2015 AFLCA Votes

[Kenny_01]

Fremantle vs Port Adelaide
10 Fyfe (Frem)
6 D. Pearce (Frem)
4 Mundy (Frem)
4 Wines (PA)
3 Pavlich (Frem)
2 Polec (PA)
1 Ebert (PA)

 

[Seppo]

WOW perfect 10 from Fyfe straight up.

I wonder if that translates to a brownlow vote or 2.

Im guessing it may go:
3. Pavlich
2. D.Pearce/Fyfe
1. Ebert/Wines/Mundy

 

[JamFrank]

Fyfe opens up a 10pt lead on Gray

 

[clogged]

10 point lead on Ablett too.

 

[UFO Tatsu]

WOW perfect 10 from Fyfe straight up.

I wonder if that translates to a brownlow vote or 2.

Im guessing it may go:
3. Pavlich
2. D.Pearce/Fyfe
1. Ebert/Wines/Mundy

I didn't really think Fyfe was BOG but it is an indication that Fyfe is going to score well in the Brownlow. If AFL doesn't find a way to suspend him and he can build up a decent lead on Ablett while he finds form, he has a very good chance to be our first Brownlow medalist.

BUT after last years result, I dunno if I actually want him to get one.

 

[electricfeel]

Every week I pray that Fyfe does not get suspended. I hope this is the year for him to win the Brownlow!

 

[Nickos66]

So that settles it - Ebert was BoG.

 

[purplerunsdeep]

Fyfe will get the votes over Ebert only because we won. Would be reversed if we lost.
To get 10 straight up - big. I didn't think he was BOG... umps even screwed him on that mark - guess they felt bad for him

Please fyfe stay out of trouble.......

 

[Kenny_01]

I thought Fyfe was BOG. His work rate and work in close was great. He won so many 1 on 1 contests. He ran back to help the defenders than ran forward to be a target. He changed the way Port defended when he went up forward.

Sometimes we expect so much from our champions that we mark them harder than others because we just expect brilliance.

 

[UFO Tatsu]

I thought Fyfe was BOG. His work rate and work in close was great. He won so many 1 on 1 contests. He ran back to help the defenders than ran forward to be a target. He changed the way Port defended when he went up forward.

Sometimes we expect so much from our champions that we mark them harder than others because we just expect brilliance.

No, I just thought Pav and D Pearce were better on the day.

 

[Scham]

Based on last years Brownlow result, I'd say Barlow would get the 3 votes.

 

[Fred Ziffel]

I didn't really think Fyfe was BOG but it is an indication that Fyfe is going to score well in the Brownlow. If AFL doesn't find a way to suspend him and he can build up a decent lead on Ablett while he finds form, he has a very good chance to be our first Brownlow medalist.

BUT after last years result, I dunno if I actually want him to get one.

I do.

 

[Fred Ziffel]

WOW perfect 10 from Fyfe straight up.

I wonder if that translates to a brownlow vote or 2.

Im guessing it may go:
3. Pavlich
2. D.Pearce/Fyfe
1. Ebert/Wines/Mundy

I had Nat as comfortable BOG.
After the stitch up by the AFL last year, I think even the umpires have a sense of injustice and Nat will get top votes for that game.

 

[Frank J Moose]

I had Nat as comfortable BOG.
After the stitch up by the AFL last year, I think even the umpires have a sense of injustice and Nat will get top votes for that game.

Fairness and injustice are not in an AFL umpires vocabulary.

Petty and narrow mindedly bias are the terms you are looking for.

 

[Fred Ziffel]

Fairness and injustice are not in an AFL umpires vocabulary.

Petty and narrow mindedly bias are the terms you are looking for.

I hear you but the umpires cast the votes . The corrupt actions to alter the outcome is the executive's work.

 

[Rob]

Good to know that 2 blokes that actually know what they're talking about also had Fyfe BOG. I thought I was going crazy reading through our votes and there were some not even giving Fyfe a vote. I don't know what bloody game they were watching.

 

[clogged]

There's also:

10 Fyfe (Frem) 5 + 5
6 D. Pearce (Frem) 3 + 3
4 Mundy (Frem) 4 + 0
4 Wines (PA) 0 + 4
3 Pavlich (Frem) 2 + 1
2 Polec (PA) 0 + 2
1 Ebert (PA) 1 + 0

 

[Alfonz]

Fremantle vs Port Adelaide
10 Fyfe (Frem) 5 + 5
6 D. Pearce (Frem) 4 + 2
4 Mundy (Frem) 0 + 4
4 Wines (PA) 1 + 3
3 Pavlich (Frem) 3 + 0
2 Polec (PA) 2 + 0
1 Ebert (PA) 0 + 1

One scenario for possible scores above, which matches below (grey is alternate). I'd be guessing that RTB gave the captain votes and had Pearce high (he always talks him up), maybe something like
Lyon - Fyfe / Pearce (Mundy) / Pavlich / Polec (Pearce) / Wines
Hinkley - Fyfe / Mundy (Pearce) / Wines / Pearce (Polec) / Ebert

 

[Alfonz]

There's also:

10 Fyfe (Frem) 5 + 5
6 D. Pearce (Frem) 3 + 3
4 Mundy (Frem) 4 + 0
4 Wines (PA) 0 + 4
3 Pavlich (Frem) 2 + 1
2 Polec (PA) 0 + 2
1 Ebert (PA) 1 + 0

Probably more likely actually. Hard to see Pavlich being snubbed by one coach. I wonder which coach would give Mundy votes?

 

[Banker]

As players get more media attention, the more easier to land brownlow votes.

Fyfe is pretty much rated the 2nd best player in the competition by everyone now, watch them umps give him votes every time Freo win.

 

[Vintage]

Fremantle vs Port Adelaide
10 Fyfe (Frem)
6 D. Pearce (Frem)
4 Mundy (Frem)
4 Wines (PA)
3 Pavlich (Frem)
2 Polec (PA)
1 Ebert (PA)

Dumb coaches are dumb

 

[Seppo]

Perfect 10 to Fyfe from Lyon and Scott:
10 – Nat Fyfe (Frem)
8 – David Mundy (Frem)
6 – Stephen Hill (Frem)
3 – Michael Barlow (Frem)
2 – Garrick Ibbotson (Frem)
1 – Michael Johnson (Frem)

Freo Overall:
20 Fyfe
12 Mundy
6 Hill
6 D.Pearce
3 Pavlich
3 Barlow
2 Ibbotson
1 Johnson

AFLCA CHAMPION PLAYER OF THE YEAR LEADERBOARD:
NAT FYFE – 20
DYLAN SHIEL – 19
JOSH KENNEDY (SYDNEY) – 16
KIEREN JACK – 14
TOM MCDONALD – 12
DAVID MUNDY – 12
RORY SLOANE – 12
DAN HANNEBERY – 11
MARCUS BONTEMPELLI – 10
PATRICK DANGERFIELD – 10
TODD GOLDSTEIN – 10
JOSH KENNEDY (WEST COAST) – 10
JORDAN LEWIS – 10
JEREMY MCGOVERN – 10
STEELE SIDEBOTTOM – 10
BRODIE SMITH – 10
TAYLOR WALKER – 10

 

[Nothing]

Good effort for Mundy with 12 out of a possible a 16 votes. Only Shiel has done relatively better.

 

[Kenny_01]

West Coast v Fremantle
10 Lachie Neale (Frem)
8 Stephen Hill (Frem)
5 Danyle Pearce (Frem)
3 Nat Fyfe (Frem)
2 Luke McPharlin (Frem)
1 Zac Clarke (Frem)
1 Garrick Ibbotson (Frem)

Fremantle Leaderboard
23 Fyfe
14 Hill
12 Mundy
11 D.Pearce
10 Neale
3 Pavlich
3 Barlow
3 Ibbotson
2 McPharlin
1 Johnson
1 Clarke

Overall Leaderboard
23 Nat Fyfe (Frem)
21 Rory Sloane (Adel)
20 Dan Hannebery (Syd)
19 Dylan Shiel (GWS)
17 Tom McDonald (Melb)
16 Cale Hooker (Ess)
16 Josh Kennedy (Syd)
15 Michael Hurley (Ess)
14 Stephen Hill (Frem)
14 Kieren Jack (Syd)

 

[Freodoc]

So, a poor week from Fyfe then... standards are dropping, lol!