List Mgmt. 2014 Draft Trade FA Megathread

[TheLastEmperor]

Oh Crap!!
I may have jumped the gun a little but my wife was half way through ironing Wines name on the back of my jumper :-(
Oh well, I guess 'WIN' across the back of my Saints jumper doesnt look too bad

Make it Winmar !

 

[Winmar2Lockett]

We aren't getting Wines so there won't be a dilemma.

Brian loves to start little fires... just like his McKenzie 12.51 agility test ripper

 

[Tragic sainter]

How embarrassing. I struggled to watch until the end.

I couldn't watch past 50 seconds.... You've got a stronger stomach than me!

 

[Barrels]

Rahul's gonna need a moment...

Bugger torching a mid-range pick on O'Shea... Take Hughie with a late one! 191cm shutdown defender, dripping leadership credentials, with elite speed? Yup. On it.

EDIT: his number (#8) is available too...

 

[12Chill]

we are last and things are a bit painfull at the moment, but thank christ we havent had to go through something like this yet:

omfg I couldn't stop laughing.

 

[Del152569]

we are last and things are a bit painfull at the moment, but thank christ we havent had to go through something like this yet:

LOL. One of the funniest things I have seen in a long time!

 

[daid2222]

I'd be wrapped if Petracca is as good as Wines.

Of course you would but Petracca could be a dud

YES. This is the type of deal I'd accept, which is obviously very unlikely to happen, but I'd take this deal.

I would take that deal, unlikely

Macrae is prob worth pick 1 on his own, just sayn'

True

We would never get 2&3 for Steven. Way way overs. Maybe one of them.

If we did get 1,2,3, I would trade three to Bulldogs for Macrae and pick 6 or whatever they have.

We would then have 1,2, and 6

Petracca,
McMartin
Macrae
pick 6 - take your pick of half a dozen

Macrae is worth more than pick 3 on his own

 

[SaintsSeptember]

If we were serious about trading Steven and Stanley would this happen?

Steven & Stanley to Collingwood
Beams to Brisbane
Merrett, Lumumba & Pick #21 to Melbourne
Pick #2 & Pick #5 to St.Kilda

Brisbane give up Pick #5 and Merrett for Beams
Collingwood give up Beams and Lumumba for Steven & Stanley
Melbourne give up Pick #2 for Merrett, Lumumba & Pick #21
St.Kilda give up Steven, Stanley and Pick #21 for Picks #2 and #5

*Got a little lost in this so may not make sense.

It makes sense for everyone except for stkilda, who would be making up the difference between what Collingwood think Beams is worth and what Brisbane think. Realistically the value of Steven isn't much different to Beams. Probably its higher because Beams "wants" to leave.

 

[Smoke_Me_AKipper]

Just chilling, watching Draft Day - getting in the mood for next week's shenanigans...

 

[Joffaboy]

Hmmm, Wines v Petracca, that would be an interesting dilemma! Think I'd probably want a little sweetener thrown in as well though.

Yup would have to be Wines and Gray

 

[Joffaboy]

we are last and things are a bit painfull at the moment, but thank christ we havent had to go through something like this yet:

Oh Jesus - The gifted Prince of Collingwood oops sorry Melbourne.

FFS

 

[Flandersss]

So we are trading Steven & getting Ollie Wines hmmm sounds reasonable but seriously have heard we are the front runners for Tim Membrey with a 3 year deal offered. I hope it's true as I rate Membrey & it would be cya later Arryn Siposs IMO. Unless we play him as a running back/wingman again.

 

[Periphery]

Why would we want Wines when we already have Dunstan? They play almost exactly the same role and recorded almost identical stats in their first seasons except Dunstan kicked twice as many goals in a much worse team and was more effective in his disposals while Wines got 1 more contested possession (they both had the same avg disposals @ 18.8).

Petracca and Dunstan > Dunstan and Wines.

 

[Bleeds_RWB]

I'm open to trading Steven and I'd call him a B+ Grader. Disposal lets him down

Coll - Steven
St Kilda - pick 4
Brisbane - beams

Then we keep 1 -petracca and 4- mccartin.

And since we're trading talent. Armo and simpkin for pick 11

Leaves us with 1,4,11,21

 

[Manimal_Dunstan]

Why would we want Wines when we already have Dunstan? They play almost exactly the same role and recorded almost identical stats in their first seasons except Dunstan kicked twice as many goals in a much worse team and was more effective in his disposals while Wines got 1 more contested possession (they both had the same avg disposals @ 18.8).

Petracca and Dunstan > Dunstan and Wines.

Heard Dunstan is on the table.

 

[Winmar2Lockett]

FFS we're not getting Wines! Brian you are a shit stirrer!

 

[TheLastEmperor]

Heard Dunstan is on the table.

I heard he's in the closet.

 

[Manimal_Dunstan]

I heard he's in the closet.

I heard he was eating to much toast for breakfast!

 

[Flandersss]

Why would we want Wines when we already have Dunstan? They play almost exactly the same role and recorded almost identical stats in their first seasons except Dunstan kicked twice as many goals in a much worse team and was more effective in his disposals while Wines got 1 more contested possession (they both had the same avg disposals @ 18.8).

Petracca and Dunstan > Dunstan and Wines.

Great point. Would be interesting to see how Wines goes in a bad team. I'm from Echuca & everyone is shocked at the impact his been able to make. Most people I know say I wonder how he would go in a crap team, so on that basis you would say Dunstan's got the runs on the board over Ollie. Wines shook the 2nd year blues of in a big way though having a no better second year then Judd I'm pretty sure, so it is interesting comparing the two..

 

[TheLastEmperor]

I heard he was eating to much toast for breakfast!

I heard he was feeling sluggish.

 

[Defacto]

Heard Dunstan is on the table.

theres not much room on the table with hiscox on there

 

[Manimal_Dunstan]

Interesting that Sydney apparently see us as the likely partner in a trade for Membrey and last night Longmire mentioned him in the departing players. So i'm going to read into both of those things along with the news last night etc and say he'll be a saint...... Deal may already be done just waiting for Monday.

 

[Plugger35]

Heard on 6PR this morning we're looking at trading pick 1 to GWS for two picks in the top 17, it was from Kim Hagdorn though so probably bullshit.

Not sure that would be a good deal, although if we still got a pick in the top 5 and another pick around the top 10 it might be worth it considering there is no real standout pick 1.

Cameron or Boyd and a pick in the top 17 would be a good deal but I don't think GWS would go for that.

Really wouldn't like us to trade Steven either unless we got an amazing deal for him, as a B&F winner he's a part of the fabric of the club.

 

[Defacto]

Heard on 6PR this morning we're looking at trading pick 1 to GWS for two picks in the top 17, it was from Kim Hagdorn though so probably bullshit.

Not sure that would be a good deal, although if we still got a pick in the top 5 and another pick around the top 10 it might be worth it considering there is no real standout pick 1.

Cameron or Boyd and a pick in the top 17 would be a good deal but I don't think GWS would go for that.

Really wouldn't like us to trade Steven either unless we got an amazing deal for him, as a B&F winner he's a part of the fabric of the club.

adam white said the same thing today on ABC grand stand

not sure if its accurate or him just reading the tea leaves

 

[AussieJones]

I could be completely off here, but who are the free agents we could target next year? Because that could drastically affect the compo pick we get for Steven (could have my FA info completely wrong) might be worth trading him now and getting max value.