heeney train?

Touché

He was a before injury, so I'm giving him 1 more chance.

 

[joop]

Heeney and Witherden are my only ‘mistakes’.

Are Newman and Kelly worth the loss of 2 trades?

It would be ruthless to cut Witherden after an 87 average but it is tempting.

why is it tempting? surely you have bigger fish to fry.

 

[BEEG]

Heeney and Witherden are my only ‘mistakes’.

Are Newman and Kelly worth the loss of 2 trades?

It would be ruthless to cut Witherden after an 87 average but it is tempting.

Newman only averaging 108 can he stay around the 90/100 mark? If you think he can I would pull the trigger.

Heeney has to go wasn't a fan off the preseason and got sucked into taking him, I traded him out for Parker and upgraded Wagner to Neale.

 

[BEEG]

Touché

He was a before injury, so I'm giving him 1 more chance.

Had a full preseason the first since being drafted.

Sydney sucks the scores out of these exciting blokes if there not a grinding ball winner they become shit house.

Parker slowly lost his way aswell.

Lloyd the only decent Sydney player I would take in SC

 

[Daniel McL]

View attachment 646909

 

[Waspy79]

why is it tempting? surely you have bigger fish to fry.

Not really. I am pretty happy with my squad.

The temptation is to make $60k and increase my scoring by 5-10 ppr. A true luxury trade.

 

[Marlowe]

I didn’t trade any of them out and I’m trading Heeney. He’s got an ankle injury which the coach has said he ‘hopes’ he can play through, he doesn’t train until later in the week, he’s playing forward and scoring shit aaaaand he’s gonna lose a dick load of value.
Absolute no brainer for me.

All good reasons to trade him out.

I have no confidence on who to bring in that will for sure outscore him over the course of the season, though, and only based on only two games so far.

If he were a midfielder (like Dusty), there'd a plethora of options to move to. Forwards a lot more suspect though. Tim Kelly and that's about it. And then you'll have to trade Heeney back in again at some point.

I also bring up Grundy/Gawn/Oliver because people overreacted and brought in the likes of Westhoff and Coniglio and cost themselves ~90 points in one week.

We all undersell that a hot rookie can outscore a premo in any given week too. You trade Heeney to Boak this week and Setterfield on your bench could wind up outscoring both of them.

 

[Requiem]

Had a full preseason the first since being drafted.

Sydney sucks the scores out of these exciting blokes if there not a grinding ball winner they become shit house.

Parker slowly lost his way aswell.

Lloyd the only decent Sydney player I would take in SC

100% agreed, I posted pretty much the same thing yesterday.

Horse is SC cancer.

 

[Requiem]

View attachment 646916

 

[Marlowe]

Dangerfield, Hawkins, Menegola, Kelly, Dahlhaus, Parfitt

Simples

Kind of want that tbh, after the byes. At least the top 4.

 

[Bollox]

Hai gaiz, I'm ranked 28 overall and just hoping for a bit of advice so I don't fall out of the top 30 if that's possible

It's my first season playing any fantasy football format whatsoever.. in fact I just started watching AFL last year

Anyway, I'm considering going Sloane to Rockliff this week.

Is that too sideways? Just trying to stay in touch with the top 10. You know how it is.

Appreciate any feedback

 

[Requiem]

Hai gaiz, I'm ranked 28 overall and just hoping for a bit of advice so I don't fall out of the top 30 if that's possible

It's my first season playing any fantasy football format whatsoever.. in fact I just started watching AFL last year


Anyway, I'm considering going Sloane to Rockliff this week.

Is that too sideways? Just trying to stay in touch with the top 10. You know how it is.



Appreciate any feedback