2012 Rookies

[MightyMark]

Is it worth getting Harry Cunningham or Simon Hogan?

And also, who (not just the two above) are the better round 12 bye rookies (any position)? This is troubling me so much!!

Hogan should see a fair bit of game time. His disposal is questionable, but he will find the ball without any issues.

As far as midfielders go for round 12, Kavangh from essendon will probably play a reasonable amount of games, Magner from Melbourne if he is elevated.

 

[Vapor]

Does anyone know if Weedon and Crozier are likely to start round 1 games?

 

[MightyMark]

Does anyone know if Weedon and Crozier are likely to start round 1 games?

Weedon more so than Crozier.

 

[Molian]

C, Wingard (PORT) or S, Coniglio (GWS)??

I currently have Wingard, he was one of my first selected i think, but after another couple of swaps i now have $22,000 left over, so is it worth spending it on Coniglio or just leave it in the bank?

Any answers and reasons very much appreciated.


*Sorry if this has been previously discussed.

 

[MightyMark]

C, Wingard (PORT) or S, Coniglio (GWS)??

I currently have Wingard, he was one of my first selected i think, but after another couple of swaps i now have $22,000 left over, so is it worth spending it on Coniglio or just leave it in the bank?

Any answers and reasons very much appreciated.


*Sorry if this has been previously discussed.

Keep Wingard, the kid is a star. Save the 22K and use it in an upgrade later on.

 

[Molian]

Keep Wingard, the kid is a star. Save the 22K and use it in an upgrade later on.

Thanks mate, appreciate it.
I think that's what i wanted to do just wanted some confirmation.

 

[MightyMark]

Thanks mate, appreciate it.
I think that's what i wanted to do just wanted some confirmation.

They should probably score the same, but if you take Coniglio, you will be kicking yourself if you come a few grand short on an upgrade.

 

[Foxx]

Koby Stevens or James mcdonald

 

[MightyMark]

Koby Stevens or James mcdonald

I get the feeling most will say McDonald, but I much prefer Stevens. McDonald didn't do much to impress me over the NAB cup.

 

[Foxx]

I get the feeling most will say McDonald, but I much prefer Stevens. McDonald didn't do much to impress me over the NAB cup.

Have you seen much of Stevens play?, because I havn't, and hate picking guys on stats alone

 

[warney7]

Really had enough of this rookie business now

Ellis, Bugg (Mohr, Spurr)

Coniglio, Ledger (Sheil, Magner)

Giles (Stephensen, Redden)

Smith, Saad (Kennedy, Dickson)

 

[Molian]

Really had enough of this rookie business now

Ellis, Bugg (Mohr, Spurr)

Coniglio, Ledger (Sheil, Magner)

Giles (Stephensen, Redden)

Smith, Saad (Kennedy, Dickson)

GWS or North?
I think i know the answer...

 

[Souup]

Why arnt many people taking Cunningham? Is it because they think he'll be pushed out of the side once guys like O'Keefe and Shaw recover from injuries?

 

[Daniels]

Why arnt many people taking Cunningham? Is it because they think he'll be pushed out of the side once guys like O'Keefe and Shaw recover from injuries?

Yes. Plus probably SUB factor

 

[Ed_Gein]

Have you seen much of Stevens play?, because I havn't, and hate picking guys on stats alone

i considered him too. but the problem might be job security.

 

[Daniels]

the problem might be job security.

This

 

[MightyMark]

Have you seen much of Stevens play?, because I havn't, and hate picking guys on stats alone

He looked good in the NAB cup. Averaged 60 with limited game time compared to 44 for McDonald. There is a lot more improvement to be found in Stevens.

Sub factor could be an issue. But I don’t think it will be like Gaff last year. Stevens is a mature body so they won’t be trying to ease him in like Gaff.

 

[beev]

How many GWS rookies is everyone starting?

 

[tommyv49]

Is there any news on Neale, could work well with the VC partial lockout loophole. Taking a bit of a risk though

 

[Molian]

Just the one in my starting 22 (Bugg)
And i think ill name McDonald and Giles as emergencies.

 

[V23]

How many GWS rookies is everyone starting?

I have eight overall o) but am only starting five for round 1.

 

[SoupAStars]

Playing 6, starting 3.

 

[themightybloods]

What are people's opinions on the following players and their chances of playing (and scoring well). I need one in the midfield and one up forward


neale, c.smith, dickson, treloar

 

[Antz]

What are people's opinions on the following players and their chances of playing (and scoring well). I need one in the midfield and one up forward


neale, c.smith, dickson, treloar

Smith and Dickson are the ones I would be going for. Good luck.

Guys I am struggling at the moment. I am not sure who to go for between Shiel and Mcdonald. Who do you guys think?

 

[shaun1800]

Smith and Dickson are the ones I would be going for. Good luck.

Guys I am struggling at the moment. I am not sure who to go for between Shiel and Mcdonald. Who do you guys think?

Having the same problem myself, right now I'm starting Mcdonald, just because I figure Shiel has had an interrupted pre-season so I think there's a chance he might get subbed.