Mega Thread 2015 Training Reports

[Simmofreo]

Dawson is aliability imo, him being out is good for us. Showed nothing in that GWS game. I'd rather have Taberner or Mayne back there.

Against Kennedy and darling. Yep me too

 

[FreoRicci]

Dawson is a liability imo, him being out is good for us. Showed nothing in that GWS game. I'd rather have Taberner or Mayne back there.

No thanks. Mayne gets beaten 70% of the time down back. Besides the GWS showed absolutely nothing from ALL players not just Dawson. Crap game all round. Dawson holds players like Hawkins, Tippett etc like a glove. He does have the overreliant to handball but compare that to Luke Mac kicking (hasn't been elite this season.. at all.).

 

[Freoforever86]

Dawson is a liability imo, him being out is good for us. Showed nothing in that GWS game. I'd rather have Taberner or Mayne back there.

Thought he was solid for his first game back. Pretty important for our structure. His blocking off the ball & 3rd man up spoiling is excellent.

 

[FreoRicci]

Does Pav and Macca train fully these days? Know sandi doesn't either. Ross probably playing dukes and drakes , as per usual

 

[Wizard]

No thanks. Mayne gets beaten 70% of the time down back. Besides the GWS showed absolutely nothing from ALL players not just Dawson. Crap game all round. Dawson holds players like Hawkins, Tippett etc like a glove. He does have the overreliant to handball but compare that to Luke Mac kicking (hasn't been elite this season.. at all.).

The dislike towards Zac is stupid. Hes a VERY key part of our team.

 

[Stuart88]

Thought he was solid for his first game back. Pretty important for our structure. His blocking off the ball & 3rd man up spoiling is excellent.

From what I could see he was getting lost up the field while Cameron was doing whatever he wanted. Put our defense under unnecessary pressure on more than one occasion (having to try and cover for him being missing).

 

[Stuart88]

The dislike towards Zac is stupid. Hes a VERY key part of our team.

We have gotten to 16-2 without him, how is he a VERY key part of our team?

 

[Wizard]

We have gotten to 16-2 without him, how is he a VERY key part of our team?

Yep, we're a better team with him.

 

[elsleevador]

Pav-50%
Macca-75%
Johnno-99%
Fyfe-110%
Sos-? 60%
Would have thought with the forecast good that tabs would be in 25 if pav was out

 

[Stuart88]

Pav-50%
Macca-75%
Johnno-99%
Fyfe-110%
Sos-? 60%
Would have thought with the forecast good that tabs would be in 25 if pav was out

We might be covered for height with Griffin, Pearce & Mayne there?
Does Mundy look fine?

 

[apuchar]

what's happened to SOS?

 

[FreoRicci]

Pav-50%
Macca-75%
Johnno-99%
Fyfe-110%
Sos-? 60%
Would have thought with the forecast good that tabs would be in 25 if pav was out

Then Fyfe at full forward is probably the go

 

[Freoforever86]

Pav-50%
Macca-75%
Johnno-99%
Fyfe-110%
Sos-? 60%
Would have thought with the forecast good that tabs would be in 25 if pav was out

Tabs can still come straight into the team if Pav is out but. Will be interesting to see if he plays WAFL tomorrow

 

[go_the_dockers]

what's happened to SOS?

I think he just pulled up sore from last game. I am guessing if he plays this week, he will rest next week.

 

[ozzie69]

Then Fyfe at full forward is probably the go

Fyfe at full forward, APearce at CHF - spine of the future?

 

[apuchar]

Fyfe at full forward, APearce at CHF - spine of the future?

Ross said the other day that Fyfe is headstrong and has made it clear he wants to be predominantly a midfielder who goes forward occasionally. Interesting that. Where does the coaches will end and the players will start?

 

[UFO Tatsu]

We have gotten to 16-2 without him, how is he a VERY key part of our team?

Having Dawson in the team allows MJ to be the loose man. We are 16-2 because Ibbotson is doing a good job in the role as well.

 

[Purpletown]

Thought he was solid for his first game back. Pretty important for our structure. His blocking off the ball & 3rd man up spoiling is excellent.

He is our best available and fit key backman ready to come in and give Luke a rest and he has a brain fart and gets rubbed out for 2 weeks???? If he is important to our set up or not is overshadowed by the stupid stuff he does. A severe test of loyalty from my BF Buddy to keep talking him up. I will have to evaluate my support for him in the off season before taking him on again for 2016.

Might help my love for him if he handed out a bit of biffo in the GF and gave some treatment to Roughead or Gunston. Even better if he could knee Mitchell in the thigh (accidentally naturally)

 

[apuchar]

He is our best available and fit key backman ready to come in and give Luke a rest and he has a brain fart and gets rubbed out for 2 weeks???? If he is important to our set up or not is overshadowed by the stupid stuff he does. A severe test of loyalty from my BF Buddy to keep talking him up. I will have to evaluate my support for him in the off season before taking him on again for 2016.

Might help my love for him if he handed out a bit of biffo in the GF and gave some treatment to Roughead or Gunston. Even better if he could knee Mitchell in the thigh (accidentally naturally)

Can be hard to be a buddy sometimes.

 

[MadDocker]

You don't deserve him. I've been whispering sweet nothings in his ear all season. I'll show him how a real buddy treats his... buddy in 2016.

 

[Sweetback]

He is our best available and fit key backman ready to come in and give Luke a rest and he has a brain fart and gets rubbed out for 2 weeks???? If he is important to our set up or not is overshadowed by the stupid stuff he does. A severe test of loyalty from my BF Buddy to keep talking him up. I will have to evaluate my support for him in the off season before taking him on again for 2016.

Might help my love for him if he handed out a bit of biffo in the GF and gave some treatment to Roughead or Gunston. Even better if he could knee Mitchell in the thigh (accidentally naturally)

I'd be happy if Dawson just lined up Mitchell from the get-go and got four weeks for it, ALA that campaigner Lake and his high hit on Sonny.

 

[ozzie69]

I'd be happy if Dawson just lined up Mitchell from the get-go and got four weeks for it, ALA that campaigner Lake and his high hit on Sonny.

And have Mitchell forever remembered like Dermot after the 1989 GF shirtfront?

 

[downthecorridor]

The dislike towards Zac is stupid. Hes a VERY key part of our team.

Respectfully disagree.

 

[Sweetback]

And have Mitchell forever remembered like Dermot after the 1989 GF shirtfront?

We have different concussion rules these days.

 

[Steinfreo]

If you hate Dawson your a freagle. Tabs and Mayne instead of Dawson. Its like you want us to lose.