2008 Keepers

[Hodges]

Team for this round will be:

Backline

C Cornes
Shaw
Birchall
Mattner --> upgrade
Symes --> possible upgrade
Ellis --> upgrade
Pfeiffer --> upgrade

Mids

Corey
Cross
Mitchell
Stevens --> possible upgrade
Houli --> upgrade
Palmer --> upgrade

Forwards

Pav
Brown
Riewoldt
Franklin
Didak --> possible upgrade
Porps --> possible upgrade
Deledio --> possible upgrade

I think Didak and Porps will end up being keepers. Only really need to add Chapman to forwards and they are finished. I think Symes will be a keeper, but not so sold on Stevens.

 

[stainedclass]

I think Birchall Is a keeper.anyone else?

 

[demonboy13]

YES!! for sure....

he most certainly is....

he will not have a massive average of 95 at the end of the year but it will be between 80 and 90

the thing with birchall is he is super consistant and gets relatively similar scores week in, week out!!

he is more than handy all year round!!

 

[MarkJohnson#1]

I think Birchall Is a keeper.anyone else?

Unless injured, definate keeper.

 

[Kenny_01]

don't see why Johncock is a keeper and Porpz a possible upgrade. to me, they'd both probably score about the same.

Not too many quality defenders to be honest so I think it is safe keeping Johncock.

 

[AdamG03]

i'd go with Riewoldt; SJ is the more riskier choice. Gram for Waters? smells a bit side ways, but bringing Pav in is a good move. not sure if Aker is injured, but wouldn't trade him out just because he's playing Sydney soon.

Thanks for the advice, I'm thinking and hoping Riewoldt is a better long term option.

Gram for Waters is pretty sideways but i really just want to get Gram out as soon as possible.

I'm also observing how Marcus Drum is gonna go in his second game, scored 95 last week and on the HBF or HFF, he can give them a lot of run. Harvey just needs to play him.

 

[LemmingMaster]

Marcus Drum is risky, he gets injured a heap.

 

[Porps_is_HOT_loz]

Is Robert Murphy a keeper???

 

[richo1982]

Is Robert Murphy a keeper???

he is if u have him but he definitely isnt worth picking up