Analysis 2017 List Management Discussion Part II

[Stiffler's Dad]

wow bigfooty is bleak today

Where did I leave those bloody double edged razor blades?

Shit gotta fly, my warm bath is about to overflow - hate to ruin the carpet in the hallway!

 

[HARKER]

Nothing has changed for me in the past three weeks.
Still feel the same way about how we're going to go about things

That's going to start shifting soon enough, when noises start getting louder.

 

[bigm386]

Bye bye!

I am FAR FAR from a Rowe fan, but don't have to be so excited about it.

Can't say he didn't serve the club to the best of his ability. :/

 

[reubsblues]

My wish list
Keep Gibbs
Keep Jones
Keep kreuzer
Keep Casboult
Get kelly using our own picks
Wouldn't mind Saad or Jones
Not fussed if we didn't get hopper

 

[Dr Trade]

Did anyone else here Sam McClure (after the McKay interview) say if he leaves it will be to Carlton.

Anyone confirm?

Yep confirmed, that is what McClure said. Looks like Josh Kelly is Carlton bound and SOS will make this happen.

 

[agro]

Yep confirmed, that is what McClure said. Looks like Josh Kelly is Carlton bound and SOS will make this happen.

I'm thinking it's a lock too, given none of the main stream media even want to mention it now.

Because basically they really can't stand the fact that we've got him in the bag.

They're too busy telling us our list is no good (5 Rising Star Nominations), that Patrick Cripps is going back to Western Australia.

 

[RoyalParade]

Appreciate your insight, but i dont think Rowe is gone come seasons end.

Would only be a club with a shit culture that would do that.

Maybe us about 2 - 3 years ago.

Rowe will be handy enough for another season at least, either fill in in defence, forward or depth in the two's. i for one would be filthy if they cut him this year.

Totally agree.

I think it is admirable what rowe has been able to achieve. He deserves his spot.

 

[F_therest]

Yep confirmed, that is what McClure said. Looks like Josh Kelly is Carlton bound and SOS will make this happen.

Well he said IF he leaves it would be us...still a chance he stays at gws so not a lock.

And as we know, no such thing as a lock at this point of the year things can change between now and trade week just like tomlinson and Carlisle.

 

[ESKIE]

Getting way ahead of ourselves here re Kelly people...

 

[HBF]

Yep confirmed, that is what McClure said. Looks like Josh Kelly is Carlton bound and SOS will make this happen.

Damn I should have listened for a bit longer, but had to get into work.

 

[Benaly28]

T

Well he said IF he leaves it would be us...still a chance he stays at gws so not a lock.

And as we know, no such thing as a lock at this point of the year things can change between now and trade week just like tomlinson and Carlisle.

ThNk Christ we didn't get that flog that is Carlisle and Tomlinson is very similar to plowman.

 

[F_therest]

T

ThNk Christ we didn't get that flog that is Carlisle and Tomlinson is very similar to plowman.

Yeah I've mentioned before that in hindsight we are lucky we missed out on Carlisle, Tomlinson and prestia.

They would have cost a fair bit at trade table and $$$, Carlisle in particular is a flog and we don't need him and tomlinson since our current kpds are just as good if not better...plus younger and better blokes.

 

[maxyblue]

Yeah I've mentioned before that in hindsight we are lucky we missed out on Carlisle, Tomlinson and prestia.

They would have cost a fair bit at trade table and $$$, Carlisle in particular is a flog and we don't need him and tomlinson since our current kpds are just as good if not better...plus younger and better blokes.

Not to mention that we wouldn't have Charlie if the Tomlinson trade had gone through ...

 

[cookie monster]

Wasnt the rumour at the time that we actually cooled on Carlisle and not tell other way round? Think SOS thought he was just a money hungry flog.is it turns out he's actually a money hungry drug cheat flog

 

[F_therest]

Wasnt the rumour at the time that we actually cooled on Carlisle and not tell other way round? Think SOS thought he was just a money hungry flog.is it turns out he's actually a money hungry drug cheat flog

Nah rumour was just that saints came in later with a much better offer

 

[Pafloyul]

My wish list
Keep Gibbs
Keep Jones
Keep kreuzer
Keep Casboult
Get kelly using our own picks
Wouldn't mind Saad or Jones
Not fussed if we didn't get hopper

Sigh... the old fortification strategy teams up with the messiah complex once again.

 

[passmark]

Bye bye!

Bit shit.

 

[passmark]

Getting way ahead of ourselves here re Kelly people...

Wonder what number he wants ?

Marchbank already has 22 and Jesus Jones has his dad's old number 14.

 

[TerryWallet]

Yep confirmed, that is what McClure said. Looks like Josh Kelly is Carlton bound and SOS will make this happen.

If i could give people 2 pieces of life advice, they would be:

1) Don't pee into the wind.

2) Don't listen to a word professional clickbait artists like Maclure, Stevens, Browne, Cornes etc say. They know nothing.

 

[F_therest]

Sigh... the old fortification strategy teams up with the messiah complex once again.

Trading in Kelly is nothing like a 'messiah complex'...not even close.

No one is saying Kelly will carry us, he will just be a gun midfield youngster in a team full of other gun youngsters.

 

[ODNBlue]

Wonder what number he wants ?

Marchbank already has 22 and Jesus Jones has his dad's old number 14.

I suspect 7 might be available...

 

[HBF]

Getting way ahead of ourselves here re Kelly people...

I see what you're saying, but there's only 7 weeks to go of the H&A season, and he still hasn't signed.
There's enough noise around the place to suggest we're well and truly in the frame when it comes to getting him to Carlton.

 

[ESKIE]

In the frame? I haven' read anything to confirm he is Carlton bound

Yes he hasn't signed but there are other clubs in the frame as well

We need to cool our jets, IIRC Tomlinson was a lock too

 

[Andypooh23]

Wonder what number he wants ?

Marchbank already has 22 and Jesus Jones has his dad's old number 14.

#2 - Josh Kelly

 

[GapInIkonPark]

#2 - Josh Kelly

That's Ben's number ...