2012 SC Rucks

[MRB37]

You guys reckon Ivan Maric can keep up the good scores? Got another low BE this week so it's now or never for me to jump on him. I went with the Giles, Redden, Longer, Orren rucks which isn't working all that great for me ATM. If I trade Redden I got $514,800 free so I could afford guys like Ryder, McIntosh, Jacobs and Kreuzer also.

 

[Royale]

Started off with a cheap as chips ruck division in Maric, Giles, Stephenson and Redden. Maric has been outstanding given the price paid and the opposition he's faced including Cox/Nat. I think Maric is good enough to continue to score very well based on what he's done so far.

 

[Mattrox]

What is Mike Pyke's JS like? I'll need him to ruck round 10, 11 and 13 to be certain of bringing him in..... I guess I have to wait until thurs, to see if he is named to catch him on the bubble.

I guess I could play it safe and save the trade to before round 11..... Any price rise will still leave me plenty of cash to splash after the byes....

 

[MightyMark]

What is Mike Pyke's JS like? I'll need him to ruck round 10, 11 and 13 to be certain of bringing him in..... I guess I have to wait until thurs, to see if he is named to catch him on the bubble.

I guess I could play it safe and save the trade to before round 11..... Any price rise will still leave me plenty of cash to splash after the byes....

Pikes JS is looking pretty good at the moment, as Mumford still seems a fair way off 100%. I'd say if you didnt already get him and still want him for the bye rounds, it would be a safe bet.

 

[footyfan_25]

Naitanui is killing Cox SC scores ... bring back the weeks where Naitaniu missed and Cox scored 120-130

 

[MightyMark]

Naitanui is killing Cox SC scores ... bring back the weeks where Naitaniu missed and Cox scored 120-130

Should have traded NicNat in for Sandi.

Sigh...

Goldstein (with HMac returning in a few weeks) vs. Ryder (With Hille returning in a few weeks) vs. Griffin?

 

[footyfan_25]

Naitanui is killing Cox SC scores ... bring back the weeks where Naitaniu missed and Cox scored 120-130

Good 2nd half

 

[MightyMark]

Good 2nd half

NicNat still out scored him by more than 50 points

Why oh why, did I not bring him in for Sandi. Goldy your up son!

 

[GOAUS!]

Should have traded NicNat in for Sandi.

Sigh...

Goldstein (with HMac returning in a few weeks) vs. Ryder (With Hille returning in a few weeks) vs. Griffin?

I'm liking Griffin, does well when Sandi isn't around (averaged 100 last year) and is a fair bit cheaper than anyone else.

 

[celtic67]

Am having a massive dilemma with mine at the moment. Current rucks:
Cox Giles Stephenson & Pattison(R/F)
and Roughead in my forward line.

Who would everyone upgrade Giles to?

Ryder - I think he's too inconsistent
Maric - not really established and reckon he could struggle any week now
Natanui - don't wanna get carried away with last night's performance + already have Cox
Mumford & Sandi - don't trust either of their bodies

Please help!

 

[toxic]

Am having a massive dilemma with mine at the moment. Current rucks:
Cox Giles Stephenson & Pattison(R/F)
and Roughead in my forward line.

Who would everyone upgrade Giles to?

Ryder - I think he's too inconsistent
Maric - not really established and reckon he could struggle any week now
Natanui - don't wanna get carried away with last night's performance + already have Cox
Mumford & Sandi - don't trust either of their bodies

Please help!

Goldstein, Maric best only ruck options or swap roughhead into rucks and change pattison to Crozier from freo. You will need 3 rucks going fwd guaranteed - cox will be rested, giles will be rested and probably roughy rested too

 

[GOAUS!]

Am having a massive dilemma with mine at the moment. Current rucks:
Cox Giles Stephenson & Pattison(R/F)
and Roughead in my forward line.

Who would everyone upgrade Giles to?

Ryder - I think he's too inconsistent
Maric - not really established and reckon he could struggle any week now
Natanui - don't wanna get carried away with last night's performance + already have Cox
Mumford & Sandi - don't trust either of their bodies

Please help!

I wouldn't trust Sandi's body either, just reckon he's due for another injury . I would recommend either Griffin or Maric personally.

 

[The Swert]

Who would everyone upgrade Giles to?

Nobody, he's a keeper.

 

[ThePezDispenser]

Nobody, he's a keeper.

Unless his injured, luxury trade only!

 

[Double the Fist]

Anyone heard about the Mummy? Is he looking ok at the moment, I am wanting to trade Sandi for him. Can anyone suggest why I should or shouldnt get him?

Cheers

 

[rocker_oz33]

Anyone heard about the Mummy? Is he looking ok at the moment, I am wanting to trade Sandi for him. Can anyone suggest why I should or shouldnt get him?

Cheers

Big Mummy has a b/e of 191 might be 2-3 weeks away of match fitness/touch and better sc scores... thats my take.

 

[Double the Fist]

Big Mummy has a b/e of 191 might be 2-3 weeks away of match fitness/touch and better sc scores... thats my take.

Thanks for the input mate.

 

[charlez85642]

hi guys, does anyone know when Hmac is back? how is his recovery going?

 

[toxic]

hi guys, does anyone know when Hmac is back? how is his recovery going?

listed as 5-6 weeks i read somewhere

 

[Hawthorn United]

Estimated return of round 18.

 

[MightyMark]

Estimated return of round 18.

I hope thats right, I bought in Goldstein, so need HMac to stay out and let Goldy tear it up for a bit.

 

[TheBuzz]

With Sandi out, everyone is talking Griffin.

What about Zac Clarke? Will his output improve without Lurch hogging all the taps? Or will he still be predominantly a forward with Griffin purely taking the Sandi role.

I trawled through Zac's history & he's capable of the odd ton. I'm thinking at a 70k saving he might be value. Or am I nuts?

 

[MightyMark]

With Sandi out, everyone is talking Griffin.

What about Zac Clarke? Will his output improve without Lurch hogging all the taps? Or will he still be predominantly a forward with Griffin purely taking the Sandi role.

I trawled through Zac's history & he's capable of the odd ton. I'm thinking at a 70k saving he might be value. Or am I nuts?

I'd say nuts, but that said, none of my gambles have paid off this year

 

[Double the Fist]

I'd say nuts, but that said, none of my gambles have paid off this year

LOL priase your honesty

 

[rocker_oz33]

Campbell scored well in his first game pity big will only had one match ban campbell can play forward hope the dogs play him more could be a good dg.