2018 Rate My Team (Post JLT)

[tpcrispy]

Hey guys, any ideas/thoughts would be greatly appreciated - 2nd year so still pretty new to this.

 

[Flandersss]

Was it lock Hurn at D1?

 

[Jcpdragonx]

Hey guys, any ideas/thoughts would be greatly appreciated - 2nd year so still pretty new to this.

Without considering its your second year its pretty good.

Hanley has missed 20 games in 3 seasons and has been nowhere near what he used to be since 2014, not a fan.

Ryder is a bit risky because we don't know if we have D3 for his r10 bye, and if we do then its probably going to be a 30-60 score (similar scoring to guys like Mason Cox and Ivan Soldo).

I think Christensen is a dud pick, missed a year, sleeps with teammates partners and is awkwardly priced. I'd go Sicily>Fwd line for Christensen, add Coffield/Naughton down back and upgrade Zorko/Oliver/Titch to King Patrick.

 

[Jcpdragonx]

I'm just not sure about anything yet. Some feedback on this side would be much appreciated. View attachment 461186View attachment 461187

On [device_name] using BigFooty.com mobile app

Like the Gov pick

Lobb has to go, he isn't playing JLT and is in doubt for R1. D.Smith is playing midfield this year and I think he'd be a good replacement.

 

[Jcpdragonx]

Post-AFLX V.1

Looks pretty strong but very Lycett dependent. If Lobb is out for a while I like Dawson Simpson as a replacement.

I think you've overspent in defense, apart from McDonald there is no value there. I'm not sure where you'd spend the extra cash though. Perhaps for some expensive rookies in defense as at this stage (Coffield, J.Smith, O'Brian, Naughton). Doesn't look likely we'll have many cheap def rookies.

 

[Jcpdragonx]

My latest iteration. A bit of risk but the upside is HUGE! $93.6K in the bank.
View attachment 460928

Rookies are set in jelly at the moment - will look at locking based on JLT form.

Defenders
If Aliir Aliir gets a fair bit of ruck time in JLT he will be coming in possibly for Wilson.

Midfield
Pretty happy with my selections here - others in the mix for M5 and M6 are Cripps and Coniglio but think the upside of Rocky and JOM much greater than the music factory (C&C).

Rucks
Ruck line has been the one that I have cogitated over more than any other line. Gawn is locked and loaded and I've decided on Sandi at R2 as he seems to be tracking well in pre-season, he's publicly stated he wants to play every game and there is an injury concern with Sean Darcy. I just want him on the park and scoring for 10 rounds then look at upgrading to Ryder or the best available ruck.

Forwards
Heeny locked and key thrown away. Job security and upside of lunch meat and Curnow looks to be huge and Simpkin will play every game for North - will be closely watching his JLT for SC scoring.

Thoughts people?

Interesting. Like Curnow, not sure I have the balls to pick him.

Burton's a gun but will apparently play deep defense which means less rebounding and intercepts.

I wouldn't touch Rockliff. I was listening to Adelaide Radio in January and Rockliff was on, and he mentioned his shoulder is a bit of an issue even months after surgery. It's a Gary Ablett type job. He can't tackle with confidence, I don't see him scoring well at all. He didn't lay more than four tackles in a single game since his injury, whereas before he had a couple 10+ tackle games. And this is before considering how many other injuries he has had.

 

[Flandersss]

Will probably get a game earlyish.....

Coffield, Cumming, Collins, Cole, Doedee, Finlayson, Goddard, Hibberd, Keeffe, Mirra, Murray, Smith, Rice, O'Connor, Willis, Guthrie

Questionable JS and less likely to start early......

Buckley, Eagles, Johnson, Richards, Redman, Smith, Dear, Frost, Hewett, McLarty

Coffield/Goddard unlikely.

B: Geary Brown Webster
HB: Roberton Carlisle Savage
C: Sinclair Armitage Acres
HF: Billings McCartin Weller
F: Gresham Bruce Membrey
R: Longer Ross Steven
I: Dunstan Steele Newnes Gilbert

 

[tpcrispy]

Without considering its your second year its pretty good.

Hanley has missed 20 games in 3 seasons and has been nowhere near what he used to be since 2014, not a fan.

Ryder is a bit risky because we don't know if we have D3 for his r10 bye, and if we do then its probably going to be a 30-60 score (similar scoring to guys like Mason Cox and Ivan Soldo).

