2015; Player X or Player Y or Player Z

[Lums23]

Yeah just thinking he has gone to another level now though. Avg. 117 over his last 16 games, and scored 135 and 116 in the NAB. Hawks also have a very favourable draw before the bye. I really want both but need to get Gaz in now.

Maybe just go him then. Surely Wines won't go that well

 

[JohnnyDrama1]

Maric vs Nic Nat

 

[pill]

Hibberd(if cleared) vs Swan

 

[SnappyHappy]

Maric vs Nic Nat

I'm having the same debate within my team. I'm not as worried as some about Nic Nat's form against Freo, think he moved well enough and just did enough to get through the game, underdone though so might start the season slowly. Maric finished 2014 well and looked good against Goldstein, only worry with him is durability, similar concerns with Nic Nat tbh. At this stage I have Maric.

Hibberd(if cleared) vs Swan

I think Swan will get back over 100 so Swan easily for mine, can see Hibberd avg. 95 but Swan should outscore him.

 

[SnappyHappy]

Bennell v Buddy

 

[mike1234]

Newnes v luamambua

 

[scaryness]

Bennell v Buddy

Bennell right now. If Essendon players get suspended though I would be interested in starting Buddy just because his score in round 1 could be massive.

Newnes v luamambua

This is tough, I am taking Newnes but you could pick either. Both have high ceilings and risk attached (from what we have seen)

 

[kenneje]

M.Bontempelli + D.Sheed
VS
D.Swan + I.Heeney

 

[Benson FC]

M.Bontempelli + D.Sheed
VS
D.Swan + I.Heeney

Swan and Heeney, but bonti and cripps would make a better case

 

[scaryness]

M.Bontempelli + D.Sheed
VS
D.Swan + I.Heeney

Swan and Heeney, but bonti and cripps would make a better case

Ditto

 

[kenneje]

Swan and Heeney, but bonti and cripps would make a better case

Ditto

Cheers guys!

I've already got Cripps in my side, but I'll stick to Heeney and Swan then.

 

[Lums23]

Bennell v Buddy

Buddy by a very long way in my books

Newnes v luamambua

Get aboard the 6kg train (Newnes)

 

[SnappyHappy]

Lewis & Bennell

V.

Wines & Buddy

 

[Ashton Agar]

Lewis & Bennell

V.

Wines & Buddy

Wines and Buddy by the length of the Conrod Straight.

 

[Kk1ll]

Lewis & Bennell

V.

Wines & Buddy

Lewis and Bennell for mine.

Will be able to get buddy cheaper during the year and shouldn't outscore bennell by much overall imo.

Then lewis > Wines all day.

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

Selwood v Pendles

Treloar v Danger

JPK v Beams

 

[Kk1ll]

Selwood v Pendles

Treloar v Danger

JPK v Beams

Selwood v Pendles - Take your pick both consistent and guns

Treloar v Danger - Danger by a nose

JPK v Beams - Beams

 

[kenneje]

D.Martin v B.Deledio?

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

D.Martin v B.Deledio?

Dusty. On the up and hasn't missed a beat all pre-season.

Higher ceiling as well.

 

[scaryness]

D.Martin v B.Deledio?

Martin

 

[SnappyHappy]

D.Martin v B.Deledio?

Lids, I'll back him in to outscore Martin again who is yet to prove that he can play 4 quarters.

 

[Shakermaker94]

D.Martin v B.Deledio?

Deledio, just

Swan vs Bontempelli
Maric & Minson vs Goldstein & Nic Nat

 

[kangaroos3]

Deledio, just

Swan vs Bontempelli
Maric & Minson vs Goldstein & Nic Nat

Swan
Goldy & Nic Nat



Need to choose out of;
J. Gibson (D2), Wines (M4), Griffen (M5), Bartel (F2)
Or
Newnes (D3), Jelwood (M4), A. Swallow (M5), Dusty (F2)?

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

Lids, I'll back him in to outscore Martin again who is yet to prove that he can play 4 quarters.

I just traded Martin out and upgraded to Gray.

I feel like I'm the only one without him.

 

[Mercuri Rising]

Swan
Goldy & Nic Nat



Need to choose out of;
J. Gibson (D2), Wines (M4), Griffen (M5), Bartel (F2)
Or
Newnes (D3), Jelwood (M4), A. Swallow (M5), Dusty (F2)?

Flip a coin, but #2 maybe fractionally less risky.

Bont vs. Neale?