Position 2017 Rookies

[Super Hans]

Seems like English is in the box seat for round one. Even though he'll probably go out of the team pretty soon Bev has shown he doesn't really care who you are and will play whoever is in form.

 

[GRUFFY]

Seems like English is in the box seat for round one. Even though he'll probably go out of the team pretty soon Bev has shown he doesn't really care who you are and will play whoever is in form.

 

[Glorin]

I got him, I think he can average 60-70
In his and your dreams. He will pull out one decent game SC a year which may drag his ave up to 50-55.
A stop gap only if there are no other fwd rookies.

 

[Double the Fist]

I got him, I think he can average 60-70


I just need 6-7 straight games, then I'll cull his arse. I think he'll be best 22 for the first half of the year at least.

6-7 straignt games may take 3/4s of a year judging by his durability
Made of tissue paper?

 

[shotgun_blues]

Have I missed something? Why doesn't everyone have Shoenclangers?

Playing forward in his favourite CHF position, however he does get better with every game so if he plays a full JLT3 and named Rd. 1 he will definitely be either my F6 or F7. With Gunston, Roughy & Vickery taking 3 good backmen he could get off the chain for a couple of games. Has averaged 72 playing at CHF over decent blocks of games, and rewatch the 2015 GF. Killed it at CHF.

I'm expecting a 70-80 average early on. Easily 70+. Seriously.

 

[Thuggee_Cult]

Playing forward in his favourite CHF position, however he does get better with every game so if he plays a full JLT3 and named Rd. 1 he will definitely be either my F6 or F7. With Gunston, Roughy & Vickery taking 3 good backmen he could get off the chain for a couple of games. Has averaged 72 playing at CHF over decent blocks of games, and rewatch the 2015 GF. Killed it at CHF.

I'm expecting a 70-80 average early on. Easily 70+. Seriously.

Hawthorn have Essendon, Gold Coast, Saints , Melbourne and Brisbane in the first 7/8 games. It wouldn't surprise me if he kicked 3-4 against Essendon

 

[KenTucker]

According to the Adelaide board, he is a massive chance.

What about Gallucci?

 

[toxic]

Hawthorn have Essendon, Gold Coast, Saints , Melbourne and Brisbane in the first 7/8 games. It wouldn't surprise me if he kicked 3-4 against Essendon

Schoenmakers
If he plays chf

Hurley
May
Carlisle
T.McDonald

He'll be lucky to kick 4 in total

 

[adammania9]

Schoenmakers
If he plays chf

Hurley
May
Carlisle
T.McDonald

He'll be lucky to kick 4 in total

Any club coach who would send their best defender to Schoenmakers would be sacked on the spot.

I don't have him but if he plays CHF, I think he can average 60-70 but that's not really enough for me; I'd rather take a rookie who could go better.

 

[toxic]

Any club coach who would send their best defender to Schoenmakers would be sacked on the spot.

I don't have him but if he plays CHF, I think he can average 60-70 but that's not really enough for me; I'd rather take a rookie who could go better.

Its two fold.

Send TMac for example to Schoenmakers and TMac becomes a 3rd man up option.
Sending a gun def to an average attacker is also an agressive coaching move

 

[freddy mercury]

Schoenmakers
If he plays chf

Hurley
May
Carlisle
T.McDonald

He'll be lucky to kick 4 in total

I am that confident he wont kick more than 1 we will leave him spare man in the forward line.

 

[HereIam86]

SC 588512

 

[pincrusher]

SC 588512

Your ranking last year???

 

[InFiction]

6-7 straignt games may take 3/4s of a year judging by his durability
View attachment 342226Made of tissue paper?

It's not durability, he was just always in and out on form/team structure. I don't expect that to change this year, especially with Ruff back. Huge pass for me!

 

[The Lemon]

Clangermakers is a spud. Avoid.

 

[scaryness]

Clangermakers is a spud. Avoid.

This is true.

I've never known someone to have the word 'clanger' in their nickname and be a great player.

 

[Obese Arachnid]

View attachment 342202

I would choose English, unfortunately my first language is bollocks.

 

[KardiniaPark]

Schoenmakers
If he plays chf

Hurley
May
Carlisle
T.McDonald

He'll be lucky to kick 4 in total

LOL.

 

[Lums23]

This is true.

I've never known someone to have the word 'clanger' in their nickname and be a great player.

Clangerfield...

 

[Underarm]

Taranto's had a couple of good games, will he break into the GWS side early on?

 

[The Lemon]

Taranto's had a couple of good games, will he break into the GWS side early on?

Seems Hopperish to me. Will get a big one, then disappoint.

 

[The Lemon]

Clangerfield...

Dangergod gets +4 for clangers.

 

[Beedub]

Fo

Taranto's had a couple of good games, will he break into the GWS side early on?

for the same price bracket I think blokes such as Swallow and Melksham in the midfield or the likes of McCartin or McCarthy in the forward line have much better job prospects and could go just as big at times

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Fo

for the same price bracket I think blokes such as Swallow and Melksham in the midfield or the likes of McCartin or McCarthy in the forward line have much better job prospects and could go just as big at times

KPP as rookies are a big no for me .....prefer a Hoskin Elliott playing on the wing

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Taranto's had a couple of good games, will he break into the GWS side early on?

Could you actually drop him on his two games to date ? .....it'll depend on his 3rd game