I'll take back my ''dislike''. It's actually a good call. McGrath has copped some heat, but you're right, not a lot.McGrath avoids the spotlight just as much
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
LIVE: Port Adelaide v Carlton - 7:30PM Thu
Squiggle tips Port at 63% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Round 12
The Golden Ticket - MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
I'll take back my ''dislike''. It's actually a good call. McGrath has copped some heat, but you're right, not a lot.McGrath avoids the spotlight just as much
They have both slid under the radar massivelyI'll take back my ''dislike''. It's actually a good call. McGrath has copped some heat, but you're right, not a lot.
Agree Richards is very underrated. Very good half back.Raynor at half back over Richards is a laughable take,
No current season stats available
Which of the following 4 player do you put him in front of in a redraft?Don't care how biased it sounds, but Dylan Moore is top 10 if you do a redraft.
Has become the heart and soul of our footy club.
For me: De Koning, Balta, Miers (50/50) and KellyWhich of the following 4 player do you put him in front of in a redraft?
Taylor
Naughton
Brayshaw
Fritsch
Allen
Cerra
DeKoning
Miers
Mihocek
Kelly
Baker
Balta
Davies-Uniacke
Which of the following 4 player do you put him in front of in a redraft?
Taylor
Naughton
Brayshaw
Fritsch
Allen
Cerra
DeKoning
Miers
Mihocek
Kelly
Baker
Balta
Davies-Uniacke
Which of the following 4 player do you put him in front of in a redraft?
Taylor
Naughton
Brayshaw
Fritsch
Allen
Cerra
DeKoning
Miers
Mihocek
Kelly
Baker
Balta
Davies-Uniacke
Miers
Miohcek
Baker
De Koning
Balta
On exposed form that wasn't too difficult.
He's been more consistent for a longer period of time than all those players, perhaps minus Mihocek.
Hasn't had the same team success as Baker or Miers, but if you compare career statistics Moore is ahead in the majority of categories.
From scratch I could see all those players minus Miers or Baker being taken first because they are taller, athletic types.
So is the question where would be rank on what we've seen or if you were still drafting on player potential?
De Koning in particular still has further to potentially rise IMO.
Baker and Balta were both top 10 in Richmond's B&F in 2020 when Moore was struggling to get a game.
Miers has played every game when fit since the start of 2019 in some very good teams whereas Moore didn't become a regular until 2021 in a poor team.
He's a good player and you can argue he's better but it's just wrong to say he's been more consistent for longer than those players.
He averaged 15 disposals in 2021.(Moore) Was the only player other than Marcus Bontempelli to average 20 touches and a goal over the two season period of 2021 and 2022.
He averaged 15 disposals in 2021.
And you would still be wrong, which I suspect you know.I believe the stat was over a 2 season period. If I'm incorrect in that then it was definitely the case for 2022. Just Dylan and Bont.
And you would still be wrong, which I suspect you know.
Cumulatively during 2021 and 2022 he averaged 17.88 disposals, not the 20 you stated.
Plus, if you were quoting the two years as an aggregate you would have included Petracca, who averaged 28.6 disposals and kicked 48 goals through 2021-22, but you correctly didn't include him because he only kicked 19 goals in 2021, which fell short of your 20 goal criteria.
Just admit you &^%^&$# up your stats and got it wrong.
So now you're only talking about one year when your whole premise was a two year period.I literally said 'If I'm incorrect then it was definitely for 2022'.
I don't know how much more ownership I need to take for a statical error.
So now you're only talking about one year when your whole premise was a two year period.
Go back to the drawing board.
No chance. 1.7 goals a game for a contender.Miohcek
Yep. Miers another ahead of Moore.Baker and Balta were both top 10 in Richmond's B&F in 2020 when Moore was struggling to get a game.
Miers has played every game when fit since the start of 2019 in some very good teams whereas Moore didn't become a regular until 2021 in a poor team.
He's a good player and you can argue he's better but it's just wrong to say he's been more consistent for longer than those players.
Yep. Another ahead of Moore.Zach Bailey would be ahead of Moore as well. Do really rate Dylan though just a tough top 10 to crack
Come on now. Your continued non rating of Miers is baffling enough but Dylan Moore ahead of Tim Kelly.Kelly
I hate the Hawks as much as anyone but Tim Kelly has had two excellent years at Geelong and four average ones at West Coast.No chance. 1.7 goals a game for a contender.
Yep. Miers another ahead of Moore.
Yep. Another ahead of Moore.
Come on now. Your continued non rating of Miers is baffling enough but Dylan Moore ahead of Tim Kelly.
Not even close.
No chance. 1.7 goals a game for a contender.
Yep. Miers another ahead of Moore.
Yep. Another ahead of Moore.
Come on now. Your continued non rating of Miers is baffling enough but Dylan Moore ahead of Tim Kelly.
Not even close.
Elaborate on this with a defined period and statistics.One year or two doesn't change the fact that Dylan Moore shared an impressive run of form with Marcus Bontempelli and no other player.
Elaborate on this with a defined period and statistics.
I suggest you take a closer look at Kelly in WCE. Not really average at all.I hate the Hawks as much as anyone but Tim Kelly has had two excellent years at Geelong and four average ones at West Coast.
Also saying that Miers (who I do rate, by the by) is neck and neck with Moore isn't an insult. Both are very good small forwards.
How do we know anything of leadership qualities for people not exposed to it? He could have leadership capabilities and they're untapped. He could have none.Miers has been part of a stronger side and done a fantastic job of making a career of being quite a unique player for a small forward.
But he isn't as dynamic as Moore as a footballer and doesn't have the same leadership capabilities. If we are talking about who goes first in a redraft then these qualities would be taken into account.
Statistically over their careers Moore leads in almost every category.
Dylan Moore and Gryan Miers AFL Stats Comparison
Dylan Moore and Gryan Miers AFL Stats Comparison.www.footywire.com