I think Christensen is a dud pick, missed a year, sleeps with teammates partners and is awkwardly priced. I'd go Sicily>Fwd line for Christensen, add Coffield/Naughton down back and upgrade Zorko/Oliver/Titch to King Patrick.

Cheers for the information, with Ryder I was going to blow 2 trades for his r10 bye - assume this isn't a good play?

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Hey guys, any ideas/thoughts would be greatly appreciated - 2nd year so still pretty new to this.

Still probably know as much as us .....but it's good to get a 2nd opinion

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Interesting. Like Curnow, not sure I have the balls to pick him.

Burton's a gun but will apparently play deep defense which means less rebounding and intercepts.

I wouldn't touch Rockliff. I was listening to Adelaide Radio in January and Rockliff was on, and he mentioned his shoulder is a bit of an issue even months after surgery. It's a Gary Ablett type job. He can't tackle with confidence, I don't see him scoring well at all. He didn't lay more than four tackles in a single game since his injury, whereas before he had a couple 10+ tackle games. And this is before considering how many other injuries he has had.

Did i hear that he reached for his shoulder in a recent internal trial ??

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Cheers for the information, with Ryder I was going to blow 2 trades for his r10 bye - assume this isn't a good play?

I'd suggest if you want Ryder ......put another Ruckman in till R11, then put Ryder in ......that's only one trade, and maybe his price is a bit lower by then

 

[Double the Fist]

View attachment 461228
First Crack.

Thinking of going J. Kelly to an Oliver or T Mitch; alternatively downgrade to Cogs and upgrade a few rookie or a premo. Lobb and a few other campaigners pending JLT/round 1 selection. Not liking Laird this year as he may get a lot of work put into him.

Poholke ahead of Gallucci? I'd pay the difference because I think y ou will see more of the Lucci!

 

[WaynesWorld19]

View attachment 461228
First Crack.

Thinking of going J. Kelly to an Oliver or T Mitch; alternatively downgrade to Cogs and upgrade a few rookie or a premo. Lobb and a few other campaigners pending JLT/round 1 selection. Not liking Laird this year as he may get a lot of work put into him.

You Adelaide supporters have a fascination with McGovern ....haven't seen him in many sides, particularly those of WC supporters ?

1. Lots of debate about O'Meara as a M6 .....absolutely no discussion as a M5

2. How do you replace your Gold Coast players for the China game (Rnd 10) ?

3. Lobb has been injured a lot of the PS .......dangerous to consider

4. Wigg also injured

5. Get one more true Premo mid

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Poholke ahead of Gallucci? I'd pay the difference because I think y ou will see more of the Lucci!

Big wraps on Poholke, very highly rated .....Gallucci will play as a small forward, Poholke as a true mid, and likely to be the better scorer

Knight now being injured "may" open the door for a Poholke?

 

[Double the Fist]

Big wraps on Poholke, very highly rated .....Gallucci will play as a small forward, Poholke as a true mid, and likely to be the better scorer

Knight now being injured "may" open the door for a Poholke?

I guess whoever is chosen rnd 1.
Interesting. Ta

 

[Jcpdragonx]

Did i hear that he reached for his shoulder in a recent internal trial ??

Someone said that on the port board

 

[Jcpdragonx]

Cheers for the information, with Ryder I was going to blow 2 trades for his r10 bye - assume this isn't a good play?

Trades are gold, not a good play at all

 

[Mitchell54]

Burton's a gun but will apparently play deep defense which means less rebounding and intercepts.

Where have you heard this?

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Where have you heard this?

I haven't heard anything about a specific role yet for Burton .....i'm sure the Coach would be interested to hear ?

 

[atlas1]

View attachment 461286

This is just as good as the Kony emoji

 

[scarrgo]

Ok.
Want to try with a heavy starting midfield but not totally sold on D4 set up.
Not fully sold on NicNat and Christensen.

 

[Hai_Newman]

Coffield/Goddard unlikely.

B: Geary Brown Webster
HB: Roberton Carlisle Savage
C:

This is just as good as the Kony emoji

 

[St BKD]

Like the Gov pick

Lobb has to go, he isn't playing JLT and is in doubt for R1. D.Smith is playing midfield this year and I think he'd be a good replacement.

Lobb?

On [device_name] using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Jcpdragonx]

Lobb?

On [device_name] using BigFooty.com mobile app

Oops

Greene has had an interupted pre season though

 

[crow77]

Let us know what you think people. .