Competitions Best ever Crows players - FINAL - A. McLeod vs M. Ricciuto - Mea Culpa for ruining our season with the delay :(

[Samcro24]

Is Fred still in hiding?

 

[moogerfooger]

Wouldn't it be more interesting comparing like for like players? Jacobs v Rehn, McGuinness v Goodwin?

Comparing an ant with an elephant seems pointless.

 

[adelaidecrows]

Doesn’t get much easier than this one

McGuinness by length of flemington straight

Second this. Younger Crows fans dont understand just how good McGuiness, McDermott and Andrew Jarman were in the early days.

 

[dogs105]

Final qualifying match-up is

[PLAYERCARD]Jordan Dawson[/PLAYERCARD]
45 games
16 goals
All Australian 2023
Showdown medal 2022, 2023
2nd B&F 2022

Vs

Greg Anderson
59 games
19 goals
All Australian 1993

 

[dogs105]

Can we please have a poll reset again CrowinNT, Scorpus, brucetiki, Drugs Are Bad Mackay? , relapse ?

[PLAYERCARD]Jordan Dawson[/PLAYERCARD] vs Greg Anderson.

Thank you!

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

Can we please have a poll reset again CrowinNT, Scorpus, brucetiki, Drugs Are Bad Mackay? , relapse ?

Jordan Dawson vs Greg Anderson.

Thank you!

Did you want to bother including Anderson as a voting option?

 

[dogs105]

Did you want to bother including Anderson as a voting option?

He was top 32 in your thread...

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

 

[bootrossbootross]

The last paragraph says everything you need to know regarding the folly of rating ruckmen based upon hitouts won.

not to mention in era's that are vastly different in game style.

 

[Samcro24]

 

[morris086]

It would appear there's currently two posters who need a bit of a refresh:

 

[adelaidecrows]

View attachment 1818543

People who voted Jacobs, lord......

 

[Bovo]

Jacobs v Aaron Keating

On SM-A325F using BigFooty.com mobile app

Wait! Are you comparing a premiership player to Jacob’s? Lol. I mean the answer is obvious, but it’s so funny

 

[dogs105]

Will post the draw for the final 32 this afternoon

 

[Slippery Pete]

This thread moves slower than a wet week.

C’mon Dogs, get some speed on the ball son.

 

[dogs105]

[PLAYERCARD]Andrew McLeod[/PLAYERCARD] (1)
[PLAYERCARD]Mark Ricciuto[/PLAYERCARD] (2)
Darren Jarman (3)
Tony Modra (4)
Shaun Rehn (5)
[PLAYERCARD]Ben Hart[/PLAYERCARD] (6)
[PLAYERCARD]Nigel Smart[/PLAYERCARD] (7)
Kane Johnson (8)
[PLAYERCARD]Taylor Walker[/PLAYERCARD]
Patrick Dangerfield
Scott Thompson
Eddie Betts
Matthew Robran
[PLAYERCARD]Mark Stevens[/PLAYERCARD]
[PLAYERCARD]Tyson Edwards[/PLAYERCARD]
[PLAYERCARD]Ben Rutten[/PLAYERCARD]
[PLAYERCARD]Mark Bickley[/PLAYERCARD]
[PLAYERCARD]Daniel Talia[/PLAYERCARD]
Tony McGuinness
Andrew Jarman
[PLAYERCARD]Rory Sloane[/PLAYERCARD]
[PLAYERCARD]Simon Goodwin[/PLAYERCARD]
Graham Johncock
[PLAYERCARD]Rory Laird[/PLAYERCARD]
[PLAYERCARD]Brodie Smith[/PLAYERCARD]
John Klug
Chris McDermott
[PLAYERCARD]Peter Vardy[/PLAYERCARD]
[PLAYERCARD]Jordan Dawson[/PLAYERCARD]
Rod Jameson
Peter Caven
David Pittman

Unseeded players placed into random.org and returned:

1. Rory Laird
2. Mark Bickley
3. Scott Thompson
4. Jordan Dawson
5. David Pittman
6. Rod Jameson
7. Andrew Jarman
8. Chris McDermott
9. Eddie Betts
10. Matthew Robran
11. Graham Johncock
12. Ben Rutten
13. Peter Vardy
14. Taylor Walker
15. Brodie Smith
16. Rory Sloane
17. Mark Stevens
18. Daniel Talia
19. John Klug
20. Peter Caven
21. Simon Goodwin
22. Tyson Edwards
23. Tony McGuinness
24. Patrick Dangerfield

So we have:

[PLAYERCARD]Andrew McLeod[/PLAYERCARD] (1) vs [PLAYERCARD]Rory Laird[/PLAYERCARD]
[PLAYERCARD]Mark Bickley[/PLAYERCARD] vs Scott Thompson
[PLAYERCARD]Jordan Dawson[/PLAYERCARD] vs David Pittman
Rod Jameson vs Kane Johnson (8)

Tony Modra (4) vs Andrew Jarman
Chris McDermott vs Eddie Betts
Matthew Robran vs Graham Johncock
[PLAYERCARD]Ben Rutten[/PLAYERCARD] vs Shaun Rehn (5)

Darren Jarman (3) vs [PLAYERCARD]Peter Vardy[/PLAYERCARD]
[PLAYERCARD]Taylor Walker[/PLAYERCARD] vs [PLAYERCARD]Brodie Smith[/PLAYERCARD]
[PLAYERCARD]Rory Sloane[/PLAYERCARD] vs [PLAYERCARD]Mark Stevens[/PLAYERCARD]
[PLAYERCARD]Daniel Talia[/PLAYERCARD] vs [PLAYERCARD]Ben Hart[/PLAYERCARD] (6)

[PLAYERCARD]Mark Ricciuto[/PLAYERCARD] (2) vs John Klug
Peter Caven vs [PLAYERCARD]Simon Goodwin[/PLAYERCARD]
[PLAYERCARD]Tyson Edwards[/PLAYERCARD] vs Tony McGuinness
Patrick Dangerfield vs [PLAYERCARD]Nigel Smart[/PLAYERCARD] (7)

 

[dogs105]

Andrew McLeod
All-Australian 1998, 2000, 2001, 2006, 2007(c)
Best and Fairest 1997, 2001, 2007
AFL MVP 2001
2 time premiership player
Norm Smith Medal 1997, 1998
preseason premiership 2003
Michael Tuck medal 2003
Showdown medallist 2007
Rising star nominee 1995
2nd B&F 1999, 2000
3rd B&F 1998, 2003
4th B&F 2004, 2005, 2006

vs

Rory Laird
All-Australian 2017, 2018
Best and Fairest 2018, 2020, 2021
Rising star nominee 2013
2nd B&F 2015, 2020
3rd B&F 2017, 2019

 

[dogs105]

Drugs Are Bad Mackay? , CrowinNT , relapse , brucetiki , Scorpus
Could you please reset poll for McLeod vs Laird? Thank you!

 

[crows dude]

McLeod easy

 

[cleanhands]

Drugs Are Bad Mackay? , CrowinNT , relapse , brucetiki , Scorpus
Could you please reset poll for McLeod vs Laird? Thank you!

Don’t bother landslide

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

Brutal for Lairdy!

 

[whattagun07]

Kane Johnson seeded 8th?!

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Don’t bother landslide

No sane person will vote Laird.

May as well keep Macca & Roo out of it til final 4.

I like you Lairdy, but no chance in hell.

 

[Rory Walkerfield]

Poor Lairdy - he never stood a chance.

 

[dogs105]

McLeod out to an early lead, but still plenty of time for Lairdy...