2016 trade hypotheticals

[Sirlemsip]

Would rather keep Murdoch and GHS than get those two picks, tbh....

While Murdoch and GHS can't break into the team you may as well take two picks that would have a reasonable chance of turning into similar quality players, with the upside of getting a bargain and the 'risk' of having slightly less injury coverage.

 

[CasuallyDressed]

My spies have informed me this deal is very much over the line . Just the I's to be dotted and the T's to be crossed . I do not care about any abuse that may follow because its all about opinion on how everything is weighted & will not post again on this issue

Hawthorn #
Receive - Jaeger O'Meara (GC) and 2nd Round pick (GC)
Lose - 1st Round Pick (GC) and Bradley Hill (GC)

Gold Coast #
Receive - Stephen Hill (Fre) and Michael Barlow (Fre)
On trade 1st Round Pick (From Haw) to Fremantle

Fremantle #
Receive - Rory Lobb (GWS) and Cameron McCarthy (GWS)
Lose - On traded 1st round pick from (Haw - GC) and Round 3 pick (Fre)

GWS #
Receive - 1st round Pick (Haw - GC - Frem) and 3rs round pick (Fre)
Lose - Roory Lobb and Cameron McCarthy (Fre)

 

[Laverde]

I would give up pick 1 in a heartbeat for lobb

 

[grouse mate]

This thread, jeezus.

Carlton think Marchbank is worth a second rounder yet they price Touhy as a first and Freo think Lobb and McCarthy are worth picks 16 and 57.
The internet wasnt invented for this.

 

[WilloTree]

EFA[/QUOTE]

First round pick (Hawthorn), McCarthy (Fremantle), Barlow (GC Suns), Brad Hill (exits current plane of existence).

 

[Pure_Ownage]

Kersten for Ed Langdon (Freo)
Murdoch and Horlin Smith for pick 27&40 (GCS)
Vardy for James Stewart (GWS)

Fair?

The first and the third are fair.

Second one i think is a little bit in geelongs favour.

If it was murdoch and hs for 2 picks in the 40s thats fair although both are contracted so geelong can hold out for more (unlike kersten who is uncontracted).

 

[TigerTime99]

My spies have informed me this deal is very much over the line . Just the I's to be dotted and the T's to be crossed . I do not care about any abuse that may follow because its all about opinion on how everything is weighted & will not post again on this issue

Hawthorn #
Receive - Jaeger O'Meara (GC) and 2nd Round pick (GC)
Lose - 1st Round Pick (GC) and Bradley Hill (GC)

Gold Coast #
Receive - Stephen Hill (Fre) and Michael Barlow (Fre)
On trade 1st Round Pick (From Haw) to Fremantle

Fremantle #
Receive - Rory Lobb (GWS) and Cameron McCarthy (GWS)
Lose - On traded 1st round pick from (Haw - GC) and Round 3 pick (Fre)

GWS #
Receive - 1st round Pick (Haw - GC - Frem) and 3rs round pick (Fre)
Lose - Roory Lobb and Cameron McCarthy (Fre)

OMFG do your spies have eyes??? And why the ***k do u have spies??
Honestly I'm glad you post again on the issue because that is the biggest load of crap ever.
By any chance are you Damien Barrett??

 

[King Patty]

Mega trade

Essendon Lobb, 10
Gws, Pick 1, 22
Fremantle McCarthy
Gold Coast Barlow,
Stkilda Marchbank

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Mega trade

Essendon Lobb, 10
Gws, Pick 1, 22
Fremantle McCarthy
Gold Coast Barlow,
Stkilda Marchbank

Gold Coast lose that so bad...

Essendon massive winners from that!

 

[Ron]

Mega trade

Essendon Lobb, 10
Gws, Pick 1, 22
Fremantle McCarthy
Gold Coast Barlow,
Stkilda Marchbank

Seems like every trade put up it ends with GWS getting screwed over hard. This one is no different.

 

[Colonial]

Mega trade

Essendon Lobb, 10
Gws, Pick 1, 22
Fremantle McCarthy
Gold Coast Barlow,
Stkilda Marchbank

Lobb wont go to Essendon

If, IF, he leaves its for WA.

And we get screwed on the trade as well


So no.

Sent from my SM-G920I using Tapatalk

 

[raymagoo]

This is horrendous

I come here for a lol possibly only one decent hypothetical in 12 pages I've read! Guessing these guys are all 12 or stupid


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[citizen-erased]

Lobb wont go to Essendon

If, IF, he leaves its for WA.

And we get screwed on the trade as well


So no.

Sent from my SM-G920I using Tapatalk

ill say. would set us up.
10 could be any one of our depth requirements.
Lobb finishes off our 22.
If we land Jaeger on top of that, our list profile would be spot on for a challenge.

no chance. We should have gotten into Lobb last year.
Only target i think we can/will get from you guys will be Barrett.

 

[KohPhi]

This thread, jeezus.

Carlton think Marchbank is worth a second rounder yet they price Touhy as a first and Freo think Lobb and McCarthy are worth picks 16 and 57.
The internet wasnt invented for this.

Try reading through some of the crazy shit on our board!
Marchbank worth a late first rounder IMO. Either Blues trade one in, or trade Pick 5 for 2 later first rounders and use 1 on Marchbank.
I'd prefer to keep 5 and look to bring one in personally..

 

[SumTingWong]

Mega trade

Essendon Lobb, 10
Gws, Pick 1, 22
Fremantle McCarthy
Gold Coast Barlow,
Stkilda Marchbank

wtf??

 

[Colonial]

Pick 10 to GWS might be a bit more realistic

Still off.

Sent from my SM-G920I using Tapatalk

 

[sonnywalters]

Kersten for Ed Langdon (Freo)
Murdoch and Horlin Smith for pick 27&40 (GCS)
Vardy for James Stewart (GWS)

Fair?

This is the AFL trade thread. Not VFL.

 

[sonnywalters]

Mega trade

Essendon Lobb, 10
Gws, Pick 1, 22
Fremantle McCarthy
Gold Coast Barlow,
Stkilda Marchbank

That would be a big win for Essendon and a loss for everyone else.

 

[HavUEvaSeenTheRain]

To be fair you only have to look at some actual trades that have happened in the past and some of these hypertheticals don't seem so bad.

 

[onebillsdrive]

Straight swap Eric Mackenzie for Hayden Ballantyne

 

[TheEnsign]

Mega trade

Essendon Lobb, 10
Gws, Pick 1, 22
Fremantle McCarthy
Gold Coast Barlow,
Stkilda Marchbank

Marchbank not worth 10. Throw in Laverde with next year's second rounder from St Kilda coming back and will take it.

 

[Kunna17]

Straight swap Eric Mackenzie for Hayden Ballantyne

I don't see freo interested in Mckenzie tbh mate as Dawson/Johnson will be playing on as older KPD and we're supposed to be looking at a rebuild ...

 

[JADED]

Rumours abound,
Geelong - Deledio
Richmond - Motlop

 

[SumTingWong]

w

Rumours abound,
Geelong - Deledio
Richmond - Motlop

hat else do we get?

 

[Suma Magic]

Straight swap Eric Mackenzie for Hayden Ballantyne

I'd hope not. I'd prefer to keep our 4th best KPD than bring in a 4th best small forward.