Remove this Banner Ad

2015; Player X or Player Y or Player Z

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Ibbotson 90-95
Johnson 85-90
Suttcliffe 75-80
MJ will average more than Ibbotson. Bookmark it.
In fact, MJ will be in top 8 defenders imo.
 
Dangerfield Cripps vs
Rockliff Jed Anderson

Danger & Cripps.

I don't think Rockliff will have the output he did last year, at least I think he will drop in price first.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

What do people think of playing Z Clarke in the forward line as ruck cover?

Does he have any up side potential this year as a player who is improving, or are we better to wait for somebody like ryder who will almost certainly drop in price?
 
Lumumba v Newnes v Higgins
Newnes
What do people think of playing Z Clarke in the forward line as ruck cover?

Does he have any up side potential this year as a player who is improving, or are we better to wait for somebody like ryder who will almost certainly drop in price?
Nope unless Sandilands gets injured
 
Hibberd vs Birchall vs Kelly
Not taking into account ASADA stuff, if they are banned then will obviously pick out of Kelly and Birchall

and
Selwood and Parker vs Beams and JPK
 
Last edited:
Hibberd vs Birchall vs Kelly
Not taking into account ASADA stuff, if they are banned then will obviously pick out of Kelly and Birchall
Birchall suffered a knee injury and hasn't had much of a preseason, doubt he'll play round 1, might even miss more
Upgrade target after his bye
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Who are you guys taking between Bartel/Martin/Franklin?

Ive got Bartel atm but leaning towards Buddy.
Bartel, can play anywhere on the ground and still score 100+, been playing alot more through the Geelong midfield this pre-season meaning higher scores if this role continues. Franklin is more of an upgrade target for me. Martin vs Deledio is another one I haven't entirely decided on yet.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Dangerfield Cripps vs
Rockliff Jed Anderson

Danger and Cripps.

Rocky is slightly overpriced IMO and Anderson may find himself in and out of the side.

Lumumba v Newnes v Higgins

Newnes.

Prince could end up playing back again and resort to his old ways pretty quickly and Higgins could go down at any moment, and even if he doesnt wont have as big a ceiling as Newnes.

Might be a stupid question.

Heater & Goodes

V

Lumumba & Ibbotson

Heater and Goodes.

Shaw is the only consistent premo back thats left, may have a brain fade but could also recapture the ton average. Goodes is looking good and will be important in such a young team.

Who are you guys taking between Bartel/Martin/Franklin?

Ive got Bartel atm but leaning towards Buddy.

Ive got Franklin, but im watching closely to make sure he is 100%, he could go huge.
 
MJ will average more than Ibbotson. Bookmark it.
In fact, MJ will be in top 8 defenders imo.

I tend to agree here but I'm a bit skeptical of his nab scores. Ie. Nab 1 he scored 50 DT 111 SC. That's a big discrepancy, doesn't sound right. Nab 2 a similar result. He was averaging 98 prior to his injury last year though.
 
Judd vs Sammy Mitchell

Just want a nice price rise over the first few weeks - then upgrade to super premo.
 
Hibberd & Salem (F4)

vs

Bartel & Hamling (D7, Moving Saad to D6)
I'd go Hibberd and Salem.
Jimmy will ave more than Hibberd but Salem should score plenty more then Hamling and will appreciate more and quicker. All this obviously depends on ASADA.

Goodes + Cripps + Mumford* + Gray*
Vs
Newnes* + Heeney + Lobbe* + Bennell* + $35k
* indicates planned keeper. Option 2 will be one less upgrade to my final team.
What do you guys think they will average?

Thanks guys really appreciate any help.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top