2013 Player/s X versus Y

[Embleberry]

Keep Crouch or try for maybe Kommer/Jones or Biclavs??

Tough one. I think I might drop Crouch and look who's available next week. Hopefully Jones gets a game. With Biclavs it depends how many games you think he'll get. If he gets 4 or so and rises 60k then trade him out for Crouch if he's back by then. Would be an ok deal provided our situation...

Byrnes or Varcoe? Both will probably ave the same and hopefully rise to 375-415kish If Byrnes can achieve that I'll be happy. Fwd rookies are doing my head in, rather pay a premium for points lol

 

[tripple1zero]

need to stop making changes...pick 2 of these, L stevenson, colquhoun, Vlaustin

Stevenson and Vlastin - I am not confident Colquhoan will get consistent games.

 

[tripple1zero]

L.Brown vs N.Vlastuin

I'd go Brown since he is cheaper. I also put some confidence in Dangerfield picking him for his team (and not Crouch) - so maybe has some security.

 

[BuddysBuddy23]

Tough one. I think I might drop Crouch and look who's available next week. Hopefully Jones gets a game. With Biclavs it depends how many games you think he'll get. If he gets 4 or so and rises 60k then trade him out for Crouch if he's back by then. Would be an ok deal provided our situation...

Byrnes or Varcoe? Both will probably ave the same and hopefully rise to 375-415kish If Byrnes can achieve that I'll be happy. Fwd rookies are doing my head in, rather pay a premium for points lol

I'd go Varcoe and have. Will leave Crouch and Kommer out and hope Jones/Biclavs get a gig in week 2 of Rd 1

 

[Embleberry]

I'd go Varcoe and have. Will leave Crouch and Kommer out and hope Jones/Biclavs get a gig in week 2 of Rd 1

Yeah I'm thinking the same in regards to the rookies

Any love for Pettard or Harper?

 

[Donakebab]

Last minute, Jenkins vs Leuy vs Z.Smith

 

[GOAUS!]

Cotchin vs Selwood (Joel) ?

 

[Balony_pony16]

Dangerfield v Cassisi?

 

[eaglespremiers]

Dangerfield v Cassisi?

There's a fair difference in expected output there.

 

[Balony_pony16]

There's a fair difference in expected output there.

do you think cassisi can make 60?

 

[eaglespremiers]

do you think cassisi can make 60?

Have you already selected one of them?
Dangerfield will almost certainly average more than Cassisi regardless of last night.
Don't be so responsive.
Regardless I didn't select Dangerfield as a POD.
Instead I got J. P. Kennedy.

 

[Balony_pony16]

Have you already selected one of them?
Dangerfield will almost certainly average more than Cassisi regardless of last night.
Don't be so responsive.
Regardless I didn't select Dangerfield as a POD.
Instead I got J. P. Kennedy.

Jokes mate...Yeah Ill keep Dangerfield, although another bad preformance I would seriously look at a number of safer options I dont have like swan, peds, watson.

 

[SCchamp]

H.Shaw or Hartlett....final decision hopefully excluding rookies

 

[MightyMark]

H.Shaw or Hartlett....final decision hopefully excluding rookies

Shaw, he is a stalwart of defenders. Harlett will go down with injury fairly soon, he is just that type of player. Unlucky. As soon as he starts to get going, he goes down.

 

[pies21]

cloke or martin or krakour or sylvia?

 

[MightyMark]

cloke or martin or krakour or sylvia?

Martin. Has a lot more upside thn any of the others. Cloke could regain his best, but that still equates to poor consistency, same with most KPF

 

[SCchamp]

Swan and Hartlett V Cotchen and H.Shaw

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

Swan and Hartlett V Cotchen and H.Shaw

Cotchin and Shaw.

 

[Kadec]

I have a large group X vs Y vs Z, would really appeciate your thoughts

GROUP X
Backline: Watts
Midfield: Moloney
Ruck: Leuenberger
Forward: Roughead

GROUP Y
Backline: Vlastin
Midfield: JP Kennedy
Ruck: Leuenberger
Forward: Roughead

GROUP Z
Backline: Vlastin
Midfield: JP Kennedy
Ruck: Roughead
Forward: Khanezis


I really have no idea, unsure if i wanna take risks on leuey, khanezis or watts
appreciate the feedback.

 

[Judd_Magic]

I'd go group Z Kadec, just looks better balanced to me.

Here's my one.

Maric (R2), Karnezis (F5), Macaffer (F6)

vs

Leuenburger (R2), Zorko (F5), Macaffer (F6)


vs

Leuenburger (R2), Karnezis (F5), J.Kennedy (F6) with Macaffer on the bench.


* Would require me to burn 1 trade though by upgrading Neade or Spangher to Kennedy who are on my bench and then I would put Macaffer back on my bench.

My other forwrds are Franklin, Bartel, Rockcliff, Martin....

 

[BORK]

I'd go group Z Kadec, just looks better balanced to me.

Here's my one.

Maric (R2), Karnezis (F5), Macaffer (F6)

vs

Leuenburger (R2), Zorko (F5), Macaffer (F6)


vs

Leuenburger (R2), Karnezis (F5), J.Kennedy (F6) with Macaffer on the bench.


* Would require me to burn 1 trade though by upgrading Neade or Spangher to Kennedy who are on my bench and then I would put Macaffer back on my bench.

My other forwrds are Franklin, Bartel, Rockcliff, Martin....

If Macaffer does not get named option 3 would become a much easier pick. Being a carlton fan would like your insight on Kreuzer.

 

[BORK]

Bartel vs Kruezer/Goldstein? This would involve Luenberger on the bench for 1 week whether he is named or not. The extra cash would allow Selwood to turn into JPK and a possible a rookie upgrade.
Have Cox R1 and would start Rowe on forward bench to swap with Cox after round 1. If I chose Kreuzer your would think Rowe would play if he was out for a week.

 

[Judd_Magic]

If Macaffer does not get named option 3 would become a much easier pick. Being a carlton fan would like your insight on Kreuzer.

Kruezer's in for a big year I reckon under Malthouse.

Malthouse knows that Kruezer's best spot in the team is the number 1 ruckman and I think you'll see him do the majority of the ruck with Hampson pinch hitting from full forward.

Like Cox and Natinui Kreuzer plays a bit like a midfielder in the ruck with getting the ball out of the middle which will see him get increased possies to go along with his hitouts. good around the ground too although I reckon his kicking for goal could be a bit better at times.

Kruezer looks to be over the niggling injuries that he had last year too which is another plus.

Could be a good unique option to have as your ruck 2 I reckon.

 

[BORK]

Kruezer's in for a big year I reckon under Malthouse.

Malthouse knows that Kruezer's best spot in the team is the number 1 ruckman and I think you'll see him do the majority of the ruck with Hampson pinch hitting from full forward.

Like Cox and Natinui Kreuzer plays a bit like a midfielder in the ruck with getting the ball out of the middle which will see him get increased possies to go along with his hitouts. good around the ground too although I reckon his kicking for goal could be a bit better at times.

Kruezer looks to be over the niggling injuries that he had last year too which is another plus.

Could be a good unique option to have as your ruck 2 I reckon.

Have never selected him before but has been firmly on my radar for this year. I just have that gut feeling that has a decent record of being on the mark I would hope for a 105 average (or very close should he not reach it. E.G. 100 minimum) if I select him though. Would assume Rowe would replace him if injured or rested?

He would be R1 and Cox F2 with Luenberger R2.
Coz is R1 at this time but can swap. I guess it should be viewed as JPK and Kruezer( and an improved rookie should a 109k player not get named) vs Bartel and Selwood.

Plus greater ruck coverage flexibility.

 

[Zeno The Great]

Rockliff and Bartel v Roughead and Watts