2015; Player X or Player Y or Player Z

[TheOz]

Disagree. Gonna be a gun.

Would take Newts over him though.

Newts doesn't look like he is capable of playing out a full game.

 

[hoddo]

Maric & Griffen or Danger & McEvoy?

Maric and Griffen

probably been answered 1000 times, but here it is again
Fyfe vs Selwood
please dont say "both"

Both are great selections, but Selwood's 133 average over his last 11 games gets him my vote ... then again, Fyfe averaged 129 over his last 11 games so, yeah ... both are great selections.

Taking price into consideration....

Wines V L. Parker V C. Ward?

Parker

Got enough money to upgrade one player, which one:
Naitanui -> Maric/Minson/Lobbe
Newnes/Lumumba -> Hibberd/someone similar
J.Anderson -> Newton (have Cripps too)
Swan -> Bennell
Griffen -> Parker/Lewis etc

I'm not sure some of those options are UPgrades. NicNat>Minson

Sheed vs Newton?

Neither. Sheed is overpriced for what he's likely to return and Newton's NAB matches make it look like he can't run out a full game and is likely to get a vest of some colour.

 

[scaryness]

probably been answered 1000 times, but here it is again
Fyfe vs Selwood

please dont say "both"

I have picked Fyfe.

I have never had Selwood in my team.

 

[JC Hawks]

K.Kolodjashnij or S.Higgins?

Edit: Money is tight but can work around it.

 

[Da Breust]

Newnes vs Lumumba

Reasons??

 

[scaryness]

Newnes vs Lumumba

Reasons??

I am picking Newnes because he is younger and is his career is continuing on an upward trajectory. Lumumba has been around for a long time and hasn't been much of a SC performer, so you would really only pick him because of what he might do at a new club (a new club which might struggle).

Tough choice.

 

[the bee sharps]

Geary and Goldstein or Higgins and Minson

 

[Determinant]

I am picking Newnes because he is younger and is his career is continuing on an upward trajectory. Lumumba has been around for a long time and hasn't been much of a SC performer, so you would really only pick him because of what he might do at a new club (a new club which might struggle).

Tough choice.

For me O'Brien is preseason fairy dust, wouldn't pick him over Zac Dawson.

 

[Flandersss]

For me O'Brien is preseason fairy dust, wouldn't pick him over Zac Dawson.

To far lol.

I can't stand the "prince" but an 80+ avg is very realistic IMO.

 

[Determinant]

To far lol.

I can't stand the "prince" but an 80+ avg is very realistic IMO.

Possibly, but I prefer KK at a cheaper price

 

[Flandersss]

Possibly, but I prefer KK at a cheaper price

So do I.

"Prince" an ok option I guess.

 

[Hoges64]

Taking price into consideration....

Wines V L. Parker V C. Ward?

Parker

Parker

Ok, that's good, was leaning towards him.

So Wines v Griffen then?

 

[toxic]

Geary and Goldstein or Higgins and Minson

Higgins and Minson

 

[hoddo]

So Wines v Griffen then?

Griffen easily. He's fantastic value based on what he's already shown he can do. Wines may be good value based on what he might do.

 

[MicCheck12]

Griffen or Wines is killing me - currently have Wines....HALP.

Also..Gibson/ Smith/ Burgoyne/ Simpson?

Thanks All..

 

[_M_16_]

Boak, Parker or A. Swallow?

 

[Kadog]

I see all the new drive by posters are popping in a week out getting their easy quick fix for help. You'll never hear from them again either.

Completely ignore other posts to help or give input.

Reminds of those at school who study & do the hard yards only for lazy shitheads to ask for the answers in the exam room.

Do your fn research and participate in this forum....otherwise fook off as far as I'm concerned.

 

[scaryness]

Boak, Parker or A. Swallow?

Parker

 

[rocker_oz33]

Agreed Kadog that needs to be said in rate my team thread.the mods should put something up the top of thd srceen or something.

 

[rocker_oz33]

But I'm all for new peeps joining in.

 

[Kadog]

But I'm all for new peeps joining in.

Absolutely. Read & contribute.

 

[SnappyHappy]

Rank the Freo defenders in order of highest avg. to lowest (nominate what you think they will average if you feel like it too).

Ibbotson v Johnson v Sutcliffe

 

[Kadog]

Rank the Freo defenders in order of highest avg. to lowest (nominate what you think they will average if you feel like it too).

Ibbotson v Johnson v Sutcliffe

MJ 95
Ibbotson 85
Sutcliffe 75

 

[spangleduck]

Boak, Parker or A. Swallow?

Swallow for me mate, offers great value. He could either become a keeper, or at the least a stepping stone to get Gaz.

 

[spangleduck]

Ok, that's good, was leaning towards him.

So Wines v Griffen then?

Griffen. I'm expecting (hoping?) he'll start really strongly at GWS. While he's only averaged over 110 once (over 116 in 2013) he has been a nip under 110 a couple of times and I think there's a good chance he can approach those numbers again. Both players have the R13 bye which can help in upgrading over the byes if they don't quite reach premium status